WEBVTT

00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:00.000


00:01:11.367 --> 00:01:13.367
GOOD MORNING POINT WELCOME TO TUESDAY, DECEMBER FIFTH

00:01:16.900 --> 00:01:18.900
FOR THE SUPERVISORS MEETING POINT WILL CALL, PLEASE.

00:01:20.867 --> 00:01:22.867
>> SUPERVISOR GALLAGHER . --

00:01:23.633 --> 00:01:25.633
HERE POINT [ INAUDIBLE -LOW VOLUME ] CHAIR GREGORY.

00:01:27.733 --> 00:01:29.733
--

00:01:30.233 --> 00:01:32.233
>> AT THIS TIME, I WILL INVITE SHERIFF ORTIZ

00:01:33.600 --> 00:01:35.600
TO LEAD US IN THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE.

00:01:36.633 --> 00:01:38.633
>> I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE

00:01:44.433 --> 00:01:46.433
TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS

00:01:48.433 --> 00:01:50.433
ONE NATION UNDER GOD INDIVISIBLE WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL.

00:01:52.433 --> 00:01:54.433
>> THIS

00:02:04.367 --> 00:02:06.367
IS THE CUTEST, CUTEST FANCIEST LITTLE VISITOR WE HAVE

00:02:10.367 --> 00:02:12.367
EVER HAD. TODAY'S PET OF THE WEEK IS SCOTT.

00:02:16.367 --> 00:02:18.367
HE IS STILL AVAILABLE FOR ADOPTION, DESPITE MY MANY ATTEMPTS TO

00:02:19.367 --> 00:02:21.367
GET US IN OFFICE CAT. SHE LOVED

00:02:25.367 --> 00:02:27.367
ROAMING AROUND THE OFFICE TODAY.

00:02:29.367 --> 00:02:31.367
AND OUR SHELTER MANAGER KATIE IS GOING TO TELL US A LITTLE MORE ABOUT SCOTT AND

00:02:34.667 --> 00:02:37.100
I'M GOING TO CUDDLE.
>> SO

00:02:40.367 --> 00:02:42.367
MS. SKYE CAME TO US WHEN A NAPA CITY RESIDENT WAS GOING

00:02:46.367 --> 00:02:48.367
INTO AN ASSISTED CARE FACILITY AND CAN NO LONGER CARE FOR SKYE. SHE

00:02:51.367 --> 00:02:53.367
IS AROUND 11 YEARS OLD AND SHE WEIGHS A WHOPPING 14 POUNDS OF LOVE. SHE

00:02:55.367 --> 00:02:57.367
IS AN ABSOLUTE SWEETHEART AND THAT EVERYBODY

00:02:58.367 --> 00:03:00.367
SHE MEETS . SHE WOULD PREFER TO BE THE ONLY CAT IN THE HOUSEHOLD.

00:03:01.300 --> 00:03:03.300
YES, SHE IS ABSOLUTELY SWEET AND HAS BEEN

00:03:04.300 --> 00:03:06.300
BACK IN THE OFFICE, JUST PURRING AWAY.

00:03:10.300 --> 00:03:12.300
>> [ LAUGHTER ] >> SHE HAD

00:03:16.300 --> 00:03:18.300
A PREVIOUS INJURY IN HER YOUNGER YEARS THAT HAS HEALED. SO HER

00:03:22.300 --> 00:03:24.300
BACK LEG IS A LITTLE BIT WONKY. SHE GIVES A PRETTY STRAIGHT

00:03:25.300 --> 00:03:27.300
MOST OF THE TIME, BUT IT IS NOT WHETHER HER WHATSOEVER. DOES

00:03:28.300 --> 00:03:30.300
NOT SLOW HER DOWN. SHE IS LOOKING OUT A HOME

00:03:32.300 --> 00:03:34.300
TO LIVE OUT HER GOLDEN YEARS. THIS IS MS. SKYE.

00:03:37.300 --> 00:03:39.300
CURRENTLY, UNTIL FURTHER NOTICE, WE ARE WAIVING ALL
ADOPTION FEES AT THE SHELTER BECAUSE WE ARE A CRITICAL CAPACITY POINT ALL

00:03:45.300 --> 00:03:47.300
ANIMAL ADOPTIONS WILL BE WAIVED UNTIL FURTHER NOTICE. IF YOU WANT TO COME
DOWN AND WE ARE AT NINE 14 HUDDLE CORPORATE

00:03:52.300 --> 00:03:54.300
THIS IS AT PHONE NUMBER 707 --20. SHE DOES LOVE

00:03:58.300 --> 00:04:00.300
TO PURR.

00:04:01.233 --> 00:04:03.233
I WAS HOPING I COULD GET HER PURRING.

00:04:10.233 --> 00:04:12.233
>> OH, A QUICK UPDATE DUKE FROM LAST WEEK, ANYBODY THAT

00:04:16.233 --> 00:04:18.233
THOUGHT, HAS BEEN ADOPTED. YES!

00:04:19.233 --> 00:04:21.233
[ APPLAUSE ] HE WAS ACTUALLY ADOPTED

00:04:24.233 --> 00:04:26.233
BY A FAMILY MEMBER OF MINE. I GET TO SEE THEM ALL

00:04:27.233 --> 00:04:29.233
THE TIME. IF ANYBODY ELSE WANTS TO JOIN THE CLUB ,

00:04:31.233 --> 00:04:33.233
FEEL FREE. IT HAS BEEN PRETTY GOOD. THANK YOU SO MUCH.

00:04:43.233 --> 00:04:45.233
THANK YOU, SKYE, AND KATIE, FOR JOINING US

00:04:46.233 --> 00:04:48.233
BUT AGAIN, ALL ADOPTION FEES ARE BEING WAIVED RIGHT NOW. IF YOU KNOW SOMEONE THAT MIGHT

00:04:49.233 --> 00:04:51.233
BE INTERESTED, SEND THEM THAT CUTE PICTURE AND THE

00:04:55.233 --> 00:04:57.233
LITTLE LINK TO SKYE PURRING.

00:05:01.167 --> 00:05:03.167
>> BLACK WAS PROBABLY THE WRONG COLOR TO

00:05:13.167 --> 00:05:15.167
WEAR UP TOP TODAY. WE DO NOT HAVE ANY PRESENTATIONS,

00:05:16.167 --> 00:05:18.167
PROCLAMATIONS OR PRESENTATIONS BUT FOR OUR CONSIDERATION TODAY

00:05:19.167 --> 00:05:21.167
, AN ARCHITECT CALENDAR FOR SPECIAL DISTRICTS

00:05:25.167 --> 00:05:28.167
WE HAVE ONE ITEM. ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS BY
THE BOARD ? THING NONE, I WILL TAKE PUBLIC

00:05:31.167 --> 00:05:34.167
COMMENT ON 5A POINT THINK NONE IN THE
BOARDROOM, AND ANY ON THE PHONE LINES?

00:05:38.167 --> 00:05:41.133
I WILL BRING IT BACK TO THE BOARD FOR
DISCUSSION AND DECISION.

00:05:41.367 --> 00:05:44.133
>> SECOND. >> EMOTION AND A SECOND BY
SUPERVISOR COTTRELL. ALL IN FAVOR?

00:05:44.767 --> 00:05:46.767
>> AYE.

00:05:47.167 --> 00:05:49.167
>> THE MOTION PASSES IN MAN ASLEEP. ON THE

00:05:53.167 --> 00:05:55.167
CALENDAR, ITEM 6A THROUGH T PER THERE'S A CORRECTION

00:06:01.100 --> 00:06:03.100
--A REQUEST TO DISCUSS BY THE BOARD?

00:06:05.100 --> 00:06:07.100
THING NONE, I WILL OPEN PUBLIC COMMENT.

00:06:08.100 --> 00:06:10.100
THIS IS ON PUBLIC COMMENT 6A THROUGH T.

00:06:14.100 --> 00:06:17.100
OH, SORRY. I WILL GO TO THE PHONE LINES.
>> DONE ON THE LINE.

00:06:19.100 --> 00:06:22.100
>> OUTPOST PUBLIC, TO BRING IT BACK TO
THE BOARD FOR DISCUSSION AND DECISION.

00:06:23.100 --> 00:06:25.100
>> EMOTION BY --AND A SECOND

00:06:29.100 --> 00:06:32.100
BY SUPERVISOR GREGORY. ALL IN FAVOR?
>> AYE . >> OPPOSED? THE MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. NEXT, WE HAVE

00:06:37.100 --> 00:06:40.100
PUBLIC COMMENT THAT IS FOR ALL MATTERS NOT LISTED IN
THE AGENDA, BOTH IN THE JURISDICTION OF THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS

00:06:43.100 --> 00:06:45.100
AND THE SPECIAL DISTRICTS . PUBLIC COMMENT

00:06:46.100 --> 00:06:49.100
IS LIMITED TO GO THREE MINUTES AND WE
HAVE OUR PODIUM UP FRONT. I WILL NOW OPEN PUBLIC COMMENT.

00:06:56.100 --> 00:06:58.100
>> GOOD MORNING. JIM HINTON .

00:07:02.100 --> 00:07:04.100
45 SPRING STREET , NAPA, CALIFORNIA.

00:07:07.100 --> 00:07:09.100
RECENTLY I'VE BEEN ASKING A LOT OF QUESTIONS ABOUT THE

00:07:10.100 --> 00:07:12.100
TAX ENTERPRISE THAT IS KNOWN AS VISIT NAPA VALLEY.

00:07:14.100 --> 00:07:16.100
IT SEEMS EVEN THOUGH IT IS SUPPOSED TO BE A

00:07:17.100 --> 00:07:19.100
TRANSPARENT ORGANIZATION FUNDED BY TAX DOLLARS OR WHATEVER YOU

00:07:23.100 --> 00:07:25.100
WANT TO CALL IT, THEY SEEM TO NOT BE ACCOUNTABLE ON ANYTHING. NOBODY

00:07:26.100 --> 00:07:28.100
SEEMS TO KNOW HOW THEY SPEND THE MONEY.

00:07:30.100 --> 00:07:32.100
ASK A SIMPLE QUESTION LIKE HOW MUCH DOES THE CEO MAKE. IT SEEMS

00:07:35.100 --> 00:07:37.100
TO BE LIKE IT IS OFFENDING PEOPLE YOU SHOULD

00:07:38.100 --> 00:07:41.100
ACTUALLY ASK SUCH A QUESTION.
IT APPEARS THEY ARE MAKING OVER SOME OF HER IN

00:07:44.100 --> 00:07:46.100
--750,000 PER YEAR ACCORDING TO SOME DOCUMENTS PEOPLE

00:07:47.100 --> 00:07:49.100
HAVE SENT ME.

00:07:50.100 --> 00:07:52.100
YOU HAVE THE POWER. THERE IS A DISTRICT MANAGEMENT PLAN THAT CLEARLY OUTLINES

00:07:53.100 --> 00:07:55.100
HOW IT CAN COLLECT THE MONEY AND HANDED OVER TO THEM.

00:08:02.330 --> 00:08:04.330
AT IS 5% FOR THIS, 10% FOR THIS, 20% FOR THIS BUT

00:08:05.330 --> 00:08:07.330
IT IS CLEARLY OUTLINES. IT IS NOT UP FOR THEM TO SPEND IT HOWEVER THEY WANT

00:08:08.330 --> 00:08:10.330
TO SPEND IT THAT IS NOT WHY IT IS BROUGHT IN . PEOPLE ARE

00:08:11.330 --> 00:08:13.330
BEING TAXED WHETHER THEY WANT TO BE OR NOT.

00:08:15.330 --> 00:08:18.330
THE MAJORITY OF HOTELS WANT TO DO IT SO EVERYBODY HAS TO COLLECTED AND
THE ONLY REASON THAT IS LEGAL IS BECAUSE THERE

00:08:20.330 --> 00:08:22.330
IS A DOCUMENT IN PLACE

00:08:26.330 --> 00:08:28.330
THAT HAS SPECIFIC GUIDELINES ON HOW THEY HAVE TO SPEND

00:08:29.330 --> 00:08:32.330
THE MONEY SO THESE PEOPLE TO GET THE RETURN THEY ARE SUPPOSED TO GET.
THERE ARE RUMORS CIRCULATING THAT THE HOTELS NOW

00:08:35.330 --> 00:08:37.330
ARE NOT HAPPY.
THERE IS NOBODY SLEEPING AND THEIR RIGHT NOW. THERE ARE RUMORS THAT THE

00:08:40.330 --> 00:08:43.330
HOTEL IS ARE MAYBE GOING TO GET RID OF --
WHICH I THINK WOULD BE WONDERFUL.

00:08:44.330 --> 00:08:46.330
BUT THEY NEED TO GET SOMEBODY IN THERE WHO IS WILLING TO DO THE JOB

00:08:49.330 --> 00:08:51.330
AT A REASONABLE SALARY. THERE IS NO REASON WHY SOMEBODY WENT TO AN INSTAGRAM

00:08:53.330 --> 00:08:55.330
PAGE SHOULD MAKE MORE THAN OUR CEO OR OUR CITY ATTORNEY OR

00:09:04.967 --> 00:09:06.967
SHE IS MAKING ABOUT WHAT ALL THREE OF THEM MAY COMBINE AND SHE IS RUNNING

00:09:07.967 --> 00:09:09.967
AN INSTAGRAM PAGE. SO THE ONLY REASON THEY ARE GETTING THAT 2% IS BECAUSE YOUR TOD

00:09:10.967 --> 00:09:12.967
IS SO LOW AND MAKES IT EASY FOR THEM TO TAKE IT. OUR COMMUNITY

00:09:15.967 --> 00:09:17.967
WOULD BE BETTER SERVED IF YOU WOULD RAISE THE

00:09:22.967 --> 00:09:24.967
TOT BY 2% AND USE THAT MONEY TO FUND OUR PARKS AND TO MAKE

00:09:27.967 --> 00:09:29.967
NAPA VALLEY BETTER FOR THE COMMUNITY AND ESPECIALLY THE KIDS

00:09:31.967 --> 00:09:33.967
THAT OF NO RETURN ON INVESTMENT FROM ALL THE WINE TASTING ROOMS

00:09:34.967 --> 00:09:36.967
AND ALL OF THAT KIND OF STUFF. THEY GET NOTHING BACK ON

00:09:37.967 --> 00:09:39.967
THIS TOT HARDLY AT ALL, UNLESS YOU COUNT THEM HAVING BETTER ROADS

00:09:43.967 --> 00:09:45.967
OR MORE SHERIFFS OR FIRE SOMEHOW TO BENEFIT.

00:09:46.967 --> 00:09:48.967
THERE IS NOTHING FOR THEM TO DO IN THIS TOWN. THAT IS WHY OUR

00:09:50.967 --> 00:09:53.967
HIGH SCHOOLS WILL BE CLOSING UP. THAT IS WHY FAMILIES, YOU KNOW, THEY ARE
GETTING OUT OF HERE . NOBODY IS RAISING KIDS

00:09:55.967 --> 00:09:57.967
OR ANYONE. THERE'S NOTHING AND DRINKING. AND EXPENSIVE FOOD.

00:10:04.900 --> 00:10:06.900
IT IS TIME YOU START REALIZING THAT THERE IS AN OPPORTUNITY TO

00:10:10.900 --> 00:10:12.900
CAPTURE MORE TOT . WE NEED SOMEBODY WHO IS WILLING TO CONSIDER

00:10:13.900 --> 00:10:15.900
A FUTURE TAX INITIATIVE WHERE YOU COULD

00:10:18.900 --> 00:10:20.900
ASK THE BATTERS IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO RAISE THE

00:10:22.900 --> 00:10:24.900
TOT BY TWO PERCENT. IT IS UP TO US , THE VOTERS,

00:10:28.900 --> 00:10:30.900
TO DO IT. YOU DO NOT HAVE TO RAISE OUR SALE --SALES

00:10:31.900 --> 00:10:33.900
ARE PROPERTY TAXES. YOU CAN RAISE THE

00:10:34.900 --> 00:10:36.500
TOT.
TRANSIENT OCCUPANCY TAX.

00:10:37.400 --> 00:10:39.400
>> THANK YOU.

00:10:40.900 --> 00:10:42.900
>> I HAVE 38 SECONDS, DON'T I?

00:10:43.900 --> 00:10:45.900
>> IS A TIMER CURRENT?

00:10:49.900 --> 00:10:52.900
>> ANYWAYS, I'M LOOKING FORWARD TO NEXT MONTH WHEN WE
HAVE A NEW CHAIRWOMAN OF THE BOARD, I ASSUME. I'M ASSUMING THE ROTATION

00:10:52.900 --> 00:10:54.900
IS GOING TO GO TO MY FAVORITE SUPERVISOR ,

00:10:56.900 --> 00:10:58.900
SUPERVISOR GREGORY. I LOOK FORWARD TO THOSE THANK YOU.

00:11:00.833 --> 00:11:02.833
>> THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER FOR PUBLIC COMMENT?

00:11:07.833 --> 00:11:09.833
>> CHRISTOPHER --DISTRICT TWO. GOOD MORNING CHAIR AND

00:11:12.833 --> 00:11:14.833
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS. I COME TO THE TODAY AS THE --

00:11:16.833 --> 00:11:18.833
AND CHAIR OF THE NAPA VALLEY ARTS COMMITTEE.

00:11:19.767 --> 00:11:21.767
SO MUCH WE FOCUS ON WHAT IS NOT WORKING.

00:11:22.467 --> 00:11:24.467
TOMORROW -- I WOULD LIKE TO SHARE WHAT IS WORKING.

00:11:28.833 --> 00:11:30.833
I TENDED A MEETING LAST WEEK IN NASHVILLE ALONG

00:11:31.833 --> 00:11:33.833
WITH 50 OTHER SMALLER COMMUNITIES ACROSS THE U.S. FOR A CROSS SECTOR COLLABORATION

00:11:34.833 --> 00:11:36.833
FOCUSING ON RELATIONSHIP PROBLEM SOLVING CONNECTING COMMUNITY RISING

00:11:37.833 --> 00:11:39.833
WITH EQUITY. OF FANCY WAY OF SAYING

00:11:42.833 --> 00:11:44.833
A BUNCH OF REALLY DIFFERENT PEOPLE BROUGHT TOGETHER TO TALK ABOUT

00:11:45.833 --> 00:11:47.833
OUR PROBLEMS AND FIGURE OUT HOW TO DO THINGS BETTER. DARK UNITS BOOKER

00:11:48.833 --> 00:11:50.833
WAS NATIONAL POET AND STRATEGIST FOR THE ORGANIZATION NO STARVING ARTIST,

00:11:51.833 --> 00:11:53.833
STEPHANIE PRUITT JAMES RITCHIE LEFT US WITH

00:11:54.833 --> 00:11:56.833
A STATEMENT, PROGRESS MOVES AT THE SPEED OF TRUST.

00:11:59.767 --> 00:12:01.767
I CAME UP TO SEE THIS STATEMENT IN ACTION AS

00:12:02.767 --> 00:12:04.767
--MADE THE WORLD DEBUT

00:12:07.767 --> 00:12:09.767
AS THE ALL SPANISH-LANGUAGE REDUCTION IN OUR COUNTY ON

00:12:10.767 --> 00:12:12.767
THE MAIN STAGE AT NAPA VALLEY COLLEGE.

00:12:14.767 --> 00:12:17.767
FABRICATION OF IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE WAS WRITTEN AND
DIRECTED BY OUR VERY OWN POET LAUREATE -- PROGRESS MOVES AT THE SPEED

00:12:23.767 --> 00:12:25.767
OF TRUST.
REPRESENTATION MATTERS ON THIS HEARTWARMING AND EMOTIONAL PRODUCTION WAS

00:12:29.767 --> 00:12:31.767
PERFORMED BY MEMBERS OF OUR LATINO, LATINO MEMBERS

00:12:32.767 --> 00:12:34.767
-- AND THE MUSIC OF MARIOTTI. PROGRESS MOVES

00:12:35.767 --> 00:12:37.767
AT THE SPEED OF TRUST. INVESTMENT MATTERS.

00:12:38.767 --> 00:12:40.767
THIS WAS THE CHOICE -- JOINTLY

00:12:44.767 --> 00:12:46.767
, ARTS COUNCIL NAPA VALLEY, NAPA VALLEY PREVENTS, AND NAPA VALLEY COLLEGE. PROVIDING

00:12:50.767 --> 00:12:52.767
INCLUSIVE THEATER RIGHT HERE IN NAPA COUNTY. PROGRESS MOVES

00:12:56.767 --> 00:12:58.767
AT THE SPEED OF TRUST. I WISH YOU ALL A HAPPY AND RESTFUL HOLIDAY

00:12:59.700 --> 00:13:01.700
I LOOK FORWARD TO REAL PROGRESS AND CHANGE WHILE BUILDING TRUST TOGETHER

00:13:04.700 --> 00:13:06.700
WITH ALL MEMBERS OF NAPA COUNTY. THANK YOU.
>> THANK YOU.

00:13:11.700 --> 00:13:13.700
IT IS NICE TO HEAR NICE THINGS. I

00:13:15.700 --> 00:13:17.700
AM INCLINED TO WANT TO GIVE YOU A FEW MORE MINUTES. ANY

00:13:20.700 --> 00:13:22.700
OTHER SPEAKERS? THING NONE OF THE BOARDROOM, I WILL TURN

00:13:23.700 --> 00:13:25.700
TO THE PHONE LINES. THANK YOU. I WILL CLOSE

00:13:28.700 --> 00:13:31.700
PUBLIC COMMENT AND BRING IT BACK TO THE BOARD. FOR
OUR SUPERVISOR REPORTS AND ANNOUNCEMENTS NOW.

00:13:35.700 --> 00:13:37.700
DON'T EVERYONE GO AT ONE TIME . SUPERVISOR GREGORY?

00:13:41.700 --> 00:13:43.700
>> THANK YOU. AS THEY'VE DONE THE LAST FEW YEARS, THE

00:13:46.700 --> 00:13:48.700
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE HAS COME TO NAPA FOR THEIR RETREAT

00:13:50.700 --> 00:13:52.700
AND MEETINGS. WE ALL GOT TO VISIT WITH THEM LAST WEEK

00:13:53.700 --> 00:13:55.700
THAT WAS SPECIAL. I'M GLAD THEY COME TO

00:13:59.633 --> 00:14:01.633
BEEN WORKING ON AT SKYLINE PARK CALLED A BICYCLE SKILLS COURSE

00:14:05.633 --> 00:14:07.633
PARK. A --WE ARE FINISHED.

00:14:11.633 --> 00:14:13.633
I LET A FUNDRAISING CAMPAIGN TO BUILD THIS THING

00:14:15.633 --> 00:14:17.633
, COMPLETELY PRIVATELY FUNDED BUT IT IS FINISHED AND

00:14:18.633 --> 00:14:20.633
WE ARE HAVING THE GRAND OPENING ON THE 16th. A COUPLE SATURDAYS

00:14:23.633 --> 00:14:25.633
FROM NOW. COME ON OUT AND CHECK IT OUT. IT IS GREAT

00:14:26.633 --> 00:14:28.633
FOR THE FAMILY AND KIDS.

00:14:29.833 --> 00:14:31.833
THEY ARE GOING TO LOVE IT. THANK YOU.

00:14:34.900 --> 00:14:37.100
>> SUPERVISOR COTTRELL
.
>> THANK YOU.

00:14:39.633 --> 00:14:41.633
GOOD MORNING, CHAIR. I HAVE THREE THINGS TO GO OVER QUICKLY. MEETINGS

00:14:44.633 --> 00:14:46.633
HERE IN THE COUNTY OVER THE PAST COUPLE WEEKS. FIRST OF ALL, YESTERDAY,

00:14:47.633 --> 00:14:49.633
I DID A TOUR OF THE -- HOME WITH SOME OF THEIR TEAM THERE.

00:14:50.633 --> 00:14:52.633
ONE OF THEIR GOVERNMENT RELATIONS REPRESENTATIVES.

00:14:53.633 --> 00:14:55.633
WE LOOKED AT THE

00:14:59.567 --> 00:15:01.567
SCOPE OF THE -- FACILITY WHICH IS CURRENTLY ON TRACK TO BE

00:15:02.567 --> 00:15:04.567
COMPLETED IN LATE 2024 AND THEN THEY WILL HAVE TO GO FOR THE

00:15:06.567 --> 00:15:08.567
CERTIFICATION FOR THAT. THAT WILL NEED MORE PEOPLE BEING SERVED ON THAT

00:15:09.567 --> 00:15:11.567
CAMPUS. THEY ALSO TALKED ABOUT SOME OF THE ADAPTATION

00:15:14.567 --> 00:15:16.567
WE ARE LOOKING AT. THERE WILL BE 41 EB CHARTERS ON THAT SITE. WE

00:15:19.567 --> 00:15:21.567
ALSO TOURED SOME OF THE --WORK THAT IS HAPPENED AROUND

00:15:22.567 --> 00:15:24.567
THAT PROPERTY WHICH IS SO IMPORTANT FOR PROTECTING

00:15:26.567 --> 00:15:28.567
THE EASTERN PART OF THE COUNTY, AND ALSO THE COMMUNITY OF NAPA.

00:15:29.567 --> 00:15:31.567
AND THEN ABOUT THE FEW MEMBERS OF THE

00:15:33.567 --> 00:15:35.567
WINERY TEAM FOR THE UPDATED ME. THEY JUST RECEIVED THEIR FLUZONE CERTIFICATION.

00:15:37.567 --> 00:15:39.567
IT WAS GREAT TO HEAR ABOUT THAT EFFORT ACROSS THE COUNTY AND ACROSS

00:15:42.567 --> 00:15:44.567
INDUSTRIES. IS A GOOD REMINDER TO ME THAT AS

00:15:46.567 --> 00:15:48.567
WE, AT THE COUNTY, WE START THE CLIMATE ACTION WORK, THERE ARE LOTS OF WILLING PARTNERS OUT

00:15:50.567 --> 00:15:52.567
THERE WHO ARE WORKING ON IT IN THEIR OWN SPACES AS WELL.

00:15:53.567 --> 00:15:55.567
AND FINALLY, WE MET WITH THE NEW CHAIR OF THE FOOD

00:15:57.567 --> 00:15:59.567
SAFETY COALITION . WE ARE NOW CALLING THAT THE FOOD SECURITY COALITION.

00:16:02.500 --> 00:16:04.500
THAT IS KAREN -- YOU MAY KNOW. SHE IS THE DIRECTOR OF THE NAPA

00:16:07.500 --> 00:16:10.500
FARMERS MARKET. TALKED ABOUT KIND OF A VISION OF
HOW TO BETTER ORGANIZE THE NETWORK WITH THE NONPROFITS WORKING IN THE SPACE.

00:16:17.500 --> 00:16:19.500
EXCITED TO SEE THAT RELAUNCH TOO. THANK YOU.

00:16:20.500 --> 00:16:22.500
>> OKAY.

00:16:28.500 --> 00:16:30.500
THAT'S IT FOR BOARD OF SUPERVISORS REPORTS

00:16:32.500 --> 00:16:34.500
AND ANNOUNCEMENTS. WE DO NOT HAVE ANY ITEMS

00:16:37.500 --> 00:16:39.500
PULLED FROM THE CONSENT AND WE DO NOT HAVE ANY ITEMS AND SPECIAL

00:16:40.500 --> 00:16:42.500
DISTRICTS. I WILL GO A LITTLE OUT OF ORDER HERE. FIRST, I WILL

00:16:44.500 --> 00:16:46.500
GO AHEAD AND JUMP TO THE WILLIAM SOME ACT.

00:16:50.500 --> 00:16:52.500
--WILLIAM SOME ACT.

00:16:56.500 --> 00:16:58.500
DO WE HAVE THAT? IF NOT, I CAN MOVE AROUND. OKAY. I WILL GO

00:17:02.500 --> 00:17:04.500
AHEAD AND MOVE IT AROUND. SO IF YOU COULD HAVE THAT ONE

00:17:08.500 --> 00:17:10.500
READY AND QUEUED UP. THANK YOU. I WILL THEN FIRST GO TO OUR

00:17:14.500 --> 00:17:16.500
DEPUTY COUNTY FIRE CHIEF.

00:17:17.500 --> 00:17:19.500
IT WILL PROVIDE AN ANNUAL REPORT ON FIRE.

00:17:20.500 --> 00:17:22.500
ALL THINGS FIRE.

00:17:23.500 --> 00:17:25.500
PREPAREDNESS AND RESPONSE. WELCOME, CHIEF MARTIN.

00:17:26.500 --> 00:17:28.500
>> GOOD MORNING.

00:17:32.500 --> 00:17:35.500
>> GOOD MORNING. >> HOW IS EVERYBODY DOING TODAY?
>> RIGHT .

00:17:35.500 --> 00:17:37.500
ARE YOU LOOKING FOR AN OFFICE ?

00:17:41.500 --> 00:17:44.500
>> [ LAUGHTER ] >> IS THIS WORKING?
>> IT IS WORKING.

00:17:44.500 --> 00:17:46.500
>> WE WILL WAIVE THE FEES.

00:17:49.500 --> 00:17:51.500
>> ON CONSENT, WE HAVE A NEW OFFICE SO MAYBE THAT IS SOMETHING

00:17:52.500 --> 00:17:54.500
WE HAD TO THE OFFICE. GOOD MORNING, EVERYBODY.
JASON MARTIN, WITH THE NAPA

00:17:59.433 --> 00:18:01.433
COUNTY FIRE DEPARTMENT. THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME. OH, THANK YOU. MY

00:18:05.433 --> 00:18:07.433
PRESENTATION IS UP THIS MORNING. I WANT TO GIVE YOU A YEAR END PRESENTATION

00:18:08.433 --> 00:18:10.433
OF ALL THE EFFORTS WE HAVE PUT FORTH WITHIN THE COUNTY.

00:18:13.433 --> 00:18:15.433
I WANT TO PREFACE IT A LITTLE BIT .

00:18:16.433 --> 00:18:18.433
LAST TIME WE CAME TO THE BOARD AND ASKED FOR KIND OF --

00:18:20.433 --> 00:18:22.433
WHERE DID WE START AND WHERE WE AT TODAY? SO THIS IS KIND

00:18:23.433 --> 00:18:25.433
OF AN OVERVIEW THAT GIVES US SOME EXAMPLES AND

00:18:29.433 --> 00:18:31.433
SHOWS US THE OVERALL EFFORT WE PUT FORTH OVER THE LAST THREE YEARS

00:18:35.433 --> 00:18:37.433
. I WILL GO AHEAD AND START BUT IS A GET READY TO CLOSE OUT THIS

00:18:38.433 --> 00:18:40.433
YEAR, AND BEGAN 2024, WE WANT TO PAUSE AND SHARE

00:18:43.433 --> 00:18:45.433
OUR FIRE RESILIENCY PROGRESS WE MADE THIS YEAR. AND ALSO OVER THE

00:18:47.433 --> 00:18:49.433
LAST THREE YEARS. WHEN I SAY IT IS "WEAK ," IT

00:18:50.433 --> 00:18:52.433
IS NOT JUST ME. IS A COLLABORATIVE ENVIRONMENT. WE ARE

00:18:53.433 --> 00:18:55.433
IN PARTNERSHIP WITH NOT ONLY THE NAPA UNIT

00:18:59.367 --> 00:19:01.367
AS THE UNIT, BUT ALSO NAPA COUNTY FIRE DEPARTMENT, THE COUNTY

00:19:02.367 --> 00:19:04.367
OF NAPA.

00:19:05.367 --> 00:19:07.367
OUR STAKEHOLDERS SUCH AS THE -- AND THE GRAPE GROWERS.

00:19:11.367 --> 00:19:13.367
AND ALSO COMMUNITY MEMBERS AND OUR STAKEHOLDERS FOR THEIR VERY IMPORTANT

00:19:15.367 --> 00:19:17.367
FOR US TO MEET THE FIRE RESILIENCY COMMITTEE. NOW THAT WE

00:19:20.367 --> 00:19:22.367
ARE IN HERE, --LET ME SHARE SOME OF THE OBJECTIVES

00:19:25.367 --> 00:19:27.367
AND SOME THINGS WE HAVE BEEN ABLE TO ACCOMPLISH OVER THE YEARS.

00:19:30.367 --> 00:19:32.367
LET'S START WITH THE FIRE STATS FOR THIS KIND OF GIVES

00:19:33.367 --> 00:19:35.367
US AN IDEA OF WHAT THE LAST COUPLE YEARS

00:19:36.367 --> 00:19:38.367
HAVE LOOKED LIKE.

00:19:39.367 --> 00:19:41.367
WE HAVE BEEN BLESSED WITH SOME MODERATE WEATHER IN THE LAST

00:19:42.367 --> 00:19:44.367
FEW YEARS. THIS YEAR AND LAST YEAR. SO WE LOOK AT

00:19:48.367 --> 00:19:51.367
2020 AS AN EXAMPLE.
THERE WAS A LITTLE OVER 4 MILLION ACRES BURNED THROUGHOUT THE STATE. THIS IS

00:19:57.367 --> 00:19:59.367
STATEWIDE, BUT THIS GIVES US A WAS LOOKING LIKE. COMPARED TO 2023

00:20:00.300 --> 00:20:02.300
WHICH WAS ONLY 319,000. ALBEIT, THAT IS

00:20:04.300 --> 00:20:06.300
STILL A CONSIDERABLE AMOUNT OF ACREAGE ,

00:20:07.300 --> 00:20:09.300
BUT STATEWIDE, THAT IS A VERY LIGHT FIRE SEASON.

00:20:12.300 --> 00:20:14.300
BUT THAT ALSO MEANS THAT WE HAD TO TAKE ADVANTAGE FOR THAT AND

00:20:17.300 --> 00:20:19.300
CONTINUE OUR FIRE PREPARATIONS. NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. IN 2020,

00:20:24.300 --> 00:20:26.300
WE KIND OF EMBARKED ON THIS ADVENTURE , DEVELOPING

00:20:30.300 --> 00:20:32.300
A COUNTYWIDE CW PP. THAT WOULD'VE BEEN THE FIRST ,

00:20:34.300 --> 00:20:36.300
THAT WAS THE FIRST OF ITS KIND IN STATE. WITH THAT,

00:20:39.300 --> 00:20:41.300
IT TOOK PLANNING TO FORMULATE HOW WE ARE GOING TO ADDRESS THE

00:20:44.300 --> 00:20:46.300
OVERALL ISSUES. HOW WE ARE GOING TO MINIMIZE THE IMPACT, NOT JUST

00:20:49.300 --> 00:20:51.300
BY SMALL INCREMENTS, BUT BY A LARGE HAIL. BY DEVELOPING

00:20:54.300 --> 00:20:56.300
SOME COLLABORATION WITH OUR PARTNERS AS STATED PREVIOUSLY

00:20:57.300 --> 00:20:59.300
ON HOW WE CAN JOIN FORCES WITH EACH

00:21:02.233 --> 00:21:04.233
ONE OF THE PROJECTS TO HAVE AN OVERALL PLAN.

00:21:06.233 --> 00:21:09.233
THAT STARTED IN 2020.
WE LOOKED AT SOME OF THE GAPS WITHIN THE PLAN AND WE

00:21:12.233 --> 00:21:15.233
ADDRESSED THEM. WE PUT TOGETHER SOME TACTICS
AND STRATEGIES. WE IMPLEMENTED THAT PLANNING. NEXT

00:21:18.233 --> 00:21:20.233
SLIDE, PLEASE.

00:21:21.233 --> 00:21:23.233
WE CONTINUE TO DO OUR CHIPPING PROGRAM THAT HAD BEEN IN

00:21:24.233 --> 00:21:26.233
PLACE, BUT WE WANTED TO INCREASE THE EXPOSURE OF

00:21:30.233 --> 00:21:32.233
THAT PLAN. ALSO, WE WANTED TO GET MORE COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT

00:21:33.233 --> 00:21:36.233
WITH THIS FREE SERVICE.
WHAT THAT PROVIDED TO US WAS KIND OF A METRICS WE

00:21:40.233 --> 00:21:42.233
COULD USE TO FIGURE OUT IF OUR MESSAGING TO THE COMMUNITY IS ACCURATE AND

00:21:45.233 --> 00:21:47.233
WHERE WE NEEDED TO MAKE SOME IMPROVEMENTS.

00:21:48.233 --> 00:21:50.233
WHEN WE LOOK AT 2020, WE HAD ABOUT

00:21:54.233 --> 00:21:56.233
1077 REQUESTS . WHEN WE LOOK AT 2023, WE HAD A LITTLE OVER

00:22:00.167 --> 00:22:02.167
1100 , ALMOST 1200 REQUESTS.

00:22:03.167 --> 00:22:05.167
WE HAD SOME PEAKS AND VALLEYS WITHIN THAT. AGAIN,

00:22:07.167 --> 00:22:09.167
THAT IS SOME OF THE EDUCATIONAL COMPONENTS WHICH ALLOWED US TO PIVOT

00:22:11.167 --> 00:22:13.167
. AGAIN, WE SAW THE SUCCESS WITH THAT PROGRAM AND WE WANT TO CONTINUE THAT PROGRAM.

00:22:15.167 --> 00:22:17.167
NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. IT WAS

00:22:21.167 --> 00:22:23.167
ASKED OF THE BOARD TO PROVIDE A MAP OF THE DENSITY WHERE THE SHIPPING

00:22:27.167 --> 00:22:29.167
OPERATIONS HAVE BEEN HAPPENING WITHIN THE COUNTY. WE OVERLAID OUR

00:22:33.167 --> 00:22:35.167
2023 MAP. THAT SHOWED THAT THE CHIPPING ITSELF

00:22:39.167 --> 00:22:42.167
IS THROUGHOUT THE COUNTY.
IT IS NOT JUST CONSOLIDATED IN ONE AREA WHICH IS ACTUALLY REALLY GOOD. IT

00:22:45.167 --> 00:22:47.167
HELPS US IN A LOT OF OUR TARGET AREAS SO WE SEE THE

00:22:51.167 --> 00:22:53.167
WHITE AREA.

00:22:54.167 --> 00:22:56.167
THOSE ARE TWO OF THE TARGETS WE HAVE IN THE AREA. AGAIN,

00:22:57.167 --> 00:22:59.167
THAT JUST REITERATES TO US FROM THE PROGRAM SIDE THAT WE ARE MESSAGING

00:23:03.100 --> 00:23:05.100
AND THAT MESSAGE IS WIDE AND FAR. NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

00:23:12.100 --> 00:23:14.100
OUR DEFENSIBLE SPACE INSPECTIONS FOR THIS IS ACTUALLY

00:23:15.100 --> 00:23:17.100
A BIG ONE. IN 2020, WE LOOK AT HOW MANY DEFENSIBLE SPACE INSPECTIONS

00:23:18.100 --> 00:23:21.100
WE WERE ABLE TO ACCOMPLISH.
WE REALLY HAD TO DRILL DOWN AND HOW THAT PLAN

00:23:23.100 --> 00:23:25.100
IS BEING DEPLOYED. WE MADE SOME ADJUSTMENTS TO

00:23:27.100 --> 00:23:29.100
THAT PLAN. WE ESTABLISHED SOME BENCHMARKS IN ORDER TO HAVE MORE EXPOSURE

00:23:33.100 --> 00:23:35.100
, INCREASE THE AMOUNT OF PUBLIC EDUCATION TO ALL

00:23:36.100 --> 00:23:38.100
THE RESIDENTS AND THE NEED AND IMPORTANCE OF DISPENSABLE SPACE.

00:23:42.100 --> 00:23:44.100
IF YOU LOOK AT 2020,

00:23:48.100 --> 00:23:50.100
ALBEIT 900 INSPECTIONS IS REALLY, REALLY GOOD.

00:23:51.100 --> 00:23:53.100
BUT WHEN WE COMPARE IT TO 2023 , WITH A LITTLE OVER 2500 INSPECTIONS,

00:23:54.100 --> 00:23:56.100
THAT JUST REALLY IS AN EXAMPLE OF PLANNING

00:24:00.330 --> 00:24:02.330
AND ALSO STAFFING.

00:24:03.330 --> 00:24:05.330
SO WE FIND GREAT SUCCESS WITH THAT PROGRAM.

00:24:06.330 --> 00:24:08.330
WE ALSO DEVELOPED THROUGH THE FIRE MARSHAL'S OFFICE,

00:24:09.330 --> 00:24:11.330
A CERTIFICATE.

00:24:12.330 --> 00:24:14.330
THE CERTIFICATE AT FIRST GLANCE IS SOMEBODY GETS A PIECE OF PAPER THAT SAYS, HEY,

00:24:18.330 --> 00:24:20.330
I MET THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE YEAR.

00:24:21.330 --> 00:24:23.330
BUT IT PROVIDES A LITTLE MORE LEVERAGE FOR THE HOMEOWNERS

00:24:24.330 --> 00:24:26.330
TO PROVIDE BACK TO INSURANCE COMPANIES WHEN ASKED IF THEY

00:24:30.330 --> 00:24:32.330
HAVE DEFENSIBLE SPACE. HAS ANYBODY INSPECTED, OR LOOK AT

00:24:36.330 --> 00:24:38.330
YOUR PROPERTY?
I KNOW THEY HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO PROVIDE THEM A LEGAL DOCUMENT. WE WERE

00:24:41.330 --> 00:24:43.330
THE FIRST COUNTY IN THE STATE IN ORDER TO PROVIDE SUCH

00:24:45.330 --> 00:24:47.330
A CERTIFICATE. AND NOW THAT HAS BECOME ANOTHER RECOGNIZED SOURCE

00:24:48.330 --> 00:24:50.330
OF THE KNOWLEDGE IT. AGAIN, THAT IS

00:24:54.330 --> 00:24:56.330
A FIRST FOR MANY OF THESE THINGS.

00:24:57.330 --> 00:24:59.330
NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. SO WHEN ME LOOK AT THIS

00:25:02.967 --> 00:25:04.967
MAP, THIS IS OUR DENSITY FOR OUR DEFENSIBLE SPACE INSPECTIONS FROM

00:25:05.967 --> 00:25:07.967
THIS LAST YEAR. AS I STATED

00:25:11.967 --> 00:25:13.967
IN A COUPLE OF BOARD MEETINGS PRIOR, WE HAVE A THREE-YEAR PLAN TO TRY TO

00:25:14.967 --> 00:25:16.967
LINK IT 100% OF THE COUNTY. THIS IS

00:25:20.967 --> 00:25:22.967
AN EXAMPLE OF WHERE WE LOOK AT OUR TARGET HAZARDS

00:25:23.967 --> 00:25:25.967
TO ENSURE COMMUNITIES THAT ARE AT RISK ARE BEING

00:25:26.967 --> 00:25:28.967
LOOKED AT AND THEY GET THE EDUCATION AND INSPECTIONS AS NEEDED. AND ALSO,

00:25:32.967 --> 00:25:34.967
USE THAT STRATEGY TO ENHANCE OR

00:25:38.967 --> 00:25:40.967
GROW THAT INSPECTION.

00:25:41.967 --> 00:25:43.967
NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

00:25:44.967 --> 00:25:46.967
WHEN WE LOOK AT 2020, WE ALSO HAD TO RECOGNIZE THAT

00:25:50.967 --> 00:25:52.967
, ALBEIT WE SEND OUT FLYERS, THERE IS

00:25:58.900 --> 00:26:01.900
SOMEHOW TO AND HOW YOU GET PREPARED.
WE REALIZE THERE IS STILL A GAP WITH THAT.

00:26:05.900 --> 00:26:08.900
AND REALLY TRULY UNDERSTANDING. WHEN WE LOOK AT
THE FIRE PERSPECTIVE, IT MAKES SENSE TO US.

00:26:11.900 --> 00:26:14.900
WHEN WE LOOK AT IT FROM THE HOMEOWNERS PERSPECTIVE, IT
MAY NOT NECESSARILY MAKE SENSE BECAUSE YOU WANT THE PROPERTY TO LOOK

00:26:16.900 --> 00:26:18.900
A CERTAIN WAY. SO WE IMPLEMENTED THE CONSULT MEANT

00:26:20.900 --> 00:26:23.900
--CONSULTING INSPECTION PROCESS THROUGH THE OFFICE.
THAT AFFORDS US THE AUTHORITY TO GO OUT PRIVATE PROPERTIES AND

00:26:27.900 --> 00:26:29.900
BUSINESSES TO GIVE THE PROPERTY OWNERS SOME INFORMATION ON

00:26:33.900 --> 00:26:35.900
HOW BEST TO ACCOMPLISH DEFENSIBLE SPACE

00:26:37.900 --> 00:26:39.900
AND DEVELOP A PLAN AND TO EXECUTE THAT PLAN. AT FIRST,

00:26:41.900 --> 00:26:43.900
WE WERE NOT SURE IF IT WAS GOING TO TAKE HOLD. WE FOUND A LOT OF SUCCESS WITH

00:26:45.900 --> 00:26:48.900
THIS PROGRAM.
NOT ONLY IS IT AFFORDING INFORMATION TO

00:26:51.900 --> 00:26:53.900
THOSE PROPERTY OWNERS, BUT IT IS ALSO ENHANCING THE FIRE RESILIENCY

00:26:58.900 --> 00:27:00.900
FRONT OF THE COUNTY BECAUSE THAT INFORMATION IS ALSO BEING SHARED WITH THOSE FRIENDS,

00:27:02.900 --> 00:27:04.900
FAMILIES, AND OTHER BUSINESSES. NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

00:27:09.900 --> 00:27:11.900
AGAIN, SHADY FIELD BREAKS AS A METHOD WE USE

00:27:15.900 --> 00:27:17.900
FOR FIRE RESILIENCY. THIS IS OUR ONE EXAMPLE OF HOW WE CAN

00:27:20.900 --> 00:27:22.900
REDUCE THE FUEL LOADING WHICH CHANGES THE

00:27:24.900 --> 00:27:27.900
FIRE CHARACTERISTICS.
SO WHEN WE LOOK AT THIS SLIDE IN 2021, WE TREATED

00:27:30.900 --> 00:27:32.900
350 ACRES. IN 2023, ALMOST DOUBLE, AT

00:27:36.900 --> 00:27:38.900
633 ACRES.

00:27:39.900 --> 00:27:41.900
TREATED ACRES. THESE SHADED FIELD

00:27:43.900 --> 00:27:45.900
BREAKS AROUND OUR COMMUNITIES SUCH AS --

00:27:47.900 --> 00:27:49.900
CERTAIN OAKS, VARIOUS ISLANDS, AND THE ESTATES. NEXT

00:27:51.900 --> 00:27:53.900
SLIDE, PLEASE.

00:27:54.900 --> 00:27:56.900
ROADSIDE CLEARING.
AGAIN, ONE OF OUR PRIORITIES WE HAVE WITHIN THE COUNTY, OUR NUMBER ONE

00:28:00.833 --> 00:28:02.833
TO ENSURE THAT OUR INGRESS

00:28:04.833 --> 00:28:06.833
AND EGRESS ROUTES ARE OPEN. AGAIN, WHAT THIS DOES IS IT REDUCES THE FIRE

00:28:07.833 --> 00:28:10.833
INTENSITY IMPACT ON THOSE ROADWAYS.
IN 2021, WE WERE ONLY ABLE TO ACCOMPLISH ABOUT

00:28:12.833 --> 00:28:14.833
10 MILES OF ROADSIDE CLEARANCE. WHEN WE LOOK AT

00:28:18.833 --> 00:28:20.833
2023, WE TREATED 134 MILES.

00:28:21.833 --> 00:28:23.833
AGAIN, THIS IS A CONTINUED EFFORT. THIS IS A STRATEGIC

00:28:24.833 --> 00:28:26.833
GOAL WE HAVE WITHIN THE COUNTY IN ORDER TO

00:28:27.833 --> 00:28:29.833
MAINTAIN THOSE INGRESS AND EGRESS ROUTES. AND WE ARE

00:28:33.833 --> 00:28:35.833
CONTINUING TO SEE GREAT SUCCESS WITH THAT. AS WE MOVE

00:28:38.833 --> 00:28:40.833
FORWARD, WE CONTINUE TO IMPROVE ON THAT PROGRAM. NEXT

00:28:42.833 --> 00:28:44.833
SLIDE, PLEASE WE HAVE SPOKEN ABOUT

00:28:48.833 --> 00:28:50.833
STRATEGIC DOZER LINES WITHIN THE COUNTY AND WHAT THOSE ACTUALLY MEAN. REALLY,

00:28:51.833 --> 00:28:53.833
THAT IS OPENING UP CRATERS.

00:28:59.767 --> 00:29:01.767
FIRES AND THEN TO LEVERAGE THOSE AND MAINTAIN THEM SO THAT

00:29:03.767 --> 00:29:05.767
IT PROVIDES US A BREAK IN THE LANDSCAPE

00:29:09.767 --> 00:29:11.767
AND SOME OBJECTIVES OR SOME PRIORITIES FOR

00:29:12.767 --> 00:29:14.767
FIRE OPERATIONS . WE CAN STRATEGICALLY USE THOSE DOZER LINES WERE LOOKING

00:29:18.767 --> 00:29:20.767
AT 2021, IT WAS WITHIN OUR PLAN. WE WERE NOT ABLE

00:29:21.767 --> 00:29:23.767
TO EXECUTE. BUT DUE TO A GENEROUS DONATION

00:29:26.767 --> 00:29:28.767
FROM THE VINEYARDS, IN 2023, WE WERE ABLE TO DO THE MAINTENANCE

00:29:30.767 --> 00:29:32.767
AND OPEN UP 69 MILES.

00:29:33.767 --> 00:29:35.767
THOSE ARE STRATEGIC DOZER LINES THAT WE UTILIZE IN ORDER TO

00:29:39.767 --> 00:29:41.767
SUPPRESS FIRES AS THEY ARE MOVING THROUGH OUR ENVIRONMENT.

00:29:42.767 --> 00:29:44.767
NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

00:29:45.767 --> 00:29:47.767
SO I HAVE TO APOLOGIZE ON THIS ONE. NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

00:29:51.767 --> 00:29:53.767
OH, WE ARE STUCK.

00:29:59.700 --> 00:30:01.700
THERE YET. AS WE WAIT FOR THE SLIDE TO CATCH

00:30:02.700 --> 00:30:04.700
UP, WE ASKED ABOUT --EFFORTS. AND SO WE WENT

00:30:06.700 --> 00:30:08.700
AFTER TO GET SOME DATA FROM THE VENDORS . WE DID NOT GET ANYTHING BACK FROM THEM.

00:30:09.700 --> 00:30:11.700
WE KNOW THEY ARE OUT THERE AND THEY ARE TREATING

00:30:14.700 --> 00:30:16.700
SEVERAL ACRES . I CAN REPORT OUT TO YOU

00:30:18.700 --> 00:30:20.700
THAT FROM OUR CWPP AND OUR EFFORTS, WE TREATED 353

00:30:24.700 --> 00:30:26.700
ACRES THROUGH GRAZING IN 2023. WE KNOW THAT GRAZING

00:30:30.700 --> 00:30:32.700
WITH THE CONTRACTORS THAT ARE WITHIN THE VALLEY HAS BEEN ONGOING.

00:30:36.700 --> 00:30:38.700
THAT'S ON SEVERAL OF THE LARGE PROPERTIES. IT IS TAKING HOLD AS A

00:30:39.700 --> 00:30:41.700
VERY ECONOMIC WAY TO START CLEARING AND MAINTAINING

00:30:45.700 --> 00:30:47.700
THE PROPERTIES . UNFORTUNATELY, I DO NOT HAVE THE

00:30:48.700 --> 00:30:50.700
TOTAL NUMBERS BUT I WAS HOPING I DID, BUT I DO NOT HAVE

00:30:51.700 --> 00:30:53.700
THAT. I CAN TELL YOU THAT THAT IS ONGOING AND WILL BECOME

00:30:56.700 --> 00:30:58.700
ONE OF THE NORMS WE WILL SEE WITHIN FOR THE USE OF GRAZING ANIMALS. NEXT

00:31:00.633 --> 00:31:02.633
SLIDE, PLEASE.

00:31:03.633 --> 00:31:05.633
OKAY. RECAPS. IN 2023 , FIELD BREAKS.

00:31:09.633 --> 00:31:11.633
WE TREATED 633 ACRES. ROADSIDE CLEARING IS 134 MILES.

00:31:15.633 --> 00:31:17.633
GRAZED ACRES WAS 353 ACRES.

00:31:18.633 --> 00:31:20.633
AND IN THE STRATEGIC DOZER MILES WAS 69.

00:31:24.633 --> 00:31:26.633
WHEN WE COMPARE THAT FROM 2021 THROUGH 2023, THE SHADY

00:31:27.633 --> 00:31:29.633
FIELD BREAKS ACRES TREATED WAS ALMOST 2400 ACRES. THE

00:31:30.633 --> 00:31:32.633
ROADSIDE CLEARING MILES IS TO 19 MILES.

00:31:35.633 --> 00:31:37.633
GRAZED ACRES, AGAIN, WE IMPLEMENTED GRAZING LAST YEAR

00:31:39.633 --> 00:31:41.633
SO IT IS ONLY 353 ACRES. AND THEN THE STRATEGIC

00:31:42.633 --> 00:31:44.633
DOZER MILES OVER THAT PERIOD OF TIME WAS A TOTAL OF

00:31:45.633 --> 00:31:47.633
73. AGAIN, THIS GIVES US KIND OF A PRETTY GOOD IDEA

00:31:51.633 --> 00:31:54.633
OF HOW MUCH WORK WE HAVE GOTTEN ACCOMPLISHED AND WHAT WE
ARE LEARNING AS WE MOVE ALONG IN THIS PROCESS. WE ARE

00:32:00.567 --> 00:32:03.567
AS WE TRANSITION INTO 2024, WE WILL SEE SOME
IMPROVEMENTS IN THOSE NUMBERS, NOT ONLY WITH FUNDING

00:32:05.567 --> 00:32:07.567
FROM THE COUNTY, BUT ALSO FROM THE GRANTS WE HAVE CURRENTLY

00:32:09.567 --> 00:32:11.567
IN QUEUE. NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

00:32:14.567 --> 00:32:16.567
SO NOW WE ARE GOING TO LOOK AT WHERE WE SPENT THESE PROJECTS

00:32:18.567 --> 00:32:20.567
THUS FAR. IN 2021, WE STARTED WITH --MILLION DOLLARS TO

00:32:25.567 --> 00:32:27.567
START THE PROGRAM AND IMPLEMENT THE FIRE RESILIENCY

00:32:31.567 --> 00:32:33.567
PLAN. IN 2022, WE SPENT 6.1 MILLION. IN 2023, WE SPENT

00:32:37.567 --> 00:32:39.567
--.6 FOR THAT WAS REFLECTED ON THE PROJECTS

00:32:40.567 --> 00:32:42.567
WE JUST WENT THROUGH. AND THAT IS THE OVERALL

00:32:43.567 --> 00:32:45.567
COST TO DATE. WHAT

00:32:48.567 --> 00:32:50.567
WE SPENT FOR OUR FIVE YEAR COMMUNITY FIRE PREVENTION PLAN. NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

00:33:00.500 --> 00:33:03.500
NOW WE WILL GET INTO SOME OF OUR COMMUNITY EFFORT.
THANKS TO A GRANT THIS YEAR WE WERE ABLE TO

00:33:05.500 --> 00:33:07.500
FOCUS ON REFLECTIVE MANAGEMENT PROGRAM. THOSE ARE THE

00:33:10.500 --> 00:33:12.500
ACRA'S MARKERS. THAT GIVES US THE INFORMATION FOR SOME OF THESE

00:33:14.500 --> 00:33:17.500
LONG DRIVEWAYS FOR THE FIRE DEPARTMENTS.
SO PERTAINING TO NOT ONLY THE ADDRESS OF

00:33:20.500 --> 00:33:22.500
THE PROPERTY, BUT TO THE TURNAROUNDS FOR THE

00:33:25.500 --> 00:33:27.500
FIRE APPARATUS. IS THERE A WATER SOURCE AVAILABLE?

00:33:28.500 --> 00:33:30.500
IS THERE ANY OTHER TYPE OF FIRE DEPARTMENT INFRASTRUCTURE WE

00:33:31.500 --> 00:33:33.500
CAN LEVERAGE IN ADVANCE OF A MOVING FIRE? WHEN WE LOOK AT THIS,

00:33:34.500 --> 00:33:36.500
THERE WERE SIX FIRE STATE COUNCILS THAT RECEIVED

00:33:40.500 --> 00:33:42.500
THEIR ADDRESS SIGNS FOR DIAMOND MOUNTAINS, SPRING MOUNTAIN,

00:33:43.500 --> 00:33:45.500
--POWER COURSE VALLEY, CALISTOGA, VALLEY.

00:33:49.500 --> 00:33:51.500
--ESTATES FIRE SAFE COUNCIL. A TOTAL OF 1187

00:33:54.500 --> 00:33:56.500
ADDRESS SIGNS WERE PRINTED AND INSTALLED.

00:33:58.433 --> 00:34:00.433
THEY SPENT A LITTLE OVER $27,000 ON THIS PROJECT

00:34:01.433 --> 00:34:03.433
IN ORDER TO ENSURE WE CHANGE OUR SIGNAGE

00:34:07.433 --> 00:34:09.433
AND THAT ALLOWS US BETTER AXIS, NOT ONLY FOR THE PROPERTY OWNERS, BUT

00:34:12.433 --> 00:34:14.433
ALSO FOR THE EMERGENCY RESPONSE SIDE OF THAT PROGRAM. NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

00:34:22.433 --> 00:34:24.433
AND THIS LAST YEAR, WE PARTICIPATED IN THE FIRE WISE

00:34:26.433 --> 00:34:29.433
DISPENSABLE SPACE COST SHARE PROGRAM.
THIS WAS A PROGRAM BASED ON A GRANT FROM CAL FIRE

00:34:34.433 --> 00:34:36.433
THAT PROVIDED A COST SHARE TO PROPERTY OWNERS TO PROVIDE DEFENSIBLE

00:34:39.433 --> 00:34:41.433
SPACE. THAT IS BASICALLY A REIMBURSEMENT UP

00:34:43.433 --> 00:34:45.433
TO $3500 . AND THEN, THERE WAS 320 PARTICIPANTS

00:34:46.433 --> 00:34:48.433
IN THIS PROGRAM.

00:34:49.433 --> 00:34:51.433
THAT IS VERY SUCCESSFUL.

00:34:52.433 --> 00:34:54.433
THE PROPERTY OWNER SPENT A LITTLE OVER $300,000 IN DEFENSIBLE SPACE

00:34:58.367 --> 00:35:00.367
EFFORTS. WE WERE REIMBURSED AT 100,000

00:35:04.367 --> 00:35:06.367
-- 100,006 93 BACK TO THE PROPERTY OWNERS.

00:35:09.367 --> 00:35:11.367
THESE ARE ONGOING THROUGHOUT THE COUNTY AND

00:35:12.367 --> 00:35:14.367
BECOME AVAILABLE AND WE ARE ABLE TO LEVERAGE

00:35:15.367 --> 00:35:17.367
IT. WE UNDERSTAND HOW BEST TO PROMOTE THIS PROGRAM. AND ALSO COULD

00:35:20.367 --> 00:35:22.367
DO A FOLLOW-UP WITH PROPERTY OWNERS IN EDUCATION.

00:35:23.367 --> 00:35:25.367
THIS IS IMPLEMENTATION THROUGHOUT THE COUNTY WHICH WE SEE

00:35:27.367 --> 00:35:29.367
WILL BE LONG-LASTING. NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

00:35:33.367 --> 00:35:35.367
WILL TALK ABOUT THE SPECIFIC UNION COLLEGE.

00:35:37.367 --> 00:35:39.367
THE FUELS REDUCTION PROJECT WE HAVE UP THERE. OVER

00:35:43.367 --> 00:35:45.367
$1 MILLION SPENT IN FUEL REDUCTION EFFORTS IN PUC. THAT IS IN

00:35:49.367 --> 00:35:51.367
THE -- AREA. 184 ACRES HAS TAKEN PLACE WHICH IS REDUCING THE

00:35:52.367 --> 00:35:54.367
FIRE LOADING WITHIN THAT AREA WHICH IS

00:35:58.300 --> 00:36:00.300
PROTECTING THE GREATER PART OF ENGLAND. AND 60 ACRES OF

00:36:03.300 --> 00:36:05.300
HAMTRAMCK. AGAIN, THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE TWO IS WITHIN

00:36:06.300 --> 00:36:08.300
THE MECHANICAL APPLICATION, TRACTORS AND WHAT

00:36:10.300 --> 00:36:12.300
HAVE YOU. AND THEN HAND TRIMMING IS PERSONNEL WALKING IN AND OF

00:36:15.300 --> 00:36:17.300
PHYSICALLY CUTTING AND STACKING AND PILING DAD

00:36:19.300 --> 00:36:21.300
AND DOWNED TREES IN ORDER TO OPEN UP THE LAND WHICH

00:36:25.300 --> 00:36:27.300
CHANGES OUR FIRE ENVIRONMENT WHICH REDUCES THE FIRE IMPACTS AND

00:36:28.300 --> 00:36:30.300
MAKES IT EASIER FOR SUPPRESSION.

00:36:31.300 --> 00:36:33.300
NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

00:36:40.300 --> 00:36:42.300
PUBLIC EDUCATION WAS ONE OF OUR PRIORITIES WITH THE CWPP

00:36:45.300 --> 00:36:47.300
AND ONE OF THE STRATEGIES WE WANTED TO REALLY ENHANCE

00:36:49.300 --> 00:36:51.300
WHEN YOU LOOK AT OUR OVERALL PLAN STARTED IN 2020. THE PROGRAM HAS

00:36:52.300 --> 00:36:54.300
BEEN VERY SUCCESSFUL. WE PARTICIPATED IN

00:36:55.300 --> 00:36:57.300
SEVERAL EVENTS IN THE COMMUNITY. WE FOUND THE ENGINE

00:36:58.300 --> 00:37:00.300
DAYS, GETTING ENGINE COMPANIES OUT IN THE COMMUNITIES

00:37:04.300 --> 00:37:06.300
, IS AMONGST ONE OF THE MOST POPULAR EVENTS. AS WE SAW

00:37:09.300 --> 00:37:11.300
WITH THE COMPANIES GOING UP IN THE SILVERADO, THOSE FIRE

00:37:13.300 --> 00:37:15.300
CITY COUNCILS OR THE ORGANIZATIONS, OUR COMPANIES WILL

00:37:16.300 --> 00:37:18.300
GO OUT AND MEET WITH THE PROPERTY OWNERS

00:37:19.300 --> 00:37:21.300
ON THOSE COMMUNITY MEMBERS. THEY WALKED THE PROPERTY

00:37:22.300 --> 00:37:24.300
AND ASK QUESTIONS AND HOW IT RELATES DIRECTLY TO

00:37:28.300 --> 00:37:30.300
THEM. THEY GIVE THEM DIRECTION OR SUGGESTIONS ON HOW BEST TO FORTIFY THEIR PROPERTIES.

00:37:34.300 --> 00:37:36.300
WE FIND SUCCESS WITH THAT. NOT ONLY ARE PUBLIC EVENT THAT

00:37:39.300 --> 00:37:41.300
WE ATTEND, BUT ALSO THESE SMALLER EVENTS .

00:37:43.300 --> 00:37:45.300
SHOWING THAT OUR PUBLIC EDUCATION PROGRAM CONTINUES TO EXPAND . WE ARE

00:37:49.300 --> 00:37:51.300
FINDING SUCCESS AND WE ARE LOOKING AT 2024 A FEW MORE

00:37:52.300 --> 00:37:54.300
PROGRAMS IF WE CAN. NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE POINT

00:37:58.233 --> 00:38:00.233
LASTLY, I WANT TO GIVE SOME HIGHLIGHTS FOR 2023 OF THE THINGS WE

00:38:01.233 --> 00:38:03.233
HAVE ADDED THAT PROVIDE US THE MEANS TO

00:38:07.233 --> 00:38:09.233
PROVIDE FIRE PROTECTION TO NAPA COUNTY. ENHANCEMENTS

00:38:12.233 --> 00:38:14.233
AND TOOLS PROVIDED TO THE COMMUNITY.
THE BIG ONE, I THINK, THAT IS ONE OF THE TOOLS THAT IS DIRECTLY

00:38:16.233 --> 00:38:18.233
AVAILABLE TO DIVINITY THROUGH THE PAGES

00:38:22.233 --> 00:38:25.233
IS THE FUEL MAPPER. THAT IS THAT TOOL IF YOU RECALL THAT
SOMEBODY CAN PUT IN THEIR ADDRESS AND IT WILL PROVIDE THEM

00:38:28.233 --> 00:38:30.233
A SHEET THAT TELLS THEM WHAT THEY NEED TO REDUCE ON

00:38:32.233 --> 00:38:34.233
THEIR PROPERTY FOR FIRE RESILIENCY TO REDUCE

00:38:37.233 --> 00:38:39.233
THEIR RISK FOR WILDFIRES. OF COURSE, OUR ENGINE

00:38:41.233 --> 00:38:43.233
DAYS. IMPLEMENTATION OF OUR MOBILE ADDED TERMINALS WE PUT INTO

00:38:44.233 --> 00:38:46.233
THE FIRE ENGINES FOR THAT IS THE

00:38:47.233 --> 00:38:49.233
TABLET COMMAND PROGRAM. THAT IS ALLOWING US NOT ONLY TO

00:38:52.233 --> 00:38:54.233
RECEIVE INFORMATION FROM OUR COMMAND CENTER ON THE

00:38:55.233 --> 00:38:57.233
TYPE OF CALL AND RELATIVE INFORMATION , BUT ALSO MAP LAYERS THAT

00:39:00.167 --> 00:39:02.167
ARE PERTINENT TO FIRE INFORMATION SUCH AS

00:39:05.167 --> 00:39:07.167
WATER SOURCES.

00:39:08.167 --> 00:39:10.167
WE ARE IN PARTNERSHIP WITH METER ME. THAT PROVIDES US

00:39:14.167 --> 00:39:16.167
GIS DATA THAT SHOWS US THE PRIVATE WATER SOURCES WE CAN TAP

00:39:17.167 --> 00:39:19.167
INTO IN THE EVENT THERE IS A FIRE. COMMUNITY MAPS

00:39:23.167 --> 00:39:25.167
FOR EGRESS AND/OR INFRASTRUCTURE , BRIDGE LIMITS, ET CETERA.

00:39:29.167 --> 00:39:31.167
WE ARE HAPPY TO UPDATE OUR MOBILE RADIUS. WE

00:39:33.167 --> 00:39:35.167
HAVE THE COMMUNICATION ISSUES WITH OUR CURRENT

00:39:38.167 --> 00:39:40.167
FIRE EQUIPMENT. LAST YEAR, THROUGH A COUNTY COMMUNICATIONS PARTNERSHIP

00:39:41.167 --> 00:39:43.167
WITH THEM, WE STARTED TO INSTALL AND UPGRADE OUR

00:39:45.167 --> 00:39:47.167
RADIO SYSTEM. WE ARE MOVING FORWARD TO CONTINUE THAT

00:39:49.167 --> 00:39:51.167
INCREASE IN COMMUNICATION CAPABILITIES.
AGAIN, THIS YEAR, STARTING THE

00:39:55.167 --> 00:39:57.167
FIRE SEASON, WE HAD THE ALERT CALIFORNIA AI FIRE

00:40:05.100 --> 00:40:07.100
CAMERAS WE DEPLOYED WITH ALERTING IN OUR COMMAND CENTER. WE

00:40:08.100 --> 00:40:10.100
FOUND GREAT SUCCESS WITH THAT PROGRAM AND I SEE THAT PROGRAM CONTINUE

00:40:11.100 --> 00:40:13.100
AND EXPAND IN THE COMING YEARS.

00:40:16.100 --> 00:40:18.100
STAFFING LEVELS. AGAIN, WE HAVE FIRE PREVENTION.

00:40:20.100 --> 00:40:22.100
THAT IS ONE SIDE OF OUR CAPABILITIES

00:40:24.100 --> 00:40:26.100
AND WHAT IS NECESSARY IN ORDER TO MITIGATE FIRES SO STAFFING

00:40:29.100 --> 00:40:32.100
IS A CRITICAL ROLL.
THEY PROVIDE THE HIGHEST LEVEL OF PROTECTION WITHIN THE COMMUNITY. THANK YOU

00:40:35.100 --> 00:40:37.100
TO THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS WE INCREASED OUR FIELD STAFFING LEVEL,

00:40:38.100 --> 00:40:41.100
NOT ONLY ON OUR FIRE ENGINES, BUT INCREASED
THE CONTROL CAPABILITIES WITH OUR FIELD BATTALIONS. AND

00:40:47.100 --> 00:40:49.100
ALSO, THROUGHOUT THE COUNTY, WE INCREASED OUR WINTER STAFFING PREPAREDNESS

00:40:50.100 --> 00:40:52.100
WITH OUR AMADOR PLAN FOR THAT IS WERE THE

00:40:56.100 --> 00:40:58.100
CAL FIRE STATION STAY OPEN. THEY WE BROUGHT THAT ON STAGE

00:41:02.330 --> 00:41:04.330
OR ONBOARD STATION 30 TWO AT THE SURGE CAPACITY NECESSARY

00:41:05.330 --> 00:41:07.330
TO PROVIDE THE LEVEL OF PROTECTION THROUGHOUT

00:41:08.330 --> 00:41:10.330
THE SEASON. OH, AND THE LAST PART OF THAT IS COMPLETION

00:41:13.330 --> 00:41:15.330
OF OUR FIRE MASTER PLAN. THAT GIVES US SOME OBJECTIVES AND SOME PRIORITIES

00:41:17.330 --> 00:41:19.330
WITHIN THE FIRE DEPARTMENT THROUGHOUT ALL THE

00:41:20.330 --> 00:41:22.330
PROGRAMS AND WHAT WE NEED TO ADDRESS AND WHERE WE CAN

00:41:26.330 --> 00:41:29.330
MAKE IMPROVEMENTS. THAT IS THE END OF
MY PRESENTATION. I AM AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS YOU

00:41:31.500 --> 00:41:33.300
MAY HAVE.
>> THANK YOU, CHIEF. IT IS GREAT TO

00:41:38.330 --> 00:41:40.330
HEAR A YEAR END REPORT OF THE INVESTMENTS WE HAVE

00:41:41.330 --> 00:41:43.330
MADE. WHAT IS MOST SIGNIFICANT IS ACTUALLY SEEING THE CUMULATIVE WORK

00:41:47.330 --> 00:41:49.330
OVER THREE YEARS AND INVESTMENTS , AND NOT JUST FOR THE CWPP,

00:41:53.330 --> 00:41:55.330
BUT ALSO A CHANGE IN METHODOLOGY OF HOW WE ARE

00:41:56.330 --> 00:41:58.330
DOUBLING DOWN IN ALL AREAS.

00:41:58.967 --> 00:42:00.967
THAT IT HAS, IN FACT, YIELDED RESULTS. WE CERTAINLY CANNOT

00:42:01.967 --> 00:42:03.967
PUT A PRICE ON THE SAFETY OF

00:42:07.967 --> 00:42:09.967
OUR RESIDENTS.

00:42:10.967 --> 00:42:12.967
WE KNOW WILDFIRES AT THE TOP OF EVERYONE'S MIND AS WE WENT THROUGH MORE THAN OUR FAIR

00:42:15.967 --> 00:42:17.967
SHARE. THIS SNAPSHOT IS VERY MUCH APPRECIATED.

00:42:18.167 --> 00:42:20.133
SUPERVISOR PEDROZA?
>> THANK YOU, CHAIR.

00:42:22.967 --> 00:42:24.967
ON THE GRAZING , CHIEF, THANK YOU FOR DOING THAT SPREAD AGAIN,

00:42:26.967 --> 00:42:28.967
THAT IS PART OF UNDERSTANDING EVERYTHING THAT IS HAPPENING. I THINK

00:42:31.967 --> 00:42:33.967
IT TAKE REACHING OUT TO A FEW OF THE FOLKS THAT DO THIS. WE HAVE A NETWORK. --AND

00:42:34.967 --> 00:42:36.967
JOHNNY WHITE.

00:42:37.967 --> 00:42:39.967
THEY WILL TELL YOU THE NUMBER, RIGHT? NOT INTERESTED IN REGULATING IT

00:42:42.967 --> 00:42:44.967
, BUT REALLY UNDERSTANDING WHAT IS HAPPENING.

00:42:45.967 --> 00:42:47.967
WHEN YOU'RE OUT THERE, YOU SEE IT HAPPENING AND I THINK IT

00:42:48.967 --> 00:42:50.967
IS A GOOD THING. I JUST WANTED TO PROVIDE YOU THAT. ON

00:42:52.967 --> 00:42:54.967
THE BURNING. I REALLY THINK THAT IS AN OPPORTUNITY

00:43:01.900 --> 00:43:04.900
TO ENSURE FOLKS UNDERSTAND ALL THE TOOLS IN THE TOOL BELT. ARE WE STILL DOING
CONTROLLED BURNS RIGHT NOW? OR DID THAT

00:43:05.533 --> 00:43:06.867
STOP?
>> OH, NO. THAT IS A REALLY GOOD SEGUE FOR A COUPLE THINGS.

00:43:09.900 --> 00:43:11.900
YES, WE'LL BE DOING SOME CONTROLLED BURNS.

00:43:12.900 --> 00:43:14.900
WE ARE COMING INTO THE WEATHER SEASON.
WE HAVE TO ENSURE IT IS IN PRESCRIPTION, RIGHT? BECAUSE

00:43:16.900 --> 00:43:18.900
WE ARE GOING OUT THERE. WE PUT FIRE ON THE GROUND

00:43:19.900 --> 00:43:21.900
AND WE ARE LOOKING FOR

00:43:24.900 --> 00:43:26.900
A PARTICULAR RESULT, RIGHT? WE DO NOT WANT A DIRTY BIRD PUT ON A

00:43:27.900 --> 00:43:29.900
CLEAN BURN AND WE WANT TO TAKE CARE OF THE DEAD AND DOWN FOR THAT IS I

00:43:31.900 --> 00:43:33.900
WOULD DO A BROADCAST FOR. WE HAVE A BROADCAST UNSCHEDULED

00:43:34.900 --> 00:43:36.900
FOR 41 ACRES IN THE LOWER --AREA AND ALSO IN --WHICH IS

00:43:40.900 --> 00:43:42.900
13 ACRES. WE'VE BEEN TRYING TO FIND THE WEATHER IN ORDER TO

00:43:44.900 --> 00:43:46.900
IMPLEMENT THOSE TWO WORDS, BUT THEY ARE PLANNED . ALTHOUGH

00:43:49.900 --> 00:43:51.900
LINES ARE PUT IN , ALL OF THAT HAS BEEN TAKEN CARE OF FOR

00:43:52.900 --> 00:43:54.900
THAT IS ON OUR RADAR . WE ARE LOOKING AT ALSO

00:43:56.133 --> 00:43:58.133
STARTING A PRESCRIBED BURNING ASSOCIATION, A PPA.

00:43:59.567 --> 00:44:01.567
THERE IS A LOT OF DISCUSSIONS WITH THAT AND

00:44:04.833 --> 00:44:06.833
THAT IS MORE TO COME WITH THAT.

00:44:10.833 --> 00:44:12.833
WE ARE LOOKING AT, AGAIN, PUTTING FIRE BACK
INTO OUR ENVIRONMENT LIKE WE USED TO BE ABLE TO DO ALL THE TIME. WE

00:44:15.833 --> 00:44:17.833
HAD A LOT OF REGULATORY ISSUES. THAT IS ONE OF THE

00:44:18.833 --> 00:44:20.833
TOOLS WE WILL BE DEPLOYING THROUGHOUT THE COMING YEAR

00:44:21.533 --> 00:44:22.833
.
>> IMAGINE SOMETHING THAT I LEARNED FOR TO DO A CONTROLLED

00:44:25.833 --> 00:44:27.833
BURN, YOU NEED TO DO

00:44:31.833 --> 00:44:33.833
CEQA.

00:44:34.833 --> 00:44:36.833
>> IT IS AN EMERGENCY. WHEN IT IS AN EMERGENCY -- AN I KNOW

00:44:40.833 --> 00:44:42.833
, BUT YOUR ., I'M HAVING A REALLY HARD TIME UNDERSTANDING THAT

00:44:43.833 --> 00:44:45.833
THIS IS A TOOL WE WANT TO USE RESPONSIBLY. BEING MINDFUL IT CREATES THINGS

00:44:46.833 --> 00:44:48.833
IN THE AIR. BUT

00:44:50.833 --> 00:44:53.833
WHEN A NATURAL DISASTER STRIKES, THE IMPACT IS THERE. SO THIS IS A TOOL
WE BELIEVE IN. I THINK WE NEED TO EXPLORE

00:44:55.833 --> 00:44:57.833
IF THIS IS SOMETHING THAT YOU

00:45:01.767 --> 00:45:03.767
, THE MAN WITH THE BADGE, SAYS IS A TOOL AND YOU BELIEVE WE

00:45:04.767 --> 00:45:06.767
SHOULD DO MORE OF IT IN NAPA COUNTY, THINK WE NEED TO

00:45:09.767 --> 00:45:11.767
FIND A WAY TO ENCOURAGE AND SUPPORT YOU DOING WORK FOR THE ONE THING I

00:45:12.767 --> 00:45:14.767
LEARNED FROM THE VERY BEGINNING, THE WAY YOU CHANGE FIRE IS TO MANAGE THE

00:45:19.233 --> 00:45:21.533
FIELD ALERT.
>> THAT IS TRUE. >> --

00:45:23.767 --> 00:45:26.767
>> THEY DO.
WE TOE THE LINE. AGAIN, WE HAVE TO PUT IN CONTROLS, RIGHT?
>> I COMPLETELY AGREE.

00:45:27.767 --> 00:45:30.767
>> THAT IS WERE THE CEQA REQUIREMENT COMES IN.
>> I WANTED TO UNDERSTAND WHAT THAT

00:45:33.767 --> 00:45:36.767
MEANS AND WHERE THE EXEMPTIONS MIGHT BE PAID IF YOU DO IT THROUGH CEQA
OR OF A PRIVATE PARTY DOESN'T, IT SOUNDS

00:45:38.767 --> 00:45:40.767
LIKE THERE MAY NOT BE PRESENT IS SOMETHING I AM REALLY INTERESTED

00:45:41.233 --> 00:45:42.467
IN
>> AS WE DEVELOP THE PBA'S AS IT IS CALLED,

00:45:44.767 --> 00:45:46.767
THE PRESCRIBED ASSOCIATIONS, THAT WILL

00:45:47.767 --> 00:45:49.767
AFFORD US SOME OF THE PRIVATE ENTITIES

00:45:52.767 --> 00:45:55.767
TO DO THOSE CONTROLLED BURNS UNDER CONTROLLED
CIRCUMSTANCE WITH GUIDANCE. THAT GIVES AS WE ARE TRYING TO STAND UP THOSE

00:45:58.733 --> 00:46:00.367
PROGRAMS.
>> I MADE MY . THERE. ON THE FIRE TRUCKS , I THINK THAT IS

00:46:05.700 --> 00:46:07.700
A REALLY COOL THING WE BRING OUT TO NEIGHBORHOODS ARE WE STILL

00:46:08.667 --> 00:46:10.733
GOING OUT TO SCHOOLS?
>> YES. BUT THAT IS ONE OF THOSE GAPS

00:46:14.700 --> 00:46:16.700
WE WANT TO INCREASE THAT PUBLIC EDUCATION COMPONENTS. OBVIOUSLY,

00:46:21.700 --> 00:46:23.700
FIRE PREVENTION EFFORTS IS NOT JUST, YOU KNOW,

00:46:25.700 --> 00:46:27.700
MOM AND DAD AND BUSINESS OWNERS. IT IS ALSO CHILDREN

00:46:28.700 --> 00:46:31.700
INVOLVED. BECAUSE I THINK, SEVERAL YEARS AGO, I
KIND OF APPROACH THE BOARD THAT THIS IS A SYSTEM APPROACH .

00:46:35.700 --> 00:46:37.700
THAT TAKES ALL PARTIES. IT IS THE CHILDREN , HOW THEY UNDERSTAND

00:46:38.700 --> 00:46:40.700
WHAT IS GOING ON. IN

00:46:42.700 --> 00:46:44.700
OUR CRAZY ENVIRONMENTS AND WHAT THEY CAN DO.

00:46:50.700 --> 00:46:52.700
HOW THEY GET PREPARED, HOW THEY REMIND THEIR PARENTS,

00:46:53.700 --> 00:46:56.700
ET CETERA. YES, THAT IS ON THE RADAR, FOR SURE.
>> I APPRECIATE IT BUT I LIKE YOU GOING INTO NEIGHBORHOODS

00:46:56.700 --> 00:46:59.700
AND GETTING ADULTS EXCITED ABOUT FIRE TRUCKS.
BUT I THINK GOING INTO THE SCHOOLS AND ARE

00:47:00.700 --> 00:47:02.700
EDUCATING OUR KIDS AND YOU SO THEY GROW UP WITH THIS MIND-SET AROUND FIRE. WE

00:47:03.700 --> 00:47:05.700
ARE DOING OPEN HOUSES AND I THINK WERE GOING TO DO THAT

00:47:08.700 --> 00:47:10.700
, AND EDUCATING OUR YOUTH AROUND IT IS GOOD. AND JUST THE LAST PART.

00:47:14.700 --> 00:47:16.700
WE TEND TO GLOSS OVER SOMETIMES THE IMPACT THAT OUR PARTNERS STUPID

00:47:18.700 --> 00:47:20.700
I THINK FOR THE WINE INDUSTRY TO CONTRIBUTE THE WAY THEY DID, I THINK

00:47:23.700 --> 00:47:25.700
IS INCREDIBLE. WE TALK ABOUT ENOUGH IS ENOUGH AND GROWTH

00:47:26.700 --> 00:47:28.700
BUT HERE'S AN EXAMPLE OF WHAT THIS INDUSTRY
IS DOING TO IMPROVE THE LIVES OF NAPA COUNTY RESIDENTS.

00:47:29.700 --> 00:47:31.700
>> YEAH, I CAN TELL YOU, AGAIN, THE AVERAGE WE

00:47:34.700 --> 00:47:36.700
HAVE DONE WITH A LOT OF OUR PARTNERS IN THE INDUSTRY

00:47:38.700 --> 00:47:40.700
HAS BEEN PHENOMENAL.

00:47:41.700 --> 00:47:43.700
I WILL USE SARAH -- IS THE ONE

00:47:47.700 --> 00:47:49.700
THAT COMES TO MIND.

00:47:50.700 --> 00:47:52.700
JUST WHAT WE DO, HOW DO WE DO THIS? WHAT IS THE BEST METHOD? THE

00:47:53.700 --> 00:47:56.700
BEST APPROACH?
SHE IS NOT JUST ARCTIC, BUT WENT VERY ALSO SHARED LESSONS LEARNED THROUGH

00:47:59.633 --> 00:48:01.633
THEIR PROCESS OF HOW

00:48:03.633 --> 00:48:05.633
THEY ARE REDUCING THEIR FUEL LOADING IN AND AROUND THEIR VINEYARDS AND

00:48:07.633 --> 00:48:09.633
THEIR INFRASTRUCTURE. THAT IS HOLDING RESILIENCY WITHIN OUR COMMUNITY. AS

00:48:11.633 --> 00:48:13.633
I SAID, HOW DO WE DESIGN , FROM THE

00:48:17.633 --> 00:48:19.633
FIRE PERSPECTIVE, VINES ARE CONTINUOUS MEANING THEY'LL

00:48:20.633 --> 00:48:22.633
TOUCH EACH OTHER. IF WE GET

00:48:25.633 --> 00:48:28.633
ALL OF THE PROPERTY OWNERS, THE LARGE PROPERTY
OWNERS IN THESE VINEYARDS INVOLVED IN THAT AS WELL,

00:48:32.633 --> 00:48:35.633
WE CAN START TO FILL IN THE GAPS THROUGH THEIR EFFORTS AND THEY
HAVE DONE A PHENOMENAL JOB. THE INDUSTRY HAS REALLY

00:48:37.633 --> 00:48:39.633
STOOD UP AND ASKED THE GREAT QUESTIONS OF HOW DO WE

00:48:41.633 --> 00:48:43.633
DO THIS AND HOW CAN WE DO THIS. THEY HAVE FUNDED IT. AND

00:48:46.633 --> 00:48:48.633
THEN EXECUTED AT A VERY HIGH LEVEL. WE ARE VERY THANKFUL. I CONTRIBUTE PART

00:48:49.633 --> 00:48:51.633
OF THAT TO THE RELATIONSHIPS WE GROW WITH THE GRAPE GROWERS

00:48:53.633 --> 00:48:55.633
IN ORDER TO HAVE THAT WITH QUESTIONS. HOW DO I GET

00:49:01.567 --> 00:49:03.567
THIS DONE OR WHAT IS GOING ON WITH THIS? WHAT YOU THINK ABOUT THIS? AND THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT

00:49:05.567 --> 00:49:07.567
WE WANT TO DO .

00:49:08.567 --> 00:49:10.567
>> I APPRECIATE IT. THANK YOU, CHIEF. >> SUPERVISOR GALLAGHER KIM ISOMETRIC

00:49:14.567 --> 00:49:16.567
YOU SO MUCH FOR THE REPORT . IT IS REALLY IMPRESSIVE

00:49:17.567 --> 00:49:19.567
TO SEE ESPECIALLY THE WORK THAT HAS BEEN

00:49:20.567 --> 00:49:22.567
DONE BETWEEN 2021 AND NOW. READY PHENOMENAL. I WANTED TO ASK ABOUT

00:49:26.567 --> 00:49:28.567
THE CAMERAS. YOU SAID THEY WERE REALLY HELPFUL. CAN YOU

00:49:29.567 --> 00:49:31.567
DIG IN A LITTLE MORE? I'M CURIOUS BECAUSE WE HAVE THOSE NOW AND IT IS

00:49:32.567 --> 00:49:35.567
NICE TO HEAR MORE ABOUT HOW THEY ACTUALLY HELPED.
>> YEAH, WE HAD A

00:49:38.567 --> 00:49:40.567
VERY LIGHT FIRE SEASON. I HAVE STATS FOR THIS YOU

00:49:41.567 --> 00:49:43.567
ONLY HAD 670 ACRES WITHIN THE ENTIRE UNIT.

00:49:44.567 --> 00:49:46.567
THAT IS BETWEEN SIX COUNTIES. THAT IS A

00:49:47.567 --> 00:49:49.567
REALLY LIGHT FIRE SEASON, ESPECIALLY FOR THIS REGION.

00:49:50.567 --> 00:49:52.567
BUT THE AI CAMERAS IN THE PROCESS THEY PUT

00:49:58.500 --> 00:50:00.500
WE WERE TASKED FOR THE ALERT CALIFORNIA SYSTEM.
SO YOU JUST NEVER KNOW HOW THAT IS GOING TO WORK. THERE

00:50:05.500 --> 00:50:07.500
WERE A FEW LITTLE HICCUPS ALONG THE WAY. THAT IS WHY WE WERE CHOSEN

00:50:08.500 --> 00:50:10.500
TO PARTICIPATE IN THIS.

00:50:11.500 --> 00:50:13.500
WE FOUND THAT THE CAMERAS, ONCE THEY ARE ALERTED,

00:50:14.500 --> 00:50:16.500
THEY NOTIFY EMERGENCY COMMAND CENTER, SOMETIMES JUST PRIOR TO ANY

00:50:19.500 --> 00:50:21.500
OTHER ALERT. THEY HELPED US TO DEFINE THE EXACT LOCATION. SOMETIMES

00:50:26.500 --> 00:50:28.500
IT IS IS BASED IN THE AREA OF HER KIND OF UP ON THE

00:50:29.500 --> 00:50:31.500
HILL OR WHAT HAVE YOU. THEY GAVE US SOME VISION AND

00:50:32.500 --> 00:50:34.500
IT WAS A VERY USEFUL TOOL AND THE FOLKS ON THE BACK END

00:50:37.500 --> 00:50:39.500
OF ALERT CALIFORNIA CONTINUED TO MAKE CHANGES TO THAT PROGRAM TO

00:50:40.500 --> 00:50:42.500
ENHANCE OUR ABILITY TO LEVERAGE THAT SYSTEM. WE CAN SEE

00:50:44.500 --> 00:50:46.500
THIS SYSTEM WILL CONTINUE WHICH IS STATEWIDE. IT

00:50:48.500 --> 00:50:50.500
WILL CONTINUE WITH ITS GROWTH AND CAPABILITIES AS WE MOVE FORWARD.

00:50:53.500 --> 00:50:55.500
>> SUPERVISOR COTTRELL THANK YOU, CHIEF MARTIN, FOR ALL

00:51:01.433 --> 00:51:03.433
THIS INFORMATION. PARTICULARLY YOUR WILLINGNESS TO DIVE INTO SPECIFIC INFORMATION

00:51:05.433 --> 00:51:07.433
AND DATA POINTS.

00:51:08.433 --> 00:51:10.433
I THINK WE GOT TO HAVE YOU VISIT SEVERAL

00:51:13.433 --> 00:51:15.433
TIMES OVER THE PAST YEAR AND IT IS GETTING RICHER AND RICHER IN TERMS
OF DATA. THAT IS REALLY HELP WILL AS

00:51:17.433 --> 00:51:20.433
WE WORK THROUGH THIS YEAR. AND TO THE
. ABOUT GATHERING INFORMATION ON THE GRAZING. WE KNOW

00:51:22.433 --> 00:51:24.433
IT IS OUT THERE . SO TAPPING INTO THE NETWORK

00:51:26.433 --> 00:51:28.433
THAT CAN HELP US MAP OUT ALL THOSE ACRES

00:51:29.433 --> 00:51:31.433
MAKES IT AN EVEN MORE COMPELLING STORY. THAT WOULD BE GREAT

00:51:32.433 --> 00:51:34.433
TO SEE. AND UPON

00:51:38.433 --> 00:51:40.433
PRICHARD HILL . WHAT THEY HAVE DONE IS AMAZING TO

00:51:42.433 --> 00:51:44.433
SEE. AND SO HOW WE CAPTURE ALL OF THAT IN OUR OWN DATABASES TOO

00:51:45.433 --> 00:51:47.433
I'M INTERESTED IN PUT A COUPLE QUESTIONS. SO

00:51:48.433 --> 00:51:50.433
YOU MENTION ALL THOSE INSPECTIONS. WHAT DO WE HAVE

00:51:54.433 --> 00:51:56.433
DATA ABOUT IF SOMEONE GOES OUT AND DOES AN INSPECTION

00:51:57.367 --> 00:51:59.367
UNTIL IS A RESIDENT WHAT THEY NEED TO DO ? IT IS GREAT WE HAVE A

00:52:00.367 --> 00:52:02.367
CERTIFICATE PROGRAM NOW BECAUSE WE CAN KIND OF CLOSE THAT AND

00:52:04.367 --> 00:52:06.367
SAY THE WORK WAS DONE. DO YOU HAVE A SENSE

00:52:08.367 --> 00:52:10.367
OF WHAT PERCENTAGE OF FOLKS ARE GETTING THOSE INSPECTIONS AND DOING 90% OF

00:52:13.367 --> 00:52:15.367
THE WORK? YOU KNOW, THE EFFECTIVENESS OR

00:52:20.367 --> 00:52:22.367
THE FOLLOWING THREE OF THOSE INSPECTIONS?
>> WELL, THE EFFECTIVENESS AS WE HAVE A VERY

00:52:27.367 --> 00:52:29.367
ROBUST ABATEMENT.

00:52:32.367 --> 00:52:34.367
THAT ORDINANCE WITHIN THE COUNTY.
WE HAVE NOT ONLY THE PUBLIC RESOURCES , BUT WE HAVE ENHANCEMENTS

00:52:36.367 --> 00:52:38.367
TO THAT.

00:52:39.367 --> 00:52:41.367
AND IF THEY ARE RECEIVING A CERTIFICATE , AND/OR

00:52:43.367 --> 00:52:46.367
IF THERE ARE VIOLATIONS AND WE HAVE TO DO THE FOLLOW-UP, I WOULD THINK
WE HAVE OUT OF THAT , THERE IS ABOUT

00:52:48.367 --> 00:52:50.367
A 90% COMPLIANCY FOR THAT. THAT IS JUST

00:52:53.367 --> 00:52:55.367
KIND OF BASED ON HOW MANY WARRANTS WE HAVE

00:52:57.300 --> 00:52:59.300
TO HAVE THE PROPERTIES ABATED. THE PROPERTIES

00:53:03.300 --> 00:53:05.300
WE HAVE TO GO IN AND ABATE ARE THOSE PROPERTY OWNERS THAT ARE

00:53:06.300 --> 00:53:08.300
FAILING TO DO ANYTHING WITH THEIR PROPERTY. THEY POSE A RISK TO

00:53:09.300 --> 00:53:11.300
THE COMMUNITY. IT IS A VERY HIGH SUCCESS

00:53:15.300 --> 00:53:17.300
TOTAL. IT TAKES A LOT OF STAFF AND ALERT TO CANVAS THE

00:53:18.300 --> 00:53:20.300
COUNTY, ALONG WITH OUR ENGINE COMPANIES. AGAIN, WE

00:53:22.300 --> 00:53:24.300
ARE STARTING TO, WE LOOK AT THAT AND WE LOOK AT THE STAFFING MODELS.

00:53:27.300 --> 00:53:29.300
WE ARE ADJUSTING THOSE MODELS APPROPRIATELY TO ENSURE WE HAVE

00:53:33.300 --> 00:53:35.300
THE HIGHEST IMPACT POSSIBLE TO GO OUT INTO THOSE COMMUNITIES.

00:53:36.300 --> 00:53:38.300
WE HAVE A COUPLE OF ISSUES WHERE WE GET

00:53:39.300 --> 00:53:41.300
SOME CALLS UP WHERE WE HAVE NOT BEEN ABLE TO COME

00:53:43.300 --> 00:53:45.300
OUT AND DO THE REINSPECTIONS. AGAIN, THAT IS BASED OFF

00:53:48.300 --> 00:53:50.300
OF STAFFING.

00:53:51.300 --> 00:53:53.300
ONE WAY WE ADDRESS THAT IS THROUGH OUR PUBLIC EDUCATION CAMPAIGNS.

00:53:54.300 --> 00:53:56.300
THE TOOLS AND WHAT TYPE OF TOOLS THAT WAY, PEOPLE CAN

00:54:02.233 --> 00:54:04.233
REFERENCE THEM SO IF WE DO A DRIVE-BY OR WALK TO THE COMMUNITIES, THEY ALREADY

00:54:06.233 --> 00:54:08.233
ARE COMPLIANT. THAT DOES NOT REQUIRE

00:54:08.267 --> 00:54:10.233
A WALK AND TALK.
>> THAT IS REALLY IMPRESSIVE. I'M LOOKING AT THIS NUMBER

00:54:15.233 --> 00:54:17.233
OF OVER 2500 INSPECTIONS . YOU'RE SAYING OVER 90% OF THOSE

00:54:21.233 --> 00:54:23.233
WILL BE INTO COMPLIANCE. THAT IS OVER --RESIDENTS'S

00:54:25.900 --> 00:54:27.900
THAT ARE COMPLIANT NOW.

00:54:28.670 --> 00:54:30.670
>> THEY ARE SUPPORTED BY FIRE

00:54:36.233 --> 00:54:38.233
SAFETY COUNCILS AS WELL. THAT IS PART OF WHAT WE GIVE TO THEM.

00:54:44.233 --> 00:54:47.233
HE, THIS IS HOW THIS IS DONE FOR THESE ARE THE REQUIREMENTS AND WE NEED
YOU TO SPREAD THE WORD. AGAIN, IT IS THAT NECK OR WE HAVE ESTABLISHED

00:54:48.233 --> 00:54:50.233
WITHIN THIS COUNTY WITH THE 21 FIRE SAFE

00:54:51.233 --> 00:54:53.233
COUNCILS THAT GIVES US THE GATEWAY OR THE DOORWAY INTO EACH

00:54:55.233 --> 00:54:57.233
OF THESE COMMUNITIES. IF I DO NOT HAVE THE STAFFING TO

00:54:59.167 --> 00:55:02.167
DO THIS BUT I HAVE A . OF CONTACT TO HELP SPREAD THE
WORD, IF YOU WILL, WE ARE FINDING THAT BY LEVERAGING THAT,

00:55:06.167 --> 00:55:08.167
WE ARE HAVING GREATER SUCCESS ACROSS THE COUNTY.

00:55:09.167 --> 00:55:11.167
>> GOT IT . MY LAST TWO QUESTIONS, I

00:55:13.167 --> 00:55:15.167
KNOW THE MORE WE ARE INTO THIS WORK, THE HIGHER THE PERCENTAGE

00:55:18.167 --> 00:55:20.167
AS OPPOSED TO INITIAL.

00:55:21.167 --> 00:55:23.167
CAN YOU GIVE US A SENSE OF WHERE WE ARE IN THAT? HOW MUCH OF THIS IS REALLY

00:55:27.167 --> 00:55:29.167
HOW MUCH YOU DO AND HOW MUCH OF IT IS

00:55:29.400 --> 00:55:31.000
NO WORK?
>> IF I CAN KIND OF BRING IT DOWN THE

00:55:35.167 --> 00:55:37.167
BEST I CAN, IF I LOOK AT THE WORK WE DID IN YEAR ONE

00:55:39.167 --> 00:55:41.167
AND COMING INTO YOUR THREE, WE ARE TAKING ON THE NEXT YEAR, BUT

00:55:42.167 --> 00:55:44.167
WE HAVE TO GO BACK TO THE YEAR ONE WORK AND DO THE

00:55:45.167 --> 00:55:47.167
MAINTENANCE ON THOSE PROJECTS.

00:55:48.167 --> 00:55:50.167
SO IT IS USUALLY ABOUT A TWO TO CO-THREE-YEAR

00:55:54.167 --> 00:55:56.167
CYCLE. EACH ONE OF AND DO THE CLEANUP. HOWEVER, WHEN

00:55:57.100 --> 00:55:59.100
THEY TALK ABOUT MAINTENANCE COMPARED TO THE

00:56:00.100 --> 00:56:02.100
INITIAL PROJECT , THE MAINTENANCE WILL BE LESS THAN

00:56:04.100 --> 00:56:06.100
THE INITIAL PROJECT BECAUSE WE ARE NOT DEALING WITH AS MUCH OF THE

00:56:08.100 --> 00:56:10.100
HEAVIES. MEANING DOWN RINGING DOWN THE TREES.

00:56:12.100 --> 00:56:14.100
THE LIMBS , THE GREAT BRUSH PATCHES, ET CETERA. WE ARE JUST

00:56:17.100 --> 00:56:19.100
CLEANING UP SOME OF THE NEW GROWTH AND SOME THAT

00:56:21.100 --> 00:56:23.100
MAY HAVE FALLEN THROUGH THE STORMS AND WHAT HAVE YOU. SO THAT IS REALLY WHAT

00:56:24.100 --> 00:56:26.100
IT IS. I YEAR ONE, THOSE PROJECTS ARE FALLING

00:56:30.100 --> 00:56:32.100
INTO MAINTENANCE AND YOUR THREE, WE ARE STARTING YOUR FOUR THIS YEAR.

00:56:33.100 --> 00:56:35.100
ACTUALLY, WE ARE IN YEAR THREE NOW. SO NEXT

00:56:38.100 --> 00:56:40.100
YEAR, WE WILL GO INTO YOUR TWO AND START THAT MAINTENANCE, ET

00:56:41.300 --> 00:56:42.867
CETERA.
>> GOT IT. THANK YOU. YOU MENTIONED

00:56:45.100 --> 00:56:47.100
THIS WORK IN THE CWPP.

00:56:48.100 --> 00:56:51.100
WE ARE TACKLING THOSE CHORES.
I THINK WHAT WOULD BE INTERESTING FOR A FUTURE PRESENTATION IS TO KIND

00:56:54.100 --> 00:56:56.100
OF TRACK THIS DATA

00:56:59.100 --> 00:57:01.100
AGAINST THE CWPP SO WE CAN SEE WHICH PROJECTS

00:57:02.100 --> 00:57:04.100
WE KNOCKED OUT AND WHICH ONE WERE IN MAINTENANCE MODE, THINGS LIKE

00:57:05.100 --> 00:57:07.100
THAT. TO GET A SENSE OF WHAT THE UNIVERSE IS OF THE

00:57:08.600 --> 00:57:10.167
CWPP.
>> THAT IS ONE MAP I DID NOT

00:57:14.100 --> 00:57:16.100
HAVE IN MY PRESENTATION. WE JUST MISSED IT.
>> BUT THERE WERE A LOT OF GREAT MAPS.

00:57:18.100 --> 00:57:20.100
>> YES, THERE WAS .

00:57:21.100 --> 00:57:23.100
>> FINALLY, ALL OF THIS DATA HELPS

00:57:24.100 --> 00:57:26.100
US SO WE ARE DOING RISK PREVENTION ACROSS THE COUNTY WHICH

00:57:27.100 --> 00:57:29.100
MAKES US ALL SAFER. BUT ALSO, HOPEFULLY, IT SHOWED

00:57:30.100 --> 00:57:32.100
IMPACT INSURANCE AT SOME POINT. WE HAVE A

00:57:36.100 --> 00:57:38.100
GIS LAYER THAT WE CAN DEVELOP AND CONTINUE TO MAINTAIN

00:57:39.100 --> 00:57:41.100
THAT HELPS SHOW ALL THIS

00:57:41.400 --> 00:57:43.400
KIND OF PREDICTION IN RISK?

00:57:43.967 --> 00:57:45.967
>> WE DO. ALL OF THESE PROJECTS

00:57:48.100 --> 00:57:51.100
ARE MAPPED.
THE IMPACTS OF ALL THE ACREAGE, THE TREATED ACREAGE,

00:57:54.100 --> 00:57:56.100
IS MAPPED.

00:57:57.330 --> 00:57:59.330
WE HAVE THAT DATA.

00:58:00.330 --> 00:58:02.330
AGAIN, IF I HAD THE MAP YOU'RE LOOKING FOR, WHICH I CAN SHARE WITH

00:58:03.330 --> 00:58:05.330
YOU LATER, THAT SHOWS EXACTLY WHERE WE HAVE

00:58:07.330 --> 00:58:09.330
DONE THOSE REDUCTIONS, ESPECIALLY AROUND OUR COMMUNITIES, THE RISK REDUCTION, IF

00:58:12.330 --> 00:58:14.330
YOU WILL. YES, THAT IS AVAILABLE. WE ARE STILL TRYING

00:58:19.330 --> 00:58:21.330
TO WORK ON THIS BROADCAST. THE WORK WE ARE DOING

00:58:22.330 --> 00:58:24.330
WITHIN THE COUNTY. AND THAT ALSO TAKES YOU

00:58:28.330 --> 00:58:30.330
FROM THE COMMUNICATIONS YOU HAVE OUTSIDE OF

00:58:34.330 --> 00:58:37.330
NAPA COUNTY. THESE ARE THE THINGS WE ARE DOING IN THESE ARE
THE EXAMPLES. WE ARE TRYING TO DO THE BEST

00:58:38.330 --> 00:58:40.330
WE CAN TO SUPPORT THAT BY POSTING WHAT WE CAN'T TO SHOW HIGHLIGHTS ON

00:58:41.330 --> 00:58:44.330
THE EFFORTS WE HAVE PUT IN WITHIN THE COUNTY.
>> THANK YOU SO MUCH.

00:58:45.330 --> 00:58:47.330
>> YOU'RE WELCOME. >> THANK YOU.

00:58:48.330 --> 00:58:50.330
QUICK QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD. SEEING NO OTHERS, I WILL OPEN PUBLIC COMMENT

00:58:52.330 --> 00:58:54.330
ON THIS ITEM. THING NONE

00:58:57.967 --> 00:58:59.967
LINES. THANK YOU. I WILL CLOSE PUBLIC COMMENT.

00:59:00.967 --> 00:59:02.967
>> I HAVE A GO BACK AT THE END.

00:59:03.967 --> 00:59:05.967
>> YOU HAVE A GO BACK? WHERE YOU GOING?

00:59:09.967 --> 00:59:12.967
>> TO COME BACK. >> [ LAUGHTER ] >> YES , TO ACTUALLY GO BACK.
>> EXCELLENT.

00:59:15.967 --> 00:59:17.967
THANK YOU SO MUCH, CHIEF GOOD WE REALLY APPRECIATE THIS RECAP.

00:59:21.967 --> 00:59:23.967
AGAIN, CONGRATULATIONS ON THE NEW OFFICE.

00:59:24.967 --> 00:59:26.967
AND REMEMBER, AN OFFICE CAT.

00:59:27.967 --> 00:59:29.967
>> YES, I WANT

00:59:31.967 --> 00:59:33.967
TO LEAVE ONE THING WITH THE COMMUNITY AS WE GET INTO THE MORE WET MONTHS.

00:59:34.967 --> 00:59:36.967
WE MADE IT THROUGH THE FIRE SEASON.

00:59:37.967 --> 00:59:39.967
THERE WAS NOT MUCH OF AN IMPACT AND WE CAN KIND

00:59:41.967 --> 00:59:43.967
OF RELAX. I WANT TO REMIND EVERYBODY WE ARE STARTING OUR PROCESS OVER AGAIN.

00:59:45.967 --> 00:59:47.967
AS WE MOVE INTO THE WINTER MONTHS, THAT

00:59:48.967 --> 00:59:50.967
IS WHEN WE START TO DEAL WITH ALL OF THE HEAVIES. THAT IS CLEANING

00:59:51.967 --> 00:59:53.967
UP THE BRUSH AND YOUR TREES AND RAKING UP OUR LAWNS AND REDUCING

00:59:54.967 --> 00:59:56.967
THE HEAVIER MODELS TO GET READY FOR SHIPPING

00:59:57.900 --> 00:59:59.900
IN THE SPRINGTIME. SO THAT ALL OF

01:00:01.900 --> 01:00:03.900
THAT STUFF IS TAKEN CARE OF AS WE MOVE INTO

01:00:05.900 --> 01:00:07.900
THE DRYER PART OF THE SEASON AFTER THE FIRST OF THE YEAR, SOMEWHERE INTO

01:00:12.900 --> 01:00:14.900
APRIL OR MAY. AND THEN WE START TO ADDRESS THAT SO WE ARE READY

01:00:15.900 --> 01:00:17.900
FOR FIRE SEASON COME JUNE. THAT IS FOR EACH ONE OF

01:00:18.900 --> 01:00:20.900
THE HOMEOWNERS . THAT WAY, WE ARE TAKING A BREAK IN

01:00:21.900 --> 01:00:23.900
THE SUMMER MONTHS AND WE ARE PREPARED FOR OUR

01:00:27.900 --> 01:00:29.900
WILDFIRE SEASON. THAT IS ALL I HAPPEN AGAIN, THANK YOU VERY MUCH TO

01:00:30.900 --> 01:00:32.900
THE BOARD. THANK YOU AGAIN FOR THE TREMENDOUS SUPPORT THE COUNTY

01:00:33.900 --> 01:00:36.500
HAS PROVIDED IN ORDER TO MEET FIRE
RESILIENCY.

01:00:36.500 --> 01:00:38.500
>> THANK YOU SO MUCH, CHIEF.

01:00:39.900 --> 01:00:41.900
THAT CONCLUDES OUR ITEM 11 A. NEXT,

01:00:45.900 --> 01:00:47.900
I WILL GO AHEAD AND CALL UP ITEM 13 A

01:00:51.900 --> 01:00:53.900
FOR THE AGRICULTURAL PRESERVES AND CONTRACTS

01:01:00.833 --> 01:01:03.233
FOR 2023.
WELCOME.

01:01:03.533 --> 01:01:05.533
>> THANK YOU. GOOD MORNING.

01:01:08.833 --> 01:01:10.833
>> GOOD MORNING.
>> OKAY.

01:01:12.833 --> 01:01:14.833
OH, GOOD MORNING.

01:01:15.833 --> 01:01:17.833
GOOD MORNING, CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE BOARD. I'M FROM PLANNING

01:01:21.833 --> 01:01:23.833
AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES. THIS ITEM IS THE NEW

01:01:25.833 --> 01:01:27.833
TRAVERTINE RESERVE CONTRACT AGREEMENT . THIS WOULD BRING APPROXIMATELY 155

01:01:33.833 --> 01:01:35.833
-- INTO THE ACT WITHIN THREE NEW ACT PRESERVE CONTRACTS. THERE

01:01:36.833 --> 01:01:38.833
ARE TWO REPLACED PRENUP CONTRACTS

01:01:42.833 --> 01:01:44.833
FROM A --WE ARE LOOKING AT ADOPTION OF THE RESOLUTION

01:01:47.833 --> 01:01:49.833
TO APPROVED IDENTIFIED CONTRACTS .
STAFF IS AVAILABLE FOR QUESTIONS. THANK

01:01:51.533 --> 01:01:53.670
YOU.
>> THANK YOU.

01:01:57.767 --> 01:01:59.767
THIS IS A PUBLIC HEARING AND I WILL ASK IF THE BOARD HAS ANY QUESTIONS

01:02:00.767 --> 01:02:02.767
ON THIS ITEM.

01:02:03.767 --> 01:02:05.767
SEEING NONE, I WILL GO TO PUBLIC COMMENT.

01:02:09.767 --> 01:02:12.767
NONE OF THE BOARDROOM. ANY ON THE PHONE
LINES TO MARK THANK YOU. I WILL CLOSE PUBLIC COMMENT AND THE PUBLIC HEARING

01:02:15.767 --> 01:02:17.767
I WILL BRING IT BACK TO THE BOARD. REQUESTED ACTION IS ADOPTION

01:02:18.767 --> 01:02:20.767
OF THE RESOLUTION.

01:02:21.767 --> 01:02:23.767
THAT WOULD COME BACK TO.

01:02:24.767 --> 01:02:26.767
>> SO MOVED >> SECOND. >> IVA MOTION BY SUPERVISOR GREGORY

01:02:32.767 --> 01:02:35.100
AND GOING TO SUPERVISOR COTTRELL.
ALL THOSE IN FAVOR?
>> AYE .

01:02:35.767 --> 01:02:37.767
>> OPPOSED? THE MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. THANK YOU SO MUCH .

01:02:39.767 --> 01:02:41.767
>> THANK YOU.

01:02:42.767 --> 01:02:44.767
>> NEXT, WE WILL TAKE A SHORT 10 MINUTE BREAK KNOWING OUR

01:02:47.767 --> 01:02:49.767
NEXT ITEM WILL BE A LITTLE LONGER.
THE NEXT ITEM WILL BE 13 B. THAT IS OUR

01:02:53.767 --> 01:02:55.767
PUBLIC HEARING FOR 9:00 A.M. AND THEN WE WILL GO BACK TO

01:02:57.700 --> 01:02:59.700
11 B AND 11 C.

01:04:23.600 --> 01:04:25.600
WE ARE NOW BACK FROM OUR RECESS.

01:04:26.933 --> 01:04:28.933
I'M GOING TO EXERCISE SOME PRIVILEGE HERE AND REOPEN PUBLIC COMMENT ON ITEM 11-A.

01:04:35.330 --> 01:04:37.330
THAT WAS THE DEPUTY COUNTY FIRE CHIEF'S REPORT

01:04:37.600 --> 01:04:39.600
BECAUSE I KNOW MICHELLE W. FROM THE VITTNER'S

01:04:40.533 --> 01:04:42.533
HAS SOMETHING TO SHARE WITH US RELATED TO THAT.

01:04:43.533 --> 01:04:45.533
AND OUR TIMING DIDN'T QUITE WORK OUT,

01:04:46.330 --> 01:04:48.330
SO I WOULD RECOGNIZE MISS W. FOR A FEW MINUTES.

01:04:48.600 --> 01:04:50.600
>> THANK YOU, CHAIR RAMOS AND THANK YOU, SUPERVISORS.

01:04:52.300 --> 01:04:54.300
FIRST AND FOREMOST, I JUST WANTED TO ACKNOWLEDGE THE PRESENTATION

01:04:56.833 --> 01:04:58.833
GIVEN BY CHIEF MARTIN AND SAY HOW WONDERFUL IT WAS TO SEE

01:05:01.733 --> 01:05:03.733
THOSE EXTRAORDINARY NUMBERS AND ALL THE PROGRESS THAT'S BEEN

01:05:03.933 --> 01:05:06.700
ACHIEVED IN OUR COMMUNITY.
IT IS REALLY AMAZING WHAT CAN HAPPEN WHEN WE ARE WORKING TOGETHER AND

01:05:10.400 --> 01:05:12.400
PULLING IN THE SAME DIRECTION. I SO WANTED TO ACKNOWLEDGE CHIEF MARTIN PERSONALLY

01:05:15.400 --> 01:05:17.400
FOR HIS PARTNERSHIP AND RESPONSIVENESS TO SPECIFICALLY

01:05:21.400 --> 01:05:23.400
MY ORGANIZATION, THE NAPA VALLEY --

01:05:29.400 --> 01:05:32.400
. WE MADE THIS OUR NUMBER ONE PRIORITY SINCE THE FIRES IN 2020
BUT WHENEVER THERE IS AN ISSUE, A TEXT, A CALL, IT IS

01:05:34.400 --> 01:05:37.400
ALWAYS RETURN SO QUICKLY AND HE ALWAYS HAS INFORMATION FOR US IN WAYS TO
MOVE FORWARD. SO CHIEF MARTIN, THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

01:05:39.400 --> 01:05:41.400
I WANTED TO FOLLOW-UP ON SOMETHING THAT SUPERVISOR

01:05:42.400 --> 01:05:44.400
PEDROZA RAISED , WHICH IS INVOLVING OUR COMMUNITY

01:05:48.400 --> 01:05:50.400
CHILDREN IN FIREFIGHTING AND LEARNING ABOUT THE IMPORTANCE OF FIRE SAFETY

01:05:53.400 --> 01:05:55.400
. ALTHOUGH THIS IS NOT AN HOUR PROMOTION PLAN

01:05:56.400 --> 01:05:58.400
TIME SCHEDULE, I WANTED TO LET YOU KNOW

01:06:00.330 --> 01:06:02.330
NOW THAT IN PARTNERSHIP WITH CWPP , NAPA VALLEY FIRE, AND THE

01:06:07.333 --> 01:06:09.333
NAPA VALLEY GRAPE GROWERS AND THE NAPA VALLEY --WILL

01:06:11.333 --> 01:06:14.333
BE BRINGING BACK OUR FIRE RESOURCE FAIR EARLIER IN THE ART NEXT
YEAR. THIS YEAR IT IS GOING TO BE ON THE SATURDAY. MARCH 16th

01:06:18.333 --> 01:06:20.333
AT THE NAPA COUNTY

01:06:23.333 --> 01:06:25.333
EXPO AT 10:00 A.M. UNTIL 2:00 P.M.

01:06:28.333 --> 01:06:30.333
WITH A SPECIFIC FOCUS ON CHILDREN. ANIMALS AND FIRETRUCKS

01:06:33.333 --> 01:06:35.333
AND I THINK I MAY HAVE HEARD WORD THAT SMOKEY THE BEAR MAY MAKE

01:06:36.333 --> 01:06:38.333
AN APPEARANCE AS WELL. WE ARE --GOING TO BE DOING A

01:06:41.333 --> 01:06:43.333
LOT OF PROMOTION AROUND THAT IN THE INDUSTRY

01:06:44.333 --> 01:06:46.333
TO PARTICIPATE AND COME CONNECT WITH THE VENDORS AND

01:06:48.333 --> 01:06:50.333
LEARN ABOUT HOW TO HARDEN YOUR PROPERTY, CREATE

01:06:51.333 --> 01:06:53.333
DEFENSIBLE SPACE, SO ON AND SO FORTH. I WANTED TO GIVE

01:06:54.333 --> 01:06:56.333
THOSE BRIEF UPDATES AND THANK YOU FOR ALL THE

01:06:57.333 --> 01:06:59.333
WORK YOU ARE DOING AS SUPERVISORS AND TO NAPA COUNTY FIRE

01:07:00.233 --> 01:07:02.167
BUREAU THANK YOU.
>> THANK YOU.

01:07:05.367 --> 01:07:07.367
AND MIGHT 1980s CHILDHOOD HEART IS EXCITED ABOUT SMOKEY THE BEAR BUT

01:07:09.267 --> 01:07:11.267
I WILL CLOSE PUBLIC COMMENT AND BRING US BACK TO OUR REGULAR PROGRAM.

01:07:15.267 --> 01:07:17.267
NEXT, I WILL CALL ITEM 13 B.

01:07:18.267 --> 01:07:20.267
THIS IS A PUBLIC HEARING INN AT THE ABBEY DEVELOPMENT

01:07:27.267 --> 01:07:29.267
. THIS IS REGARDING THE TERMS OF THE DEVELOPMENT

01:07:31.267 --> 01:07:33.267
AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE COUNTY OF NAPA AND JACKSON

01:07:36.267 --> 01:07:38.267
FAMILY INVESTMENTS LLC , THE APPLICANT, REGARDING THEIR EXISTING USE

01:07:39.267 --> 01:07:41.267
OR MODIFICATION . THIS ITSELF

01:07:45.400 --> 01:07:47.400
IS NOT A DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT. I THINK THIS IS MORE

01:07:48.267 --> 01:07:50.267
WE CAN LINK TOWARD THE INTENT TO NEGOTIATE THE TERMS OF AN ELEMENT

01:07:51.267 --> 01:07:53.267
AGREEMENT THAT THIS IS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR THE

01:07:57.267 --> 01:07:59.267
BOARD TO REALLY SAY WHAT THEY WOULD LIKE TO SEE

01:08:03.200 --> 01:08:05.200
OF WHAT WE CONSIDER TO BE THOSE PUBLIC BENEFITS FROM

01:08:09.200 --> 01:08:11.200
THE ACTUAL REQUESTED ACT . AT THIS TIME,

01:08:15.200 --> 01:08:17.200
WAIT A SECOND.

01:08:18.200 --> 01:08:20.200
JUST ONE SECOND.

01:08:21.200 --> 01:08:23.200
I CLICKED ON THE ONE --THE WRONG ONE.

01:08:24.200 --> 01:08:26.200
WAIT A SECOND. AT THIS TIME, JOINING US FOR OUR

01:08:30.200 --> 01:08:32.200
PRESENTATION IS MR. HAWKES . I WILL OPEN THE PUBLIC HEARING AND

01:08:33.500 --> 01:08:35.500
HANDED OVER.

01:08:36.733 --> 01:08:38.733
>> THANK YOU, CHAIR. MEMBER TO THE

01:08:40.667 --> 01:08:42.667
BOARD OF PROVIDES A TREVOR HAWKES.
I AM THE PLANNING SUPERVISOR FOR --MODIFICATION.

01:08:47.667 --> 01:08:49.667
THAT IS KNOWN AS THE INN AT THE ABBEY.

01:08:53.667 --> 01:08:56.667
THIS IS AN ITEM, AS THE CHAIR MENTIONED, AS
REQUESTED BY STAFF FOR DISCUSSION AND

01:08:57.667 --> 01:08:59.667
DIRECTION FROM THE BOARD ON PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT TERMS FOR THE

01:09:02.600 --> 01:09:04.600
INN AT THE ABBEY PROJECT. NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

01:09:08.600 --> 01:09:10.600
THIS IS A MAJOR MODIFICATION TO AN EXISTING
USE PERMIT VITEK SEEKS APPROVAL TO DEMOLISH THE EXISTING BUILDINGS AND

01:09:11.600 --> 01:09:13.600
IN THEIR PLACE DEVELOP A SITE AT THE 79 ROOM HOTEL.

01:09:17.600 --> 01:09:19.600
THIS INCLUDES HOTEL RETAIL , HOTEL LAWN SPACE,

01:09:23.600 --> 01:09:25.600
SPOT AND TREATMENT ROOMS, POOLS, UNDERGROUND PARKING GARAGE,

01:09:28.600 --> 01:09:30.600
FITNESS ROOM, OUTDOOR LAWN SPACE, AND GATHERING SPACE ,

01:09:32.600 --> 01:09:34.600
BACK OF HOUSE USES, AND ON-SITE USING. THIS IS

01:09:37.600 --> 01:09:39.600
APPROVED BY STAFF IN FEBRUARY 2019.
SINCE THEN, THE EQUITATION --THE APPLICATION HAS BEEN FOUND

01:09:44.600 --> 01:09:46.600
BY STEPPING AND NOTICE OF PREPARATION OF THE EIR WAS

01:09:47.600 --> 01:09:49.600
PUBLISHED IN THE NAPA VALLEY REGISTRAR AND REGISTERED

01:09:53.600 --> 01:09:55.600
WITHIN 1000 FEET OF THE PROPERTY AND INTERESTED PARTIES. ON AUGUST

01:09:56.600 --> 01:09:58.600
5, 2020, THE EIR --NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

01:10:02.533 --> 01:10:04.533
THIS IS A 15 ACRE PARCEL SPANNING SIX PARCELS.

01:10:07.533 --> 01:10:09.533
FOUR OF THOSE PARCELS ARE SITUATED NORTHEAST OF

01:10:12.533 --> 01:10:14.533
THE INTERSECTION OF --AND SR 29

01:10:16.533 --> 01:10:18.533
AND TWO REMAINING PARCELS ARE SOUTH OF SR

01:10:21.533 --> 01:10:24.533
29 INTERSECTION.
TWO OF THE PARCELS NORTH OF THE INTERSECTION FULLY

01:10:25.533 --> 01:10:27.533
ENCOMPASSED THE COMMERCIAL LIMITED ZONING DISTRICT. ONE OF

01:10:30.533 --> 01:10:32.533
THOSE IS PARTIALLY ZONED COMMERCIAL LIMITED.

01:10:35.533 --> 01:10:37.533
PARCELS WITH SALE ZONING ARE IDENTIFIED AS PARCEL SUBJECT TO GENERAL

01:10:39.533 --> 01:10:41.533
PLAN POLICY, A GLU 4. THAT ALLOWS CONTINUED OR EXPANDED

01:10:41.967 --> 01:10:43.967
COMMERCIAL ACTIVITY ON COMMERCIAL ZONED PROPERTY IS

01:10:46.967 --> 01:10:49.967
AND FOUND THEY WILL NOT BE DETRIMENTAL TO THE
CULTURAL WATERSHED OR OPEN SPACES OF THE GENERAL PLAN.

01:10:53.967 --> 01:10:55.967
IN THE STAFF PACKET, JUST TO POINT US OUT. THIS IS FROM

01:11:02.900 --> 01:11:04.900
OUR GENERAL PLAN. THIS IS WITH THE UNINCORPORATED COUNTRY. TO GIVE

01:11:05.900 --> 01:11:07.900
ABOARD AN IDEA OF WHERE ALL OF THESE ARE LOCATED

01:11:08.900 --> 01:11:10.900
IN THE COUNTY AND ALSO PEOPLE VIEWING THIS ITEM. NEXT

01:11:11.900 --> 01:11:13.900
SLIDE, PLEASE .

01:11:17.900 --> 01:11:19.900
OKAY.

01:11:23.900 --> 01:11:25.900
SORRY ABOUT THAT.

01:11:26.900 --> 01:11:28.900
THE APPLICANT PROPOSED ABOUT NINE TERMS .

01:11:32.900 --> 01:11:34.900
THOSE ARE IN ATTACHMENT A OF THE STAFF PACKET

01:11:38.900 --> 01:11:40.900
. FOUR OF THOSE ARE WITH PUBLIC BENEFITS AND FIVE ARE TERMS WHICH BENEFIT THE APPLICANT.

01:11:44.900 --> 01:11:46.900
WE WILL TALK ABOUT FOUR OF THOSE TERMS THAT A PUBLIC BENEFIT

01:11:47.900 --> 01:11:49.900
TO THEM.

01:11:50.900 --> 01:11:52.900
ONE OF THEM IS THAT THE APPLICANT IS PROPOSING

01:11:53.900 --> 01:11:55.900
TO DO ON-SITE AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNITS FOR EMPLOYEES. THERE ARE SIX EXISTING

01:11:58.833 --> 01:12:00.833
MARKET UNITS WHICH THE APPLICANT IS PROVIDING FOR EMPLOYEES.

01:12:04.833 --> 01:12:06.833
THESE ARE ONE OF THE TWO PARCELS THAT ARE

01:12:08.833 --> 01:12:10.833
SOUTHEAST OF THE LIEN AND SR 29.

01:12:14.833 --> 01:12:17.833
THE OTHER TERM APPLICANT IS PROPOSING IN THIS, AND
THESE CAN ALL BE LOOKED AT IN ATTACHMENT A, IS AFFORDABLE HOUSING

01:12:18.833 --> 01:12:20.833
FUNDING. APPLICANT IS PROPOSING TO PAY ABOUT

01:12:23.833 --> 01:12:25.833
THREE TIMES THE AMOUNT OF OUR AFFORDABLE HOUSING FUND. WHAT WOULD BE REQUIRED UNDER

01:12:26.833 --> 01:12:28.833
THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING FUND. THEY HAVE ESTIMATED ABOUT TO

01:12:29.833 --> 01:12:31.833
BE 1 MILLION 580,000 FOR THIS WILL BE PAID OVER

01:12:32.833 --> 01:12:34.833
TWO EQUAL PAYMENTS OF BUILDING PERMIT ISSUANCE

01:12:37.833 --> 01:12:39.833
AND FIVE YEARS AFTER THE PROJECT OCCUPANCY.

01:12:41.833 --> 01:12:43.833
FUNDS WOULD BE MADE AVAILABLE FOR USE BY
NAPA COUNTY FOR THE COUNTY DESIGNATED AFFORDABLE HOUSING DEVELOPER. A THIRD TERM

01:12:45.833 --> 01:12:47.833
WITH PUBLIC BENEFIT THE APPLICANT HAS PROPOSED IS

01:12:50.833 --> 01:12:52.833
FIND THE TRAIL SHELTER EASEMENTS IN CONJUNCTION WITH THE

01:12:54.833 --> 01:12:56.833
APPLICATION, THE APPLICANT IS ALREADY CONTRIBUTED EASEMENTS TO THE FINE TRAIL

01:12:59.833 --> 01:13:01.833
AND A TRAIL OF REST SHELTER FOR RECEIVING COMPENSATION. THIS WAS

01:13:05.833 --> 01:13:07.833
DUE TO THE TIMING OF THE FINE TRAIL GRANT PROCESS. THESE HAVE ALREADY

01:13:08.833 --> 01:13:10.833
BEEN ISSUED TO THE FINE TRAILER. AND THE FOURTH PROPOSED TERM WOULD BE

01:13:13.833 --> 01:13:15.833
TO IMPROVE AGRICULTURAL LANDS ON THE SOUTH PARCELS WITH

01:13:18.833 --> 01:13:20.833
AGRICULTURAL USE FOR THIS INCLUDES ACTIVE AGRICULTURE ON SELF

01:13:22.833 --> 01:13:24.833
PARCELS, AGRICULTURALLY ZONED LAND , AND THE USES CONSISTENT WITH GROWING

01:13:26.833 --> 01:13:28.833
AND HARVESTING WITHOUT PROCESSING OF AGRICULTURAL PROJECTS,

01:13:32.833 --> 01:13:34.833
AND TENDED WITH FARM TO TABLE EXPERIENCE FOR PROJECTS FOOD SERVICE AND TO EDUCATE

01:13:35.833 --> 01:13:37.833
HOTEL GUESTS OF THE AGRICULTURAL ECONOMY

01:13:41.833 --> 01:13:43.833
IN NAPA VALLEY. NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. THANK YOU.

01:13:47.833 --> 01:13:49.833
THERE ARE FIVE TERMS IN THESE PROPOSED TERMS THAT BENEFIT

01:13:50.833 --> 01:13:52.833
THE APPLICANT.

01:13:53.833 --> 01:13:55.833
THE APPLICANT IS REQUESTING THE ABILITY TO MODIFY THEIR

01:13:59.767 --> 01:14:01.767
AND BUILDING LOCATIONS SO LONG AS TOTAL SQUARE FOOTAGE

01:14:02.767 --> 01:14:05.767
AND ARE NOT INCREASED BEYOND WHAT WAS
IMPROVED AS CONFIRMED BY THE PDS DIRECTOR.

01:14:05.767 --> 01:14:07.767
ALSO, REQUESTING THAT THE

01:14:10.767 --> 01:14:12.767
ESTABLISHED INVESTED PARKING AREA WHICH IS DOCUMENTED AND APPROVED

01:14:14.767 --> 01:14:16.767
USE PERMIT 300059 WHICH IS A MINOR LOG. THAT IS IN A

01:14:20.767 --> 01:14:22.767
STAFF PACKET. THAT IS ON AW ZONE PARCELS AND THAT THAT

01:14:26.767 --> 01:14:28.767
BE RECOGNIZED IN THE D.A. AGREEMENT. THE THIRD TERM IS

01:14:30.767 --> 01:14:32.767
FOR FEE CREDIT AGAINST FUTURE AND ACTED TRANSPORTATION FEES

01:14:35.767 --> 01:14:37.767
AND AMOUNTS EQUAL TO THE VALUE OF THEIR VINE TRAIL SHELTER

01:14:38.767 --> 01:14:40.767
EASEMENTS AND OTHER TRANSPORTATION IMPROVEMENTS.

01:14:41.767 --> 01:14:43.767
THE FOURTH IS CONTINUED USE BY APPLICANT OF CELL PERSONAL BITE WASTEWATER

01:14:44.767 --> 01:14:46.767
TREATMENT SYSTEM AND AW LANDS

01:14:50.767 --> 01:14:52.767
FOR ALSO PERSONAL USES. AND FIVE IS TO ALLOW HOTEL DESK TO

01:14:59.700 --> 01:15:01.700
AW ZONED LAND SOUTH OF THE LIEN. ACTIVITIES FOR THE TOUR GAS

01:15:02.700 --> 01:15:04.700
ARE LIMITED TO THOSE ON THE DEFINITION

01:15:07.700 --> 01:15:09.700
OF AGRICULTURE. NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

01:15:11.700 --> 01:15:13.700
SO THE BOARD RECEIVED A NUMBER OF COMMENTS

01:15:14.700 --> 01:15:16.700
ON THIS ITEM. STAFF IS HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY

01:15:17.700 --> 01:15:19.700
QUESTIONS THE BOARD MAY HAVE ON THOSE COMMENTS.

01:15:20.700 --> 01:15:22.700
I WANT TO REITERATE THAT THE MINISTRY OF HEARING TODAY IS NOT

01:15:23.700 --> 01:15:25.700
TO REFUTE TO THE SITTER THE APPLICANT USE,

01:15:29.700 --> 01:15:31.700
OR THE FORTHCOMING ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS IN THE FORTHCOMING EIR.

01:15:34.700 --> 01:15:36.700
WHAT WE ARE HERE TO DO IS SEEK DISCUSSION DIRECTION FROM THE BOARD.

01:15:39.700 --> 01:15:41.700
AND IF THE BOARD FEELS

01:15:43.700 --> 01:15:45.700
THEY NEED MORE SPECIFIC INFORMATION OR TERMS THAT NEED TO BE FLUSHED OUT

01:15:50.700 --> 01:15:53.700
MORE AND THEY WANT US TO COME BACK AT A LATER TIME,
THEY CAN GIVE US DIRECTION ON THAT AND I WOULD BRING THIS ITEM BACK TO

01:15:57.633 --> 01:15:59.633
PROVIDED TO STAFF TODAY

01:16:02.633 --> 01:16:04.633
WITH THE DIRECTIVE ELEMENT AGREEMENT DOES NOT OBLIGATE THE BOARD TO
APPROVE THE DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT AT A LATER TIME.

01:16:08.633 --> 01:16:10.633
IN A DIRECTION TO STAFF IS TO ALLOW US TO COMPLETE THE

01:16:14.633 --> 01:16:16.633
ANALYSIS. WE ARE RELATIVELY CLOSE BUT WE CAN SEE THE LIGHT AT THE END OF

01:16:19.633 --> 01:16:22.633
THIS PROJECT FINISHING THE EIR ON THIS PROJECT BUT IF THERE WILL BE
A D.A. AGREEMENT

01:16:25.633 --> 01:16:27.633
, THAT HAS TO BE CONSIDERED AND ANALYZED IN THE EIR. SO

01:16:29.633 --> 01:16:31.633
WE CANNOT FINISH AND PRODUCE THAT UNTIL

01:16:33.633 --> 01:16:35.633
WE HAVE A DRAFT D.A. AGREEMENT THAT GOES ALONG WITH THAT.

01:16:39.633 --> 01:16:41.633
SO FINALLY, AS I MENTIONED, WE ARE NOT HERE TO DISCUSS

01:16:45.633 --> 01:16:48.633
THE APPLICANT USE PERMIT OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS. THERE
WILL BE FUTURE HEARINGS ON THIS AT THE MINIMUM, THERE'S

01:16:51.633 --> 01:16:53.633
A WE HUMOR HEARINGS, DEPENDING ON CONTINUANCES

01:16:54.633 --> 01:16:56.633
AND THINGS LIKE THAT BUT AT A MINIMUM, WILL BE GOING TO THE PLANNING

01:16:57.567 --> 01:16:59.567
COMMISSION AT A FUTURE DATE FOR HEARING ON THE DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT

01:17:03.567 --> 01:17:05.567
REPORT. AFTER THAT, THERE WILL BE A HEARING IN

01:17:07.567 --> 01:17:10.567
FRONT OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION ON RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE BOARD. THAT
WOULD BE ON THE USE PERMIT AND MAJOR MODIFICATION.

01:17:12.567 --> 01:17:14.567
THE FINAL EIR IN THE D.A. AGREEMENT. FINALLY,

01:17:15.567 --> 01:17:17.567
THE LAST HEARING WOULD BE A BOARD OF SUPERVISORS

01:17:18.567 --> 01:17:20.567
HEARING ON THE USE PERMIT AGER MODIFICATION

01:17:21.567 --> 01:17:23.567
, CERTIFICATION OF THE FINAL EIR, AND THE PROPOSAL

01:17:27.567 --> 01:17:29.567
OF THE DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT. THAT PROVIDES

01:17:30.567 --> 01:17:32.567
MY STAFF PRESENTATION. I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THE BOARD

01:17:33.567 --> 01:17:35.567
MAY HAVE. I'M SORRY. IF I FINISH, I WANTED TO MENTION APPLICANT

01:17:36.567 --> 01:17:38.567
IS HERE TODAY AND THAT THEY ARE AVAILABLE TO ANSWER

01:17:39.567 --> 01:17:42.567
QUESTIONS FOR THE BOARD. THANK YOU.
>> THANK YOU.

01:17:50.567 --> 01:17:52.567
WE DO NOT HAVE AN APPLICANT PRESENTATION, CORRECT?
DO WE?

01:17:54.567 --> 01:17:56.567
>> YEAH, I

01:17:57.500 --> 01:18:00.500
>> OKAY.
SO SING THE QUESTION FROM THE BOARD NOW, I WOULD LIKE TO APPLICANT REPRESENTATIVE

01:18:03.500 --> 01:18:05.500
TO COME UP AND PRESENT TO THE BOARD AND THEN WE CAN HAVE

01:18:06.467 --> 01:18:08.633
COLLECTIVE QUESTIONS.
>> GOOD MORNING, JENNIFER GOOD MORNING, SUPERVISORS.

01:18:13.500 --> 01:18:15.500
THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY THIS MORNING. MY PRESENTATION

01:18:18.500 --> 01:18:20.500
WILL BE , I GUESS I SHOULD START PRINT MY NAME IS ROB

01:18:21.500 --> 01:18:23.500
ANGLIN. I'M WORKING WITH JACKSON FAMILY ON THIS

01:18:24.500 --> 01:18:26.500
PROJECT SINCE IT WAS APPLIED FOR IN 2019.

01:18:29.500 --> 01:18:31.500
WITH ME TODAY WE HAVE SOME TEAM MEMBERS TO

01:18:33.500 --> 01:18:35.500
KIND OF BE PRESENT AND HEAR THE BOARD FEEDBACK.

01:18:38.500 --> 01:18:41.500
AND POSSIBLY ANSWER QUESTIONS IF THAT IS THE WAY THE
DISCUSSION GOES IF I COULD INTRODUCE THE BID WE HAVE JACKSON FAMILY

01:18:44.500 --> 01:18:46.500
MEMBER --JACKSON WHO SERVES AS THE DIRECTOR OF REAL ESTATE. WE HAVE LIEN

01:18:48.500 --> 01:18:50.500
EDWARDS WHO IS ON EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT OF REAL ESTATE. AND THEN

01:18:51.500 --> 01:18:53.500
WE HAVE JEFF SCOTT WHO IS EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT OF

01:18:57.433 --> 01:19:00.433
PLANNING AND ZONING.
I'M SURE I BUTCHERED SOMEBODY'S TITLE IN THAT.

01:19:03.433 --> 01:19:05.433
IN ANY EVENT, WE ALSO HAVE -- WATCHING REMOTELY TO

01:19:08.433 --> 01:19:10.433
TRY TO CAPTURE EVERYTHING THAT IS SAID TODAY. I APPRECIATE

01:19:12.433 --> 01:19:14.433
TREVOR'S STAFF REPORT TO YOU.

01:19:15.433 --> 01:19:17.433
I WOULD LIKE TO ECHO SOME

01:19:20.433 --> 01:19:23.433
OF THE COMMENTS IS JUST SO, YOU KNOW, IT IS CLEARLY APPLICANT SHARES
THE UNDERSTANDING. THIS IS NOT ABOUT THE PROJECT AND IT BEING APPROVED TODAY.

01:19:26.433 --> 01:19:28.433
WE GOT A LOT OF COMMENTS FROM INTERESTED PARTIES ABOUT

01:19:30.433 --> 01:19:32.433
POTENTIAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS THAT SHOULD

01:19:33.433 --> 01:19:35.433
AND WILL BE STUDIED IN THE EIR.
THAT WILL CERTAINLY HAPPEN. THAT IS NOT THE FOCUS TODAY. I UNDERSTAND

01:19:39.433 --> 01:19:41.433
FOLKS WANT TO BE HEARD ON THOSE THINGS AS THEY WILL

01:19:42.433 --> 01:19:44.433
BE AS THE PROCESS MOVES FORWARD.
BUT THE BOARD IS IN A POSITION WITHIN THE EIR TO MAKE ANY DECISIONS TODAY.

01:19:46.433 --> 01:19:48.433
IT IS MERELY A DISCUSSION FOR DIRECTION TO STAFF ON

01:19:50.433 --> 01:19:52.433
POSSIBLE DEVELOPMENT AND UNIT TERMS THAT THE BOARD WOULD

01:19:53.433 --> 01:19:55.433
LIKE TO SEE FOR THIS PROJECT TO MOVE FORWARD IN

01:19:57.367 --> 01:19:59.367
THE ANALYSIS. THOSE KINDS OF DECISIONS ON APPROVAL WILL

01:20:00.367 --> 01:20:02.367
BE TAKEN AT A LATER DATE I THINK IT IS WORTH NOTING THAT THE

01:20:03.367 --> 01:20:05.367
DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT IS NOT NECESSARILY

01:20:08.367 --> 01:20:10.367
REQUIRED FOR A HOSPITALITY PROJECT BUT IN THE STAFF REPORT YOU HAVE

01:20:12.367 --> 01:20:14.367
THE VERY LIMITED PLACES WITH THE COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT LIKE A HOTEL BEING PERMITTED. OTHER PROJECTS

01:20:15.367 --> 01:20:17.367
HAVE PROCEEDED WITHOUT A DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT.

01:20:20.367 --> 01:20:22.367
THAT WAS APPROVED SOME YEARS AGO.

01:20:27.367 --> 01:20:29.367
WE FELT THE DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT WAS A GOOD PROJECT HERE FOR THE DEVELOPMENT

01:20:30.367 --> 01:20:32.367
AND COMMUNITY. ALLOWS SOME PUBLIC BENEFITS TO ARISE FROM THE PROJECT AND ALLOWS A COLLABORATIVE

01:20:34.367 --> 01:20:37.367
PROCESS BETWEEN COUNTY STAKEHOLDERS IN THE APPLICANT. WE THOUGHT IT WAS
A BETTER PROCESS ALL AROUND.

01:20:45.367 --> 01:20:47.367
AND SO AS PART OF THAT, WE PUT SOME PROPOSED TERMS FORWARD FOR

01:20:48.367 --> 01:20:51.367
DISCUSSION. ONE OF THE THINGS WE HEARD AT THE
SCOPING SESSION FROM THE PLANNING COMMISSION AT THE TIME. WE

01:20:54.367 --> 01:20:56.367
HAVE HEARD IT AS RECENTLY AS THE NAPA COALITION LETTER THAT CAME IN

01:21:00.300 --> 01:21:02.300
. AFFORDABLE HOUSING IS PART OF THE DISCUSSION ON HOSPITALITY

01:21:03.300 --> 01:21:05.300
PROJECTS. WE HAVE PROPOSED SOME MEASURES ON

01:21:06.300 --> 01:21:08.300
THAT TOPIC. THAT INCLUDES THE D CHIP TO THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING THAT

01:21:12.300 --> 01:21:14.300
IS ON-SITE. THERE IS A COMPARISON CHART I RESEARCHED AND PREPARED IN YOUR

01:21:18.300 --> 01:21:20.300
STAFF REPORTS. YOU HAVE SOME COMPARISONS OF WHAT OTHER HOSPITALITY

01:21:21.300 --> 01:21:23.300
PROJECTS HAVE DONE IN THAT REGARD.

01:21:24.300 --> 01:21:26.300
THE PLANNING COMMISSION OFFING TO

01:21:30.300 --> 01:21:32.300
--OFFERING TO PAY TRIPLE FEES. WE ARE GOING

01:21:34.300 --> 01:21:36.300
BEYOND THAT. WE ARE GOING A LOT BEYOND THAT BECAUSE WE HAVE A

01:21:37.300 --> 01:21:39.300
AFFORDABLE UNITS FOR EMPLOYEE HOUSING ON SITE. IN ADDITION

01:21:40.300 --> 01:21:42.300
TO OFFERING THE TRIPLE AFFORDABLE HOUSING

01:21:46.300 --> 01:21:48.300
FEE. SO I THINK THERE ARE SOME QUESTIONS THAT

01:21:49.300 --> 01:21:51.300
ARE GOOD QUESTIONS THAT THE NAPA HOUSING

01:21:52.300 --> 01:21:54.300
COALITION RAISED. THERE IS SOME DETAILS

01:21:58.233 --> 01:22:00.233
WITH HOUSING. I DO NOT THINK THE DETAILS THAT CAN

01:22:01.233 --> 01:22:03.233
BE WORKED OUT ARE REASONS NOT TO DO IT. --HER

01:22:05.233 --> 01:22:07.233
HOUSING IS EMPLOYER SPONSORED HOUSING.
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IS DETAILED AND IT CAN

01:22:09.233 --> 01:22:11.233
BE COMPLEX. SO WE CAN WORK THROUGH THOSE DETAILS.

01:22:12.233 --> 01:22:14.233
I THINK , CERTAINLY, IT IS SOMETHING THAT EMPLOYERS SHOULD BE ENCOURAGED TO

01:22:16.233 --> 01:22:18.233
PROVIDE WHERE THEY CAN. WE ARE PROPOSED TO DOING

01:22:19.233 --> 01:22:21.233
THAT HERE.

01:22:23.233 --> 01:22:25.233
ON THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING FEE PAYMENT I THINK WE CHARACTERIZED IT

01:22:27.233 --> 01:22:29.233
AS A TRIPLE PAYMENT OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING FEES.

01:22:33.233 --> 01:22:35.233
YOU KNOW, WE ARE NOT EXPERTS IN HOUSING FINANCE.

01:22:36.233 --> 01:22:39.233
YOU HAVE AN EXPERT IN THE HOUSING FINANCE.
I HAVE SPOKEN WITH JENNIFER PALMER AND YOUR

01:22:43.233 --> 01:22:46.233
DIRECTOR IN HOUSING AND HOMELESS SERVICES.
I AM LEARNING A LOT ABOUT THE DIFFERENT WAYS IN WHICH THE COUNTY INITIATIVES OPERATE

01:22:49.233 --> 01:22:51.233
AND ARE FUNDED. AND SO WE WOULD LIKE THE OPPORTUNITY TO WORK FURTHER

01:22:55.233 --> 01:22:57.233
WITH MS. PALMER AND OTHERS IN COUNTY STAFF TO SEE HOW THOSE

01:22:57.600 --> 01:23:00.167
DOLLARS CAN BE SPENT TO BEST EFFECT.
YOU KNOW, THERE ARE THINGS LIKE THAT COUNTY PROXIMITY

01:23:04.233 --> 01:23:06.233
HOMEBUYER ASSISTANCE PROGRAM THAT I UNDERSTAND IS EXTREMELY SUCCESSFUL.

01:23:09.233 --> 01:23:11.233
MAYBE THAT IS A GOOD PLACE FOR SUPPORT.
I KNOW I NEED AMONG FAMILY HOUSING IS

01:23:15.233 --> 01:23:17.233
AN EMERGING NEED THAT IS NOT REALLY SATISFIED BY THE

01:23:18.233 --> 01:23:20.233
KIND OF CONGREGANT FACILITIES WE DEVELOPED IN THE PAST. THERE IS AN AREA

01:23:24.233 --> 01:23:26.233
THAT COULD BE BENEFITED BY A PROJECT LIKE THIS. I THINK THOSE ARE THINGS WE

01:23:28.233 --> 01:23:30.233
WOULD LIKE TO EXPLORE WITH YOUR COUNTY STAFF

01:23:31.233 --> 01:23:33.233
LETTER PUBLIC BENEFITS FROM THIS PROJECT THAT

01:23:35.233 --> 01:23:37.233
COULD GO DIRECTLY TO THE ISSUE OF HOUSING IN OUR COMMUNITY.

01:23:40.233 --> 01:23:42.233
I THINK IT IS ALSO WHEN YOU LOOK

01:23:44.233 --> 01:23:46.233
AT THAT COMPARISON CHART, I THINK IT'S HELPFUL TO SEE WHAT OTHER JURISDICTIONS

01:23:48.233 --> 01:23:50.233
ARE DOING. I THINK IT IS HELPFUL TO RECOGNIZE WHAT THOSE JURISDICTIONS
HAVE IN THEIR TOOLBOX. THERE ARE A LOT

01:23:52.233 --> 01:23:54.233
OF CITY APPLICATIONS IN OUR CITY PROJECTS IN THAT LIST.

01:23:58.167 --> 01:24:00.167
A CITY HAS THE ABILITY TO REZONE A NEARBY SITE FOR MULTIFAMILY HOUSING.

01:24:01.167 --> 01:24:03.167
THE COUNTY DOES NOT HAVE THAT ABILITY.

01:24:04.167 --> 01:24:06.167
SO I THINK WHAT WE HAVE PROPOSED

01:24:09.167 --> 01:24:11.167
OUR PUBLIC BENEFITS THE COUNTY CONTROLS THE GO TO CONEY BENEFIT.

01:24:13.167 --> 01:24:15.167
I THINK IF WE START TO EXPAND INTO A

01:24:17.167 --> 01:24:20.167
WORLD OF PUBLIC BENEFITS THAT ARE UNDER CITY CONTROL, THEN WE ARE GOING
TO START CONDITIONING THE PUBLIC BENEFITS

01:24:22.167 --> 01:24:24.167
ON THE CITY DISCRETIONARY APPROVAL THAT

01:24:29.167 --> 01:24:32.167
MAY BE EVEN MORE COMPLICATED THAT SOME OF THE OTHER DETAILS THAT HAVE BEEN
RAISED IN THE COMMENTS ON THE PROJECT.

01:24:37.167 --> 01:24:39.167
WE ARE LOOKING FOR THINGS THAT COUNTY CAN IMPLEMENT AND WAYS

01:24:40.167 --> 01:24:42.167
WE CAN PARTNER WITH THE COUNTY THE THE COUNT HE HAS CONTROL OVER. TREVOR

01:24:43.167 --> 01:24:45.167
MENTIONED THE FIND TRAIL EASEMENTS FOR JUST A LITTLE FURTHER BACKGROUND.

01:24:49.167 --> 01:24:51.167
THOSE WERE PROPOSED IN 2020. AND IN THE FIND TRAIL FOLKS AND SAID WE

01:24:52.167 --> 01:24:54.167
NEED THIS FOR GRANT FUNDING. AND SO THE JACKSON FAMILY KIND OF TOOK A

01:24:55.167 --> 01:24:57.167
LEAP OF FAITH IN THAT REGARD AND

01:25:00.100 --> 01:25:02.100
WENT AHEAD AND GRANTED THOSE EASEMENTS, EVEN THOUGH THEY HAD BEEN PROPOSED

01:25:04.100 --> 01:25:06.100
AS PUBLIC AND IF IT'S.

01:25:07.100 --> 01:25:09.100
SOMEWHERE SOMEONE OUT THERE MAY HAVE SAID YOU
ALREADY GRANTED THOSE EASEMENTS SO YOU'RE NOT GETTING THE PUBLIC IN A FIT

01:25:10.100 --> 01:25:12.100
WE PROPOSALS IN 2020. IT FELT WRONG FOR THE JACKSON

01:25:13.100 --> 01:25:15.100
FAMILY DID NOT FEEL GREAT ABOUT WITHHOLDING THAT

01:25:16.100 --> 01:25:18.100
BENEFIT GIVING THE GREAT NEED THAT THE FIND TRAIL NEEDED. IN

01:25:19.100 --> 01:25:21.100
ORDER TO GET THE GRANTS FOR THOSE EASEMENTS. SO LASTLY,

01:25:25.100 --> 01:25:27.100
I THINK IT GOES WITHOUT SAYING THAT MAYBE NOT

01:25:28.100 --> 01:25:30.100
A PUBLIC BENEFIT, BUT THE TOT TAX

01:25:33.100 --> 01:25:35.100
IS A PUBLIC BENEFIT AND FUNDS A GREAT MANY THINGS INCLUDING THE COUNTY GENERAL

01:25:37.100 --> 01:25:39.100
FUND. AFTER MAJOR I PASSAGE IN 2018, A PORTION

01:25:42.100 --> 01:25:44.100
OF IT GOES TO AFFORDABLE HOUSING. I AM CERTAIN THERE ARE LOTS OF THINGS

01:25:46.100 --> 01:25:48.100
THAT THE COUNTY CAN DO WITH THAT MONEY. THAT IS REVENUE THAT

01:25:49.100 --> 01:25:51.100
IS NOT GENERATED BY THE

01:25:53.100 --> 01:25:55.100
RESTAURANTS AND TITLE CURRENTLY ON THE SITE OR THE COMMERCIAL PLAZA. SO IF

01:25:58.330 --> 01:26:00.330
THE COUNTY IS LOOKING TO MAXIMIZE ITS

01:26:01.330 --> 01:26:03.330
RETURN OF PUBLIC AND A FIT FROM COMMERCIAL USES ON COMMERCIALLY ZONED SITES OF WHICH

01:26:04.330 --> 01:26:06.330
THERE ARE VERY FEW, THEN THE HOTEL DEVELOPMENT IS THE MAXIMUM BENEFIT.

01:26:10.330 --> 01:26:12.330
WITH THAT, THOSE OF THE COMMENTS I HAD TO

01:26:15.330 --> 01:26:17.330
KIND OF FRAME THE APPLICANT VIEW OF THE DISCUSSION. WE LOOK FORWARD TO HEARING FROM

01:26:18.330 --> 01:26:20.330
THE BOARD AND WHAT THEY THINK ON IT.
>> THANK YOU.

01:26:22.330 --> 01:26:24.330
WE DO APPRECIATE THAT CLARIFICATION

01:26:28.330 --> 01:26:30.330
OF WHAT THE JACKSON FAMILY DID IN

01:26:34.330 --> 01:26:36.330
GOOD FAITH. SO I APPRECIATE THAT CONTEXT, AND AGAIN, REITERATING THIS IS NOT APPROVAL

01:26:37.330 --> 01:26:39.330
NOR IS THIS EIR.

01:26:43.330 --> 01:26:45.330
THIS IS JUST SCOPING FOR WHAT KIND OF A RELATIONSHIP

01:26:46.330 --> 01:26:48.330
WE WANT TO HAVE.
SUPERVISOR GALLAGHER COMMENCED AN I JUST HAD A QUICK QUESTION.

01:26:52.330 --> 01:26:54.330
>> SURE. >> THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THE PRESENTATION. CAN

01:26:57.967 --> 01:26:59.967
YOU TELL ME IF THE UNITS ON SITE RIGHT NOW, IF THEY ARE

01:27:03.967 --> 01:27:05.967
INHABITED? IF THEY ARE, IS IT IN PLACE OF

01:27:08.967 --> 01:27:11.967
THE PROPERTIES THAT ARE THERE NOW?
>> THERE ARE EMPLOYEES THAT ARE FRONTED TO THOSE UNITS. I

01:27:13.967 --> 01:27:15.967
DO NOT THINK THEY ARE ALL RENTED RIGHT NOW. THERE HAVE BEEN MONTH-TO-MONTH TENDENCIES

01:27:18.967 --> 01:27:20.967
COMING AT DIFFERENT TIMES. THEY HAVE BEEN RENTED

01:27:23.967 --> 01:27:25.967
TO FIRST RESPONDERS AND FIRE PERSONNEL DURING FIRE SEASON. THEY ARE

01:27:28.967 --> 01:27:30.967
RENTED AT THE MARKETS AMOUNT . PEOPLE

01:27:34.967 --> 01:27:36.967
--PEOPLE ARE COMING AND GOING. YOU KNOW, THE

01:27:37.967 --> 01:27:39.967
DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT IS SOMETHING

01:27:41.967 --> 01:27:43.967
THAT DOES NOT HAPPEN ALL AT ONCE, RIGHT? TREVOR TALKED ABOUT SOME OF

01:27:46.967 --> 01:27:48.967
THE PROCESS THAT LEADS UP INTO THE BOARD APPROVAL IF YOU CAN GET TO THAT

01:27:52.967 --> 01:27:54.967
POINT. YOU HAVE TO BUILD IT ONE DAY. I'VE WORKED IN OTHER PROJECTS

01:27:58.900 --> 01:28:00.900
NEXT DAY. I KNOW THE BOARD DECISION ON A PROJECT

01:28:01.900 --> 01:28:03.900
IS A MARK IN TIME. AND THERE IS FINANCING AND CONSTRUCTION. THERE

01:28:04.900 --> 01:28:06.900
IS A LONG LEAD UP TO THAT IN WHICH YOU HAVE

01:28:07.900 --> 01:28:09.900
TIME TO TRANSITION PEOPLE WHO ARE IN

01:28:11.900 --> 01:28:13.900
MARKET HOUSING AND TRANSITION THEM TO OTHER OPTIONS.

01:28:16.900 --> 01:28:18.900
IF THE BOARD WERE TO APPROVE A PROJECT, WHICH WE

01:28:19.900 --> 01:28:21.900
HOPE THEY WILL, THEN IT IS NOT LIKE WE ARE SERVING

01:28:22.900 --> 01:28:25.900
EVICTION NOTICES THE NEXT DAY.
>> GREAT. THANK YOU.

01:28:25.900 --> 01:28:27.900
I WANTED TO KNOW IF THERE WERE PEOPLE CURRENTLY EMPLOYEES

01:28:31.900 --> 01:28:34.900
.
>> IT IS SOMETHING OF A MIX. TWO BIRDS ONE STONE

01:28:38.900 --> 01:28:40.900
WAS OPEN, TO REMEMBER THAT RESTAURANT?
THERE ARE SOME EMPLOYEES STAYING THERE AT

01:28:42.900 --> 01:28:44.900
THAT TIME. IT IS BEEN JUST MARKET HOUSING THAT JACKSON FAMILY HAS BEEN

01:28:46.900 --> 01:28:48.900
LEASING TO THOSE PEOPLE .

01:28:49.900 --> 01:28:51.900
>> THANK YOU. >> CERTAINLY.

01:28:52.900 --> 01:28:54.900
>> OH IF I COULD? YEAH.

01:28:58.833 --> 01:29:01.833
>> ABOUT 60% CURRENTLY.
>> THANK YOU.

01:29:01.900 --> 01:29:04.300
SUPERVISOR GREGORY?
>> A FEW QUICK QUESTIONS . THE HOUSING THAT

01:29:10.833 --> 01:29:12.833
SITS ON 1157 , THE TRIANGULAR SHAPED PIECE. THAT IS AT WATERSHED

01:29:16.833 --> 01:29:18.833
ZONED. THAT MEANS THAT IS A LEGAL NONCONFORMING USE? CORRECT?

01:29:19.833 --> 01:29:21.833
>> YES.

01:29:22.833 --> 01:29:24.833
THAT WOULD BE A LEGAL NONCONFORMING USE. I CAN CHECK THE HISTORY,

01:29:25.833 --> 01:29:27.833
BUT THAT IS ONE PARCEL THAT HAS MULTIPLE UNITS

01:29:28.833 --> 01:29:30.833
ON IT.

01:29:31.833 --> 01:29:33.833
>> AND TO ADD ONTO THAT, WE HAVE A CERTIFICATE OF

01:29:37.833 --> 01:29:39.833
NONCONFORMING IN THOSE UNITS. IS IT FAIR TO SAY WHETHER IT IS

01:29:46.833 --> 01:29:49.833
CLR W ACROSS THIS PROJECT?
>> NONE OF THAT ALLOWS HOUSING.

01:29:52.833 --> 01:29:55.833
>> WELL, A DOUBLE ZONING DOES A LOT OF HOUSING.
>> WELL, MORE THAN ONE WELL, TECHNICALLY, A

01:30:01.767 --> 01:30:03.767
W ZONING COULD ALLOW UP TO , IT WOULD ALLOW

01:30:07.767 --> 01:30:09.767
THE EDU AND SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL STRUCTURE

01:30:13.767 --> 01:30:15.767
. A COTTAGE IS WELL UNDER OUR ZONING CODE, ALTHOUGH THAT DOES NOT QUALIFY FOR

01:30:17.767 --> 01:30:20.767
INITIATIVE MENTIONED THAT DOES NOT QUALIFY AS A DWELLING UNIT. THAT IS ALLOWED
FOR HOUSING.

01:30:22.767 --> 01:30:24.767
BUT THE COMMERCIAL LIMITED I BELIEVE, I WOULD HAVE TO DOUBLE

01:30:28.767 --> 01:30:30.767
CHECK. I THINK THERE IS SOMETHING CALLED A COMMERCIAL EDU

01:30:33.767 --> 01:30:35.767
IN OUR ZONING CODE. BUT BESIDES THAT, THERE IS NO RESIDENTIAL ALLOWED IN

01:30:39.400 --> 01:30:42.000
COMMERCIAL LIMITED.
>> THANK YOU.

01:30:42.670 --> 01:30:44.467
SUPERVISOR PEDROZA?
>> THANK YOU, CHAIR. ON ISSUE OF HOUSING,

01:30:49.767 --> 01:30:51.767
IS IT BEING CONSIDERED TO INCORPORATE THE HOUSING

01:30:52.767 --> 01:30:54.767
INTO THE HOTEL POTENTIALLY? I KNOW THE RESPONSES

01:30:57.700 --> 01:30:59.700
HAVE MORE IN PLOWING HOUSE HE BEING PART OF THE DEVELOPMENT

01:31:01.700 --> 01:31:03.700
. IS THAT PART OF THE CONSIDERATION HERE?

01:31:04.700 --> 01:31:07.700
>> WELL, THAT IS A QUESTION FOR THE BOARD
AND ZONING. ZONING DOES NOT CURRENTLY ALLOW

01:31:10.700 --> 01:31:12.700
MULTI FAMILY AND A COMMERCIAL CL ZONE PARCEL. WHEN WE DEVELOPED

01:31:16.700 --> 01:31:18.700
THIS APPLICATION , WE WERE LOOKING TO COMPLY WITH THE GENERAL PLAN POLICY 45.

01:31:22.700 --> 01:31:24.700
IN THE EXISTING ZONING. SO WE ARE NOT PROPOSING TO MAKE THE

01:31:28.700 --> 01:31:31.700
ADDITIONAL TASK OF ASKING THE BOARD TO
CHANGE THE RULES FOR US. SO, YOU KNOW, IF YOU'RE PERUSING THAT QUESTION TO ME

01:31:36.767 --> 01:31:38.233
--
>> THE QUESTION TO STAFF.

01:31:43.700 --> 01:31:45.700
TERMS OF THE HOUSING, I REALLY INTERESTED IN THIS HOUSING

01:31:46.700 --> 01:31:48.700
OPPORTUNITY HERE. WHETHER IT IS CONTRIBUTING, OR BUILDING SOME TYPE OF HOUSING

01:31:53.700 --> 01:31:55.700
AS PART OF THE DEVELOPMENT, TREVOR?

01:31:56.533 --> 01:31:58.100
ARE.
>> I DO NOT HAVE THE IRATE INTO IT CONDITIONAL

01:32:04.633 --> 01:32:06.633
LAND USES FOR THE STEAL ZONING IN FRONT OF ME AT THIS

01:32:07.633 --> 01:32:09.633
SECOND. I WAS NOT ANTICIPATING -- HERE COMES THE BOSS WITH THIS LAPTOP.

01:32:13.633 --> 01:32:15.633
I SHOULD'VE BROUGHT MY LAPTOP. THE IMPEDIMENTS IS

01:32:16.633 --> 01:32:18.633
, IT SHOULD BE -- YEAH, SO CL DOES

01:32:22.633 --> 01:32:24.633
ALLOW FOR WHAT IS CONSIDERED THE ACCESSORY DWELLING UNIT. AS I

01:32:25.633 --> 01:32:27.633
MENTIONED EARLIER, OUTSIDE OF THAT, MULTI FAMILY IS NOT A RECOGNIZED

01:32:30.633 --> 01:32:32.633
LAND-USE IN THE SEAL OF ZONING EITHER BY RIGHT

01:32:34.633 --> 01:32:36.633
OR CONDITIONALLY.

01:32:40.633 --> 01:32:43.633
>> WE WOULD EFFECTIVELY BE LOOKING AT
A CHANGE TO THE SEAL ZONING DETAILS WHICH IS SOMETHING WE COULD

01:32:45.567 --> 01:32:47.167
LOOK INTO .
>> LOOK, I APPRECIATE IT. MY INITIAL RESPONSES ARE

01:32:51.633 --> 01:32:53.633
THAT HOUSING WILL CONTINUE TO BE A AN ISSUE FOR OUR COMMUNITY. WE HAVE

01:32:55.633 --> 01:32:57.633
AN OPPORTUNITY TO WORK WITH THE DEVELOPMENT THAT

01:32:58.633 --> 01:33:00.633
YOU ARE WILLING TO PAY THREE TIMES, I BELIEVE

01:33:04.633 --> 01:33:06.633
THAT IS WHAT I SAW. BUT THE FACT IS WHEN YOU LOOK

01:33:07.633 --> 01:33:09.633
AT THE COST OF $500,000 TO BUILD ONE UNIT YOU'RE

01:33:10.633 --> 01:33:12.633
NOT GETTING ANY UNITS BUT I WANTED TO WONDER HOW WE COULD

01:33:13.633 --> 01:33:15.633
DO THAT, WHETHER IT IS PARTNERING WITH US

01:33:16.633 --> 01:33:18.633
OR A HOUSING DEVELOPER. MAYBE TO USE THAT TO BUY

01:33:20.633 --> 01:33:22.633
PROPERTY TO BUY MORE.
I AM REALLY INTERESTED IN EXPLORING WAYS, IF

01:33:26.633 --> 01:33:29.633
IT IS BENEFICIAL TO HAVE MORE HOUSING ON-SITE AS PART OF
THE MODEL. I'M WILLING TO LOOK AT OUR ORDINANCES

01:33:33.633 --> 01:33:35.633
THAT MAY INHIBIT THAT. THAT IS A NEW WORLD WE'RE LIVING IN AND THAT

01:33:36.633 --> 01:33:38.633
MADE ME THE MODEL. THAT IS THE QUESTION FOR US IN THE BOARD THAT

01:33:39.633 --> 01:33:41.633
WE CAN DO THAT. SECOND OF ALL, I AM NOT INTERESTED IN HAVING A PAYMENT.

01:33:44.633 --> 01:33:46.633
I THINK WORKING WITH TO GET SOME UNITS, I THINK THAT IS

01:33:47.633 --> 01:33:49.633
A DISCUSSION TO HAVE THAT NEEDS TO BE FLESHED

01:33:51.633 --> 01:33:53.633
OUT A LITTLE MORE. THAT MAKES A REAL IMPACT OF FAMILIES. PROVIDING THEM A FAMILY

01:33:56.567 --> 01:33:59.567
-- A HOUSING OPPORTUNITY IN THIS MOMENT.
THAT IS ONE OF THE PRIZED OPPORTUNITIES I

01:34:00.567 --> 01:34:02.567
AM LOOKING AT THIS OR SOMETHING. TONIGHT WE HAVE HAD DISCUSSIONS ALONG THOSE

01:34:04.567 --> 01:34:06.567
LINES A YEAR AND A HALF, TWO YEARS AGO AND CONNECTED HIM

01:34:07.567 --> 01:34:09.567
WITH A LOT OF HOUSING FOLKS. JENNIFER PALMER

01:34:10.567 --> 01:34:12.567
AMONG OTHERS. I DO NOT KNOW WHAT THE RESULTS

01:34:14.567 --> 01:34:16.567
OF THOSE DISCUSSIONS WERE. I KNOW THERE WERE NOT ANY SHOVEL READY PROJECTS

01:34:17.567 --> 01:34:19.567
FOR FUNDING.

01:34:20.567 --> 01:34:22.567
>> YEAH, ABSOLUTELY.

01:34:26.567 --> 01:34:28.567
WE HAVE TALKED TO A LOT OF FOLKS

01:34:30.567 --> 01:34:32.567
ARE IN THE BUSINESS OF DEVELOPING AFFORDABLE HOUSING. THE LINEUP OF

01:34:35.567 --> 01:34:37.567
THEIR PROJECTS IN OUR PROJECT, WE ARE NOT EVEN AT THE BIR

01:34:40.567 --> 01:34:42.567
STAGE BUT IF YOU GO TO THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND

01:34:43.567 --> 01:34:45.567
YOU SAY WHAT YOU GUYS GOT IN THE PIPELINE, THEIR PIPELINE DOES NOT TRACK

01:34:47.567 --> 01:34:49.567
OUR LONGER ONE PROCESS. I APPRECIATE THAT THOSE FOLKS

01:34:52.567 --> 01:34:54.567
ARE THE ONES WHO NEED TO BUILD THE UNIT .

01:34:56.500 --> 01:34:58.500
THE TRICK COMES IN , OKAY, ARE WE DOING THE INSIDE A

01:35:01.500 --> 01:35:03.500
CITY? IF WE ARE, IF YOU'RE SECURING LAND

01:35:04.500 --> 01:35:07.500
INSIDE THE CITY, AND IN THE CITY HAS A JURISDICTION
OVER THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING THAT WILL BE BUILT THERE.

01:35:10.500 --> 01:35:13.500
DID THEY WANTED THERE? ARE THEY GOING TO ZONE FOUR TO BE THERE?
WILL THEY GIVE THE DISCRETIONARY APPROVALS TO CONSTRUCT IT?

01:35:17.500 --> 01:35:19.500
ARE THEY GOING TO LOVE US FOR TYING UP AFFORDABLE

01:35:20.500 --> 01:35:22.500
HOUSING SITES AND HOLDING THEM FOR THE COUNTY USE

01:35:23.500 --> 01:35:25.500
IN EXCHANGE FOR THEIR DEVELOPMENT PROJECT? THEY MAY NOT

01:35:27.500 --> 01:35:29.500
LIKE THAT, ESPECIALLY IF THEY'RE GOING TO THEIR OWN HOUSING ELEMENT PROCESS.

01:35:31.500 --> 01:35:33.500
WE MAY NOT MAKE A LOT OF FRIENDS THAT WAY. THAT

01:35:35.500 --> 01:35:37.500
IS WHY , I UNDERSTAND BUILDING AFFORDABLE HOUSING

01:35:38.500 --> 01:35:40.500
IS EXPENSIVE.

01:35:41.500 --> 01:35:43.500
IT IS COUNTERINTUITIVELY MORE EXPENSIVE THAN YOU WOULD EXPECT. BUT

01:35:44.500 --> 01:35:46.500
IF IT IS EXPENSIVE,

01:35:49.500 --> 01:35:51.500
THEN WE NEED TO PUT MONEY TOWARD IT.
THAT IS WHY WE ARE PROPOSING TO DO THAT. IF THE

01:35:53.500 --> 01:35:55.500
SOLUTION IS, WELL, YOU NEED TO GO FIND AND CONSTRUCT A

01:35:57.433 --> 01:35:59.433
SIMPLE AFFORDABLE HOUSING PROJECT INSIDE A CITY, THAT BRINGS

01:36:01.433 --> 01:36:03.433
A HOLIER COMPUTATIONS AND ISSUES. BEVERLY TYING

01:36:04.433 --> 01:36:06.433
TWO JURISDICTIONS TO DO IT. THAT IS A LOT HARDER. WE TALKED

01:36:08.433 --> 01:36:10.433
TO THOSE FOLKS SO IT IS NOT THAT WE HAVE NOT. WHAT

01:36:11.433 --> 01:36:13.433
I WOULD LOVE TO DO IS SAY, WELL, WE HAVE GOT X NUMBER

01:36:14.433 --> 01:36:16.433
OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNITS READY TO GO. ALL WE HAVE TO

01:36:17.433 --> 01:36:19.433
DO IS MAKE OUT THE CHECK.

01:36:23.433 --> 01:36:25.433
AND THEY WILL GO BUILD IT.

01:36:26.433 --> 01:36:28.433
BUT LINING THAT UP WITH THE PROJECT THAT STILL HAS A LOT OF

01:36:32.433 --> 01:36:34.433
REVIEW LEFT TO DO, THEY CANNOT COUNT ON US BECAUSE WE ARE NOT THERE YET.

01:36:35.433 --> 01:36:37.433
THEIR PROJECTS ARE NOT REALLY, THEY ARE A LITTLE MORE --

01:36:38.433 --> 01:36:40.433
>> I APPRECIATE THAT .

01:36:41.433 --> 01:36:43.433
>> A DECREE HAVE ILLUSTRATED SOME OF THE CHALLENGES ABOUT BEING

01:36:44.433 --> 01:36:46.433
CREATIVE. THERE ARE SO MANY THINGS THAT HAVE TO GET ANGRY

01:36:47.433 --> 01:36:49.433
NICE BUT I APPRECIATE THAT BUT FOR STAFF, I'M INTERESTED

01:36:50.433 --> 01:36:52.433
IN LOOKING AT THE SEAL ZONING. THE NEW LOOK AT EQUIPMENT

01:36:56.367 --> 01:36:58.367
, 40% OF THE WORKFORCE AND PROVIDING THEM AN OPPORTUNITY TO LOOK A LITTLE

01:36:59.367 --> 01:37:01.367
CLOSER TO HOME. I THINK THERE ARE A LOT OF

01:37:05.367 --> 01:37:07.367
WINGS THERE THAT MIGHT BE A BIGGER POLICY DISCUSSION

01:37:08.367 --> 01:37:10.367
WE MAY WANT TO HAVE WITH THE BOARD. I THINK THIS PRESENTS US AN OPPORTUNITY

01:37:11.367 --> 01:37:14.367
TO SECURE SOME HOUSING ON-SITE, IF IT MAKES SENSE.
>> SUPERVISOR PEDROZA, IF I COULD GO

01:37:16.367 --> 01:37:18.367
BACK . WE MENTIONED THE IMPEDIMENT IS THAT THE

01:37:20.367 --> 01:37:22.367
SEAL ZONING, THE DWELLING UNIT WITH THE COMMERCIAL ACCESSORY DRILLING UNIT

01:37:26.367 --> 01:37:28.367
BUT I WANTED TO . OUT THAT THIS PROPERTY IS GOVERNED BY,

01:37:29.367 --> 01:37:31.367
TO BRING IT TO THE BOARD ATTENTION BY GENERAL POLICY

01:37:35.367 --> 01:37:37.367
45, THAT TALKS ABOUT THE SECOND SENTENCE IN THE

01:37:41.367 --> 01:37:43.367
POLICY AS ADDITIONAL USES OF I'M SORRY MIXED RESIDENTIAL COMMERCIAL UNITS PERMITTED

01:37:44.367 --> 01:37:46.367
BY THE COMMERCIAL ZONING. THE PARTIAL SELBY

01:37:47.367 --> 01:37:49.367
COMMITTED AND THAT PARTIAL OF THAT ZONE COMMERCIAL. TO FOLLOW UP,

01:37:56.300 --> 01:37:59.300
AND I WOULD HAVE TO SPEND SOME TIME LOOKING INTO IT
AND I KNOW THE STATE HAS, MY RECOLLECTION WAS SOME OF THE WORK WE HAVE BEEN DOING

01:38:02.300 --> 01:38:04.300
ON THE HOUSING ELEMENT, WE NEED TO LOOK INTO

01:38:05.300 --> 01:38:07.300
IT. THERE HAVE BEEN SOME STATE CHANGES WITH COMMERCIAL ZONES

01:38:08.300 --> 01:38:10.300
IN REGARDS TO HOUSING. I DO NOT WANT TO

01:38:13.300 --> 01:38:15.300
SPECULATE MORE ON THAT BECAUSE THAT IS NOT SOMETHING I

01:38:17.300 --> 01:38:19.300
HAVE HAD TIME TO RESEARCH. THANK YOU.

01:38:20.300 --> 01:38:22.300
>> SUPERVISOR GREGORY? >> THANK YOU. ONE MORE.

01:38:26.300 --> 01:38:28.300
AND THEN ANOTHER QUESTION FROM ME. BUT FIRST, I WILL SAY

01:38:32.300 --> 01:38:34.300
THE DEVELOPER NEEDS TO BE DOING MORE ZONES, IN A WAY.

01:38:38.300 --> 01:38:40.300
AND WE CONTROL THIS. I THINK THAT IS WHAT YOU ARE SAYING. QUESTION.

01:38:44.300 --> 01:38:46.300
A TREND IN HOTEL DEVELOPMENT IN MORE URBAN AREAS

01:38:50.300 --> 01:38:52.300
IS GRANTING RESIDENCES. SOME OF THEM ARE A TITLE, YOU KNOW, TO A UNIT THAT

01:38:53.300 --> 01:38:55.300
IS A HOTEL ROOM , ISN'T IT?

01:39:00.233 --> 01:39:02.233
I AM JUST TRYING TO CREATE AN INVENTORY OF TOOLS FOR

01:39:03.233 --> 01:39:05.233
US TODAY. DOES OUR ZONING

01:39:05.500 --> 01:39:07.500
ALLOW FOR THAT FLEXIBILITY?

01:39:07.933 --> 01:39:09.933
>> WE DO NOT HAVE

01:39:12.233 --> 01:39:14.233
THAT CONTEMPLATING OUR ZONING.

01:39:15.233 --> 01:39:17.233
PER THE COMMENT BY SUPERVISOR PEDROZA .

01:39:19.233 --> 01:39:22.233
THAT IS DEFINITELY SOMETHING WE CAN LOOK INTO.
>> EXPRESSING MY SUPPORT.

01:39:25.233 --> 01:39:27.233
ALLOWING US THIS KIND OF FLEXIBILITY.

01:39:28.900 --> 01:39:31.100
THANK YOU.
>> SUPERVISOR COTTRELL?

01:39:35.233 --> 01:39:38.233
>> THANK YOU, JEREMY THANK YOU,
MR. ENGLAND, AND THE TEAM FOR BEING HERE TODAY.

01:39:42.233 --> 01:39:44.233
I THINK ONE OF THE THINGS, AGAIN, JUST THE CONTEXT OF THE SITE WHERE

01:39:45.233 --> 01:39:47.233
LOOKING AT REMIND OURSELVES THIS HAS BEEN HOME TO COMMERCIAL USES FOR DECADES.

01:39:51.233 --> 01:39:53.233
MY MOM USED TO WORK AT --I WORKED AT -- TERRACE AND

01:39:56.167 --> 01:39:58.167
MY HUSBAND WASHED DISHES AT THE FREMONT ABBEY RESTAURANT. WE HAVE SOME HISTORY

01:40:00.167 --> 01:40:02.167
ON THIS SITE. IT IS IMPORTANT TO ME THAT

01:40:06.167 --> 01:40:08.167
THE COUNTY CAN WORK WITH YOUR TEAM TO FIGURE OUT

01:40:11.167 --> 01:40:13.167
WHAT A SOLUTION ON-SITE IS OR A POTENTIAL SET

01:40:15.167 --> 01:40:17.167
OF SOLUTIONS. AND I'M ALSO CONCERNED ABOUT INTENSITY

01:40:18.167 --> 01:40:20.167
OF USE AT THAT SITE. THIS IS

01:40:24.167 --> 01:40:26.167
A LIEN AND AN INTERSECTION THAT IS ALREADY CHALLENGING. YOU KNOW,

01:40:29.167 --> 01:40:31.167
RESIDENTS AND NEIGHBORS ARE CONCERNED ABOUT WHAT

01:40:32.167 --> 01:40:34.167
IS HAPPENING AND WHAT COULD HAPPEN THERE.

01:40:35.167 --> 01:40:37.167
YOU KNOW, I LIKE WE ARE IN CONVERSATION ABOUT A DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT. AS

01:40:39.167 --> 01:40:41.167
I DO A LITTLE RESEARCH ON THOSE, IT GIVES THE APPLICANT SOME CERTAINTY

01:40:42.167 --> 01:40:44.167
.

01:40:45.167 --> 01:40:47.167
AND IT SHOULD GIVE JURISDICTION

01:40:51.167 --> 01:40:53.167
THE LAND USED GALATIANS CAN GET US.

01:40:59.100 --> 01:41:01.100
YOU CAN BE ASKING FOR MORE. AND THEN THAT BASELINE FROM THE REGULATION.

01:41:06.100 --> 01:41:08.100
I DO NOT HAVE , I'M GLAD WE ARE EXPLORING

01:41:11.100 --> 01:41:13.100
WHAT WE COULD DO WITH CL. I'M INTERESTED IN A BIGGER HOUSE AND COMPORTMENT OF

01:41:17.100 --> 01:41:19.100
THIS PROJECT. I'M CONCERNED WE MAINTAINED THE INTEGRITY OF OUR PRESERVE. AND NOT CREATING

01:41:25.100 --> 01:41:27.100
UNDER THE TYPE OF SITUATION IS SOMETHING WE ALWAYS WANT TO THINK ABOUT.

01:41:33.100 --> 01:41:35.100
WHAT WE HAVE ALREADY HEARD FROM SUPERVISOR GREGORY AND SUPERVISOR PEDROZA

01:41:39.100 --> 01:41:41.100
FOR ONE OF THESE THINGS BACK TO THE INTENSITY OF WATER AND

01:41:42.100 --> 01:41:44.100
TRAFFIC . THOSE WILL BE HUGE AND IMPORTANT IMPACTS

01:41:53.100 --> 01:41:55.100
WITH NEIGHBORS. I'M GLAD WE'RE HAVING THIS CONVERSATION ABOUT DIRECTION

01:41:57.330 --> 01:41:59.330
A LOT OF INFORMATION THAT WE WILL GET IN
THE ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS THAT I THINK WILL INFORM KIND OF WHAT WE

01:42:03.330 --> 01:42:05.330
COLLECTIVELY WANT. I AM A LITTLE BIT, I

01:42:07.330 --> 01:42:09.330
DON'T KNOW. I'M HESITANT OR CONFUSED ABOUT HOW WE MOVE FORWARD. AND

01:42:12.330 --> 01:42:14.330
ALSO WITH SOME INFORMATION FROM THE TRAN18 FOR THAT IS MORE

01:42:18.330 --> 01:42:21.330
STATEMENT THAN A QUESTION .
>> AND I AGREE WITH YOU A LITTLE BIT?

01:42:21.330 --> 01:42:23.330
IT IS A LITTLE CHICKEN AND EGG. I FEEL LIKE

01:42:24.330 --> 01:42:27.330
THE COUNTY DOES NOT, THIS IS NOT A CRITICISM.
THIS IS THE PROCESS. WE COME TO A BOARD WITH PROPOSED

01:42:30.330 --> 01:42:32.330
AGREEMENTS. THE BOARD GIVE AGREEMENT, AND

01:42:33.330 --> 01:42:35.330
STAFFING GOES IN AND WITH THAT DIRECTION, NEGOTIATES

01:42:36.330 --> 01:42:38.330
WITH THE APPLICANT , RIGHT? I CANNOT GET TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL

01:42:39.330 --> 01:42:41.330
IMPACT REPORT STAGE THAT WOULD INFORM ALL OF YOUR DECISION-MAKING

01:42:42.330 --> 01:42:44.330
ON THOSE ISSUES AND OTHERS UNTIL

01:42:47.330 --> 01:42:49.330
WE HAVE THIS DISCUSSION TODAY. I THINK THE WAY I VIEW

01:42:51.330 --> 01:42:53.330
THE PROCESS IS THAT , YOU KNOW, YOU

01:42:57.330 --> 01:42:59.330
ARE NOT BOUND BY ANYTHING TODAY, RIGHT? YOU ARE NOT

01:43:00.330 --> 01:43:02.330
BOUND TO APPROVE THE PROJECT. YOU'RE NOT BOUND.

01:43:09.330 --> 01:43:12.330
SO FOR TALKING PURPOSES, IF THERE WERE
AN IMPACT IN THE EIR, IT IS OF PARTICULAR CONCERN. YOU JUST THROUGH

01:43:15.330 --> 01:43:17.330
MITIGATION METER OR IF YOU FEEL LIKE IT RISES TO THE LEVEL OF BENEFIT,

01:43:18.330 --> 01:43:20.330
THEN YOU ADDRESS IT IN THE DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT.

01:43:23.330 --> 01:43:25.330
AND I THINK THAT IS A WAY WHERE THOSE TWO NEEDS

01:43:30.330 --> 01:43:32.330
, OUR NEED TO GET SOME FEEDBACK FROM THE BOARD SO WE CAN START NEGOTIATING

01:43:33.330 --> 01:43:35.330
THE COUNTY STAFF AND WHAT THE BOARD WOULD LIKE TO SEE AND THE NEED TO HAVE

01:43:39.330 --> 01:43:42.330
AN INFORMED EIR THAT CAN ONLY HAPPEN AFTER WE
DO WHAT WE ARE DOING TODAY. I THINK THAT IS THE WAY THOSE TWO RINGS COME

01:43:45.330 --> 01:43:47.330
TOGETHER.

01:44:00.967 --> 01:44:02.967
I WOULD LIKE TO HAVE MORE INFORMATION FROM THE ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS, AND

01:44:07.967 --> 01:44:09.967
PARTICULARLY, YOU KNOW, AGAIN, WHEN I MET WITH YOUR TEAM, YOU TALKED

01:44:13.967 --> 01:44:16.967
ABOUT HOW THIS IS NOT INTENSIFYING THE USE ON THE SITES,
SO TO UNPACK THAT A LITTLE BIT AND UNDERSTAND --YOU KNOW, THE WATER USE IS STAYING THE

01:44:23.967 --> 01:44:26.967
SAME OR DECREASING, THE TRAFFIC IMPACT IS STAYING THE SAME OR DECREASING,
AND HERE WE HAVE AN INTERESTING SITUATION OF GASSED AND STOP

01:44:29.967 --> 01:44:31.967
WILL BE CROSSING LODI LANE, WHICH I HAVE NO IDEA HOW TO

01:44:37.967 --> 01:44:39.967
WRAP OUR HEADS AROUND WHAT THAT IMPACT LOOKS LIKE. I GUESS I AM

01:44:40.967 --> 01:44:43.967
LOOKING ON MORE INFORMATION ON IMPACTS AS WE HAVE THE DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
CONVERSATION AS WELL. AND THEN, JUST KEEP

01:44:46.967 --> 01:44:48.967
GOING THROUGH MY LIST, AND SHELTER EASEMENTS, I APPRECIATE

01:44:57.900 --> 01:44:59.900
THAT YOU GUYS DID THAT. I WILL NOTE THAT I THINK THERE ARE 15 EASEMENTS

01:45:04.900 --> 01:45:06.900
, AND 12 OF THOSE WERE DONATED BY OTHER LANDOWNERS, SO,

01:45:17.900 --> 01:45:19.900
LOTS OF ABBY'S NEIGHBORS HAVE BEEN DONATING THEIR EASEMENTS AS WELL, AND

01:45:20.900 --> 01:45:22.900
NOT NECESSARILY GETTING A BENEFIT IN RETURN, SO, THAT IS A PUBLIC BENEFIT.

01:45:30.900 --> 01:45:33.900
HOW MUCH THAT COUNTS. I DON'T KNOW IF WE HAVE NUMBERS
ON HOW WE ARE VALUING THAT EASEMENT, BECAUSE THERE IS ALSO THIS ASK FOR

01:45:35.900 --> 01:45:37.900
A FEE CREDIT AS WELL. LET'S WELCOME THE FEE CREDIT ASK

01:45:39.900 --> 01:45:42.900
WAS AT A TIME WHEN THE COUNTY WAS CONTEMPLATING A TRANSPORTATION IMPACT
FEE.
I HAVE NOT SEEN THAT DISCUSSION DEVELOP.

01:45:43.900 --> 01:45:45.900
YOU KNOW, I THINK IT IS A FAIR POINT, SUPERVISOR COTTRELL,

01:45:49.900 --> 01:45:51.900
A LOT OF THEM DONATED EASEMENTS, I

01:45:53.900 --> 01:45:55.900
WORKED ON A WHOLE BUNCH OF THEM UP AND DOWN THE LINE.

01:45:58.833 --> 01:46:00.833
I GUESS WE KNOW, JUST TO SHOW WE ARE NOT TRYING TO TAKE CREDIT AFTER --

01:46:01.833 --> 01:46:03.833
THE REASON WHY WE NOTED IS BECAUSE WE POSTED

01:46:06.833 --> 01:46:08.833
AND WE DIDN'T WITHHOLD IT. SO, IT IS CONTEXT WHAT

01:46:15.833 --> 01:46:18.833
THE BOARD FEELS LIKE IN TERMS OF HOW MUCH THE PUBLIC BENEFIT, I DON'T
THINK THERE IS A MATHEMATICAL FORMULA FOR THAT, THAT IS UP TO EVERY BOARD

01:46:19.833 --> 01:46:21.833
MEMBER ON HOW MUCH THEY FEEL LIKE THAT WE IS IN THE CALCULATION.

01:46:25.833 --> 01:46:27.833
>> GOT IT, THANK YOU, I THINK THAT'S ALL THE QUESTIONS I HAVE

01:46:28.267 --> 01:46:29.933
AT THIS POINT.
>> OKAY, THANK YOU. I HAVE A COUPLE QUESTIONS.

01:46:31.833 --> 01:46:33.833
YOU KNOW, I DO SEE FROM

01:46:37.833 --> 01:46:39.833
THE PROPOSED TERMS OF BENEFIT FOR THE APPLICANT , REGARDING THE HISTORICAL

01:46:43.833 --> 01:46:45.833
VESTED WASTEWATER TREATMENT, AND WE HAVE HEARD A LITTLE

01:46:46.833 --> 01:46:48.833
BIT ABOUT WATER ALREADY , AND WE HAVE RECEIVED PUBLIC COMMENTS AND

01:46:55.767 --> 01:46:57.767
KIND OF A LAYOUT FOR US, IN TERMS OF WATER USAGE, HISTORICAL

01:46:58.767 --> 01:47:00.767
WATER USAGE, WHAT TYPE OF ON-SITE

01:47:04.767 --> 01:47:06.767
MITIGATIONS YOU ARE GOING TO HAVE FOR WATER USAGE.

01:47:07.767 --> 01:47:09.767
>> RAY, SO, I

01:47:10.767 --> 01:47:12.767
THINK IT IS IMPORTANT --WELL, FIRST OF ALL, THE ITEMS THAT

01:47:16.767 --> 01:47:19.767
ARE LISTED THAT ARE DESCRIBED AS ITEMS BENEFITING
THE APPLICANT, THERE ARE A COUPLE IN THERE.

01:47:22.767 --> 01:47:25.767
THE PARKING IS RECOGNIZED AS ASSOCIATED WITH THE FREE MARKET ABBY
COMMERCIAL ZONE LANDS, THAT IS ALREADY RECOGNIZED.

01:47:28.767 --> 01:47:30.767
IT IS APPROVED IN THE USE PERMIT, THAT IS EXISTING ENTITLEMENT.

01:47:31.767 --> 01:47:33.767
I THINK OUR GOAL IN PUTTING THAT

01:47:36.767 --> 01:47:38.767
FOR THE AND THERE IS WE ARE GOING TO CONTINUE RELYING ON THAT FOR THIS

01:47:39.767 --> 01:47:41.767
PROJECT. WE CAN USE IT TODAY FOR COMMERCIAL, THE RESTAURANTS AND THE OTHER THINGS, BUT

01:47:42.767 --> 01:47:45.767
WE ARE WANTING TO SHOW THAT THAT IS CONTINUED RELIANCE ON THAT EXISTING
ENTITLEMENT. ON THE SOUTH SIDE, THERE IS

01:47:47.300 --> 01:47:49.300
A SEPTIC LEACH FIELD THAT SERVES THE COMMERCIAL STRIP . I KEEP FORGETTING

01:47:53.233 --> 01:47:55.233
--[ INDESCERNIBLE ] BUT SO, WE

01:48:01.233 --> 01:48:03.233
ARE GOING TO CONTINUE TO USE THAT FOOTPRINT, BECAUSE IT IS ON A W LANDS,

01:48:04.233 --> 01:48:06.233
BUT THAT WASTEWATER SYSTEM IS ESTABLISHED AND LEGAL ANSWERS A COMMERCIAL

01:48:07.233 --> 01:48:09.233
USE, BUT WE ARE NOT EXPANDING THE FOOTPRINT OF THAT.
BUT WE WANT IT TO BE CLEAR THAT THAT IS

01:48:11.233 --> 01:48:13.233
WHAT WE ARE DOING.

01:48:14.233 --> 01:48:16.233
SIMILARLY, JUST TO TOUCH ON THIS, YOU CAN ASK

01:48:17.233 --> 01:48:19.233
ABOUT THIS, BUT WHEN WE TALK ABOUT HAVING HOTEL GUESTS VISIT THIS AGRICULTURE AREA, WE ARE

01:48:20.233 --> 01:48:22.233
NOT TRYING TO CHANGE WHAT WE ARE DOING

01:48:26.233 --> 01:48:28.233
ON AGRICULTURAL LANDS, BUT WE WANT TO BE REALLY CLEAR THAT WE

01:48:29.233 --> 01:48:31.233
ARE GOING TO HAVE A REALLY NICE AGRICULTURAL OPERATION

01:48:32.233 --> 01:48:34.233
THERE THAT WILL LOOK A LOT BETTER THAN IT DOES TODAY. THE JACKSON

01:48:35.233 --> 01:48:37.233
FAMILY HAS DONE A SIMILAR CULINARY GUARDED IN

01:48:38.233 --> 01:48:41.233
SONOMA COUNTY, IT IS BEAUTIFUL. BUT WE WOULD
LIKE OUR HOTEL GUESTS TO LEGALLY BE ALLOWED TO WALK THROUGH IT. WE DON'T WANT

01:48:42.233 --> 01:48:44.233
TO HAVE FUTURE DISCUSSIONS AND MISUNDERSTANDINGS.

01:48:49.233 --> 01:48:51.233
WE JUST WANT TO BE REALLY UP-FRONT AND CLEAR ABOUT THAT ASPECT. AS

01:48:53.167 --> 01:48:55.167
TO THE WATER USED, WE HAVE A WATER AVAILABILITY ANALYSIS THAT IS SUBMITTED,

01:48:56.167 --> 01:48:58.167
IT WILL BE STUDIED IN THE EIR, SO THIS STUDY

01:48:59.167 --> 01:49:01.167
WILL BE DISCUSSED IN GREAT DETAIL.

01:49:04.167 --> 01:49:06.167
PART OF OUR WATER SUPPLY COMES THROUGH AN EXISTING WATER AGREEMENT THAT

01:49:08.167 --> 01:49:10.167
SERVES THE NORTH PARCEL, THE PARCELS NORTH OF LODI LANE.

01:49:15.167 --> 01:49:17.167
IT DOES NOT BENEFIT THE SOUTH SIDE OF

01:49:18.167 --> 01:49:20.167
LODI LANE, AND WE KNOW THIS.

01:49:24.167 --> 01:49:27.167
THE DEMAND FOR THE SOUTH SIDE WILL BE SERVED WITH GROUNDWATER. THERE IS
AN EXISTING PUBLIC WATER SYSTEM ON THE SOUTH SIDE WITH IT WELL, THERE IS

01:49:30.167 --> 01:49:32.167
A FIVE UNIT HOTEL APPROVED THERE NOW, IN ADDITION TO THE COMMERCIAL ZONE, AND THEN

01:49:33.167 --> 01:49:35.167
WE HAVE THE RESIDENTIAL UNITS THERE. SO, WE ALREADY

01:49:37.167 --> 01:49:39.167
HAVE THAT WATER SYSTEM ESTABLISHED ON THE

01:49:42.167 --> 01:49:44.167
SOUTH PORTION OF LODI LANE. SO, WE ARE USING MULTIPLE WATER RESOURCES.

01:49:47.167 --> 01:49:49.167
AND SO, WHEN WE SAY IN MEETINGS, WHEN YOU LOOK AT ALL OF THE ENTITLEMENTS

01:49:50.167 --> 01:49:52.167
THAT THE PROPERTY HAS, TWO RESTAURANTS, COMMERCIAL --A COMMERCIAL --I DON'T KNOW

01:49:58.100 --> 01:50:00.100
WHAT TO CALL IT, IT IS NOT NECESSARILY AS MALL, BUT A COMMERCIAL CENTER,

01:50:06.100 --> 01:50:09.100
FIVE UNIT HOTEL ON THE SOUTH PARK. WHEN YOU LOOK AT ALL OF THOSE
TRAFFIC AND WATER USES, THIS HOTEL WILL

01:50:11.100 --> 01:50:13.100
USE LESS WATER THAN THAT, AND IT WILL GENERATE LESS TRAFFIC

01:50:14.100 --> 01:50:16.100
THAN ALL OF THOSE USES WOULD BE. SO, WE ARE COMPARING WHAT WE ARE PROPOSING

01:50:21.100 --> 01:50:23.100
VERSUS THE ENTITLED BASELINE OR THE ENTITLEMENTS THAT ARE THERE

01:50:25.100 --> 01:50:27.100
ON THE PROPERTY. AT THIS COMMERCIAL SITE THAT WAS HOME TO THE HEARD CANDLE FACTORY,

01:50:30.100 --> 01:50:32.100
SEMOLINA BREWING, A BUNCH OF DIFFERENT RESTAURANTS. I

01:50:33.100 --> 01:50:35.100
HADN'T HEARD ABOUT KNICKERBOCKERS, BUT YOU KNOW, IT SOUNDS

01:50:36.100 --> 01:50:38.100
LIKE IT WAS FUN. SO, ALL OF THOSE ISSUES

01:50:45.100 --> 01:50:47.100
WILL AND MUST BE ADDRESSED IN THE EIR.

01:50:49.100 --> 01:50:51.100
THE CITY OF SEMOLINA IS WATCHING WHAT WE ARE DOING AND THEY

01:50:53.330 --> 01:50:55.330
WHEN WE SUBMITTED THE APPLICATION, I REACHED

01:50:56.330 --> 01:50:58.330
OUT TO CITY MANAGER MARK, WE TALKED TO THE MAYOR AT THE TIME, THE CITY COUNCIL

01:51:00.330 --> 01:51:02.330
MEMBERS AT THE TIME.

01:51:03.330 --> 01:51:05.330
NOW THAT THE PROJECT IS --AFTER A PRETTY LONG PAUSE, THE PROJECT

01:51:06.330 --> 01:51:08.330
IS KIND OF STARTING TO GO THROUGH MORE PROCESS, YOU KNOW, I HAVE

01:51:12.330 --> 01:51:14.330
CONTACTED THE CITY MANAGER AND THE NEW PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR. WE ARE

01:51:15.330 --> 01:51:17.330
HAPPY TO TALK ABOUT , YOU KNOW, THEIR CONCERNS

01:51:21.330 --> 01:51:24.330
AS A WATER SUPPLIER TO THE SITE.
WE ARE NOT LOOKING FOR THEM TO SUPPLY ANY ADDITIONAL WATER OTHER THAN

01:51:26.330 --> 01:51:28.330
WHAT IS AGREED TO IN THE WATER AGREEMENT.
>> SO, JUST TO CLARIFY, SO, GIVEN THE EXISTING ALLOWABLE

01:51:30.330 --> 01:51:32.330
USES AND THE BASELINE ON THE SOUTH PARCEL,

01:51:36.330 --> 01:51:38.330
THE REAL INCREASE THEN COMES FROM THE ADDITIONAL SIX

01:51:42.330 --> 01:51:44.330
GUEST ROOMS, CORRECT?

01:51:48.330 --> 01:51:50.330
BECAUSE YOUR PROPOSAL HAS 11 GUEST ROOMS, YOU ARE SAYING FIVE ARE PERMITTED.

01:51:53.967 --> 01:51:55.967
>> YEAH, I GUESS IF YOU DID THE MATH THAT WAY, YEAH. NEXT SO, IT IS SIX. THE

01:51:56.967 --> 01:51:59.967
HOUSING THAT IS CURRENTLY ON-SITE IS ALREADY SUPPORTED BY GROUNDWATER.
>> A PART OF IT IS NOT. SO,

01:52:05.967 --> 01:52:07.967
OF THE SIX UNITS THAT ARE ON THE SOUTH PARCEL,

01:52:08.967 --> 01:52:10.967
FIVE OF THOSE UNITS, WHICH ARE RECOGNIZED IN THE CERTIFICATE OF LEGAL

01:52:11.967 --> 01:52:13.967
NONCONFORMITY, THEY ARE ON GROUNDWATER. THE RESIDENCE

01:52:14.967 --> 01:52:16.967
THAT IS CLOSER TO 29 IS

01:52:20.967 --> 01:52:22.967
ON A DOMESTIC CITY OF ST. HELENA CONNECTION.

01:52:23.967 --> 01:52:25.967
>> SO, WHAT --

01:52:32.967 --> 01:52:34.967
>> WHICH IS SEPARATE AND APART FROM THE WATER AGREEMENT ON THE NORTH PARCEL, RIGHT? IT

01:52:35.967 --> 01:52:37.967
IS JUST A DOMESTIC CITY OF SEMOLINA CONNECTION,

01:52:40.967 --> 01:52:43.967
WHICH HAPPENS FROM TIME TO TIME, THE CITY OF NAPA HAS THOSE,
AND OTHER PROPERTIES ALONG THE WATER LINE, WHEN CITIES GOT PERMISSION

01:52:45.967 --> 01:52:47.967
TO COME THROUGH AND PUT THE WATER LINE THROUGH PROPERTIES, OFTENTIMES THEY

01:52:48.967 --> 01:52:50.967
ARE OFFERED DOMESTIC CONNECTIONS.

01:52:53.967 --> 01:52:55.967
AND THOSE WHAT THE APPROVED TODAY, I DON'T THINK, BUT THEY EXIST. THE SADO OF

01:52:59.967 --> 01:53:01.967
NAPA HAS A TON GOING DOWN 29 IN THE OAKFIELD AREA,

01:53:02.967 --> 01:53:04.967
BUT THAT IS WHERE THAT ONE RESIDENCE IS, JUST

01:53:05.767 --> 01:53:07.767
FOR COMPLETE, YOU KNOW, FULL DISCLOSURE.

01:53:08.333 --> 01:53:10.433
>> LUCKY YOU, THIS SOUNDS
LIKE A BAR EXAM.

01:53:10.433 --> 01:53:12.433
>> IT FEELS LIKE ONE A LITTLE BIT.

01:53:14.967 --> 01:53:16.967
>> YEAH, IT IS FEELING LIKE IT, THERE ARE SOME FLASHBACKS I

01:53:19.967 --> 01:53:21.967
AM HAVING HERE RIGHT NOW. OKAY, I SEE NO OTHER QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD RIGHT NOW,

01:53:26.967 --> 01:53:28.967
WE ARE NOT DONE WITH YOU, I AM GOING TO LET

01:53:29.967 --> 01:53:31.967
YOU TAKE A SEAT FOR A BIT, I'M GOING TO OPEN PUBLIC COMMENTS,

01:53:32.967 --> 01:53:34.967
THEN WE WILL HAVE YOU BACK UP, BECAUSE I AM SURE THERE WILL BE MORE. I

01:53:35.967 --> 01:53:37.967
WILL OPEN PUBLIC COMMENT ON THIS ITEM. PUBLIC COMMENT IS LIMITED

01:53:38.967 --> 01:53:41.967
TO THREE MINUTES AND ONLY WITHIN THE SCOPE
OF WHAT IS BEING PROPOSED TODAY, AND THAT IS PROPOSED TERMS

01:53:44.967 --> 01:53:46.967
FOR THE DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT.

01:53:49.967 --> 01:53:51.967
>> GOOD MORNING, SUPERVISORS, I AM CHOCK SENTIMENT, 134

01:53:53.900 --> 01:53:55.900
HOUSING COALITION. I HAVE SPOKEN TO THE SUPERVISORS IN THE PAST, AS A

01:53:59.900 --> 01:54:01.900
THE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION, TALKING ABOUT THE ISSUE OF HOTELS,

01:54:02.900 --> 01:54:04.900
AS WELL AS WINETASTING SITUATIONS WHERE WE KEEP TALKING ABOUT ISSUES OF TRAFFIC

01:54:08.900 --> 01:54:10.900
AND HOUSING AND ALL THE REST, AND WE NEVER SEEM TO QUITE

01:54:15.900 --> 01:54:17.900
GET SOLUTIONS TO THOSE. SO MUCH OF IT IS ALL AD HOC,

01:54:20.900 --> 01:54:22.900
THAT I HAPPENED TO BE HERE YEARS AGO WHEN THE PROJECT OVER THE

01:54:24.900 --> 01:54:26.900
OLD RED PEN, LITERALLY THE PROPONENTS SPAT OUT IN THE HALLWAY

01:54:28.900 --> 01:54:30.900
AND NEGOTIATED AN AGREEMENT TO DO THAT. HOUSING THERE.

01:54:36.900 --> 01:54:38.900
AND IT IS HAPPENING NOT JUST IN THE COUNTY, IT IS HAPPENING IN THE CITY

01:54:39.900 --> 01:54:42.900
IS AS WELL, EVERYTHING SEEMS TO BE VERY, VERY AD HOC. I RECOGNIZE
THAT WHAT THE JACKSON FAMILY IS PROPOSING --AND I AM ALSO A POTTING --

01:54:48.900 --> 01:54:50.900
THEY HAVE HAD THE WISDOM WHO IS A PART OF OUR COMMUNITY

01:54:55.833 --> 01:54:57.833
, WITH A THOUGHTFUL GUY, AND I AM VERY HAPPY TO SEE

01:54:58.833 --> 01:55:00.833
THAT. OUR DILEMMA IS THAT WHAT WE SEE AS THE COALITION IS THE PROPOSALS

01:55:03.833 --> 01:55:05.833
THAT ARE BEFORE YOU ARE STILL WOEFULLY INADEQUATE, GIVEN

01:55:06.833 --> 01:55:08.833
THE IMPACTS THAT WERE CREATED.

01:55:09.833 --> 01:55:11.833
WE ARE NOT EXPERTS IN COMING UP WITH THOSE NUMBERS, AND

01:55:14.833 --> 01:55:16.833
WHAT I HAVE GIVEN TO YOU AND TO STAFF IS OUTLINES DONE IN THE CITY OF NAPA,

01:55:18.833 --> 01:55:20.833
DONE BY SOME ECONOMIC STUDIES

01:55:22.833 --> 01:55:24.833
, SHOWING THAT ROUGHLY HALF OF THE HOUSING COMING TO A TYPICAL HOTEL

01:55:27.833 --> 01:55:29.833
AS IT QUALIFIES FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING AT 80% OF AMI

01:55:30.833 --> 01:55:32.833
OR LOWER, AND JUST USING THE NUMBERS FROM THE

01:55:37.833 --> 01:55:39.833
STUDIES THAT WE HAVE SEEN BEFORE, THAT THE JACKSON FAMILY PROPOSAL WOULD

01:55:42.833 --> 01:55:44.833
REQUIRE SOMEWHERE BETWEEN 21 AND 41 NEW HOUSING UNITS , AGAIN, ROUGHLY

01:55:45.833 --> 01:55:47.833
HALF OF THOSE AFFORDABLE. BUT WE DID ASK THAT

01:55:50.833 --> 01:55:52.833
SOME KIND OF STUDY BE DONE AS PART OF THAT PROPOSAL.

01:55:54.767 --> 01:55:56.767
WE DON'T KNOW IF THAT IS BEING DONE AS

01:55:57.767 --> 01:55:59.767
PART OF THE EIR OR NOT.

01:56:00.767 --> 01:56:02.767
BUT WHAT I AM HEARING IS THERE SEEMS TO BE A
REAL STRONG WILLINGNESS ON BEHALF OF THE JACKSON FAMILY TO TRY TO

01:56:06.767 --> 01:56:08.767
SOLVE SOME OF THESE.

01:56:09.767 --> 01:56:11.767
AND I KNOW THAT YOU AS ELECTED OFFICIALS RUN INTO SITUATIONS WHERE

01:56:12.767 --> 01:56:14.767
THE DEVELOPERS HAVE NO WILLINGNESS TO PARTICIPATE IN

01:56:17.767 --> 01:56:19.767
TRYING TO SOLVE PROBLEMS, AND I AM VERY IMPRESSED THAT AS ADMINISTERED

01:56:21.767 --> 01:56:23.767
WAS SAYING, THERE IS A WILLINGNESS TO TRY TO SOLVE SOME

01:56:24.767 --> 01:56:26.767
OF THIS. AGAIN, IT IS THE DILEMMA. AGAIN, EVERYTHING

01:56:28.767 --> 01:56:30.767
SEEMS TO BE SO AD HOC, WE WOULD LOVE TO SEE SOME MORE MEAT

01:56:31.767 --> 01:56:33.767
OVERTIME, TO LOOK AT NOT JUST HOTELS, BUT THE WINERY EXPANSION IN TERMS OF THE NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES

01:56:42.767 --> 01:56:44.767
THEY ARE HAVING. SO, I WILL LEAVE IT AT THAT WITH MY THREE SECONDS

01:56:45.967 --> 01:56:47.833
LEFT, THANK YOU.
>> THANK YOU.

01:56:48.767 --> 01:56:50.767
ANY OTHER PUBLIC COMMENT?

01:56:54.700 --> 01:56:56.700
SEEING NONE.

01:56:57.700 --> 01:56:59.700
>> NO ONE ON THE LINE.

01:57:00.700 --> 01:57:03.700
>> OKAY. THANK YOU.
I WILL CLOSE PUBLIC COMMENT AND I WILL BRING

01:57:06.700 --> 01:57:08.700
IT BACK TO THE BOARD. SO, YOU

01:57:10.700 --> 01:57:13.700
MIGHT WANT TO GET YOUR NOTEPAD READY.
SUPERVISOR GALLAGHER?

01:57:15.700 --> 01:57:17.700
>> THANK YOU.

01:57:18.700 --> 01:57:20.700
I HAVE A FEW COMMENTS PRETTY MUCH ON EACH OF THE PROPOSED TERMS

01:57:24.700 --> 01:57:26.700
OF PUBLIC BENEFIT AND -- FIRST,

01:57:30.700 --> 01:57:32.700
JUST WANTED TO WEIGH IN ON THIS IDEA.

01:57:33.700 --> 01:57:35.700
I THINK WE WANT TO BE REALLY CAUTIOUS,

01:57:36.700 --> 01:57:38.700
BECAUSE BASICALLY IN THE COUNTY, THESE ZONES ARE

01:57:40.700 --> 01:57:42.700
ALL SURROUNDED BY AGRICULTURE, SO MAKING SURE THAT WE DON'T

01:57:43.700 --> 01:57:45.700
GO SOMEWHERE WE REALLY DON'T WANT TO GO IN TERMS

01:57:47.700 --> 01:57:49.700
OF URBANIZING THOSE COMMERCIAL LIMITED PARCELS

01:57:53.633 --> 01:57:55.633
ARE MOSTLY PRETTY SMALL. THE ONE THING, THOUGH, THAT I THINK WOULD BE IMPORTANT TO DO,

01:58:00.633 --> 01:58:02.633
IF WE DO LOOK AT THE CL ZONING IS WHEN THE CL

01:58:05.633 --> 01:58:07.633
ZONING TALKS ABOUT HOTELS AND BEDS AND BREAKFASTS, IT SEEMS THERE SHOULD BE A MAXIMUM OF 50 UNITS.

01:58:17.633 --> 01:58:20.633
IT DOESN'T SAY IN THE PARCEL, BUT I AM
ASSUMING THAT IS WHAT IT MEANS, PER PARCEL. SO, I THINK MAYBE WE MISSED

01:58:22.633 --> 01:58:24.633
THE INTENT, WE DIDN'T REALLY TALK IN THE ZONING CODE

01:58:26.633 --> 01:58:28.633
ABOUT CONTIGUOUS PARCELS UNDER THE SAME OWNERSHIP.

01:58:32.633 --> 01:58:34.633
SO, THIS IS A CASE WHERE WE HAVE 50 UNITS ON ONE PARCEL AND 29

01:58:36.633 --> 01:58:38.633
UNITS ON ANOTHER, BUT THE IMPACT IS GREATER

01:58:39.633 --> 01:58:41.633
THAN 50 UNITS, AND I DON'T KNOW THAT THAT WAS WHAT WAS COMPLICATED

01:58:45.633 --> 01:58:48.633
WHEN THAT LANGUAGE WAS WRITTEN, BUT IT
IS SOMETHING TO LOOK AT IN THE FUTURE. IN TERMS OF THE PUBLIC BENEFIT

01:58:54.567 --> 01:58:56.567
THE ON-SITE AFFORDABLE HOUSING FOR EMPLOYEES, I SEE THAT

01:59:02.567 --> 01:59:04.567
AS AN APPLICANT BENEFIT, NOT NECESSARILY A PUBLIC BENEFIT,

01:59:06.567 --> 01:59:08.567
BECAUSE THE PLAN IS TO MAKE THAT EMPLOYEE HOUSING , IN TERMS

01:59:12.567 --> 01:59:14.567
OF WHAT THE LANGUAGE IS HERE. IN TERMS OF THE IMPACT IS, I HAVE TO AGREE WITH

01:59:21.567 --> 01:59:23.567
SUPERVISOR PEDROZA, IT IS MUCH MORE IMPORTANT TO

01:59:24.567 --> 01:59:26.567
GET HOUSING BUILT THEN IT IS TO COLLECT FEES, OUR FEARS ARE HONESTLY

01:59:32.567 --> 01:59:34.567
WOEFULLY INADEQUATE, AND 1.5 SOUNDS LIKE A LOT OF MONEY, THAT IS 1.5 TO THREE

01:59:36.567 --> 01:59:38.567
UNITS MAY BE. IF WHAT WE HAVE TO USE RIGHT NOW IS A FEE, I WOULD SUGGEST AT LEAST DOUBLING THAT.

01:59:43.567 --> 01:59:45.567
AND I WOULD ALSO SUGGEST THAT WE --THE FEE NEEDS TO BE PAID AT THE START,

01:59:52.500 --> 01:59:54.500
THAT THERE ISN'T A GAP OF 50% NOW AND 50% LATER, BECAUSE I THINK

01:59:59.500 --> 02:00:01.500
IN WORKING WITH OUR HOUSING AND HOMELESS DEPARTMENT, IT WOULD BE VERY IMPORTANT

02:00:03.500 --> 02:00:06.500
TO HAVE THE MONEY UP-FRONT AND NOT BE WAITING
HOWEVER LONG IT TAKES FOR THE PROJECT TO BE COMPLETED, THAT COULD

02:00:10.500 --> 02:00:12.500
BE MANY YEARS. UM, ACTUALLY, THE WEINTRAUB EASEMENT

02:00:19.500 --> 02:00:21.500
--NUMBER FOUR, IMPROVED SOUTH -- PARCEL AGRICULTURAL LANDS TO

02:00:28.500 --> 02:00:30.500
PRODUCTIVE AGRICULTURAL USE. I AM NOT REALLY CLEAR AS TO WHY THIS WOULD NEED TO

02:00:31.500 --> 02:00:33.500
BE IN THE DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT, THAT IS --

02:00:37.500 --> 02:00:39.500
IF YOU HAVE AN AGRICULTURAL PARCEL, YOU CAN USE IT FOR AGRICULTURAL USE, THERE

02:00:40.500 --> 02:00:43.500
IS NO REASON, I DON'T THINK, UNLESS YOU CAN TELL ME WHY TO INCLUDE IT
IN A DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT. ADDITIONALLY, THE

02:00:45.500 --> 02:00:47.500
FARM TO TABLE EXPERIENCE, WHICH BASICALLY, THE PARCEL WOULD

02:00:49.500 --> 02:00:51.500
BE USED FOR GARDEN FOR THE HOTEL RESTAURANT, I SEE THAT AS AN APPLICANT BENEFIT,

02:00:55.433 --> 02:00:57.433
NOT A PUBLIC BENEFIT.

02:00:58.433 --> 02:01:00.433
UM, THEN WHEN WE GO TO APPLICANT

02:01:01.433 --> 02:01:03.433
PROPOSED TERMS BENEFITING APPLICANT, NUMBER THREE, THE FEE CREDIT AGAINST

02:01:08.433 --> 02:01:10.433
ANY FUTURE ENACTED TRANSPORTATION IMPACT FEE IN AN AMOUNT EQUAL TO THE VALUE

02:01:16.433 --> 02:01:18.433
OF VINE TRAIL EASEMENTS, WE ARE NOT REALLY SURE WHAT THE VINE

02:01:22.433 --> 02:01:24.433
TRAIL EASEMENTS ARE WORTH, BUT IN ADDITION TO

02:01:25.433 --> 02:01:28.433
THAT, I THINK IT IS REALLY HARD FOR US TO AGREE TO SOMETHING THAT WE DON'T
HAVE YET. SO, WE HAVE NO TRANSPORTATION IMPACT

02:01:29.433 --> 02:01:31.433
FEE, WE DON'T HAVE ANY IDEA WHAT THAT WOULD LOOK LIKE. AND MY GUESS IS

02:01:34.433 --> 02:01:36.433
THE VINE TRAIL IS PROBABLY NOT GOING TO SUBSTANTIALLY AFFECT THE VMT AND THIS AREA.

02:01:40.433 --> 02:01:42.433
SERVING ALL THESE COMMERCIAL USES. UM, AND NUMBER FIVE,

02:01:46.433 --> 02:01:48.433
ALLOW HOTEL GUESTS TO TOUR THE MODEL AGRICULTURAL OPERATIONS. UM,

02:01:55.367 --> 02:01:57.367
I WANTED TO --I THINK I WANTED TO ASK A QUESTION THERE.

02:02:02.367 --> 02:02:04.367
I WOULD ASSUME --IT SAYS ACTIVITIES OF TORAH GUESTS LIMITED TO USE IS

02:02:05.367 --> 02:02:07.367
ALLOWED UNDER DEFINITION OF ABERRANT ALTAR. I DON'T KNOW IF THIS IS

02:02:10.367 --> 02:02:13.367
IN SOME WAY ASSOCIATED WITH THE WINERY, BECAUSE
IF IT IS IN ANY WAY, THEN IT WOULD BE OBVIOUSLY -- I THINK THAT

02:02:15.367 --> 02:02:17.367
GOT ANSWERED BY MR. ENGLAND IN TERMS OF IT BEING STRICT AGRICULTURAL ZONING.

02:02:19.367 --> 02:02:21.367
UM, THE OTHER THING I WANTED TO MENTION IS THAT

02:02:28.367 --> 02:02:30.367
IT WAS BROUGHT UP THAT THE APPLICANT

02:02:34.367 --> 02:02:36.367
IS COMPARING ENTITLED USES VERSUS PROPOSED.

02:02:40.367 --> 02:02:42.367
BUT WE ALSO KNOW THAT WHEN THE EIR IS

02:02:43.367 --> 02:02:45.367
DONE, IT IS OUR PRACTICE TO --

02:02:49.367 --> 02:02:51.367
THAT THE CEQA BASELINE IS THE CURRENT USE,

02:02:52.367 --> 02:02:55.367
NOT THE ENTITLED USE, SO I THINK IT IS JUST IMPORTANT THAT
WE REMEMBER IN ALL PHASES THAT WE ARE COMPARING WHAT IS

02:02:57.367 --> 02:02:59.367
HAPPENING ON SITE NOW, VERSUS WHAT IS PROPOSED, NOT WHAT IS ENTITLED VERSUS WHAT IS PROPOSED.

02:03:04.367 --> 02:03:06.367
I THINK THAT IS THE COMMENTS I HAVE FOR NOW. THANK YOU.

02:03:15.367 --> 02:03:17.367
>> I WILL LET STAFF FINISH WRITING, THEN WE WILL GO

02:03:18.367 --> 02:03:20.367
TO THE NEXT ONE. SUPERVISOR GREGORY?

02:03:22.367 --> 02:03:24.367
>> THANK YOU, APPRECIATE

02:03:30.367 --> 02:03:32.367
OUR SINGLE PUBLIC COMMENT TODAY, MR.
SENTIMENT, WHO I HAVE KNOWN FOR A LONG TIME, AND I AGREE WITH HIM THAT THIS

02:03:34.367 --> 02:03:36.367
STUFF SHOULDN'T BE AD HOC, THE WAY IT IS. BUT THAT IS WHY WE DO NEXUS

02:03:37.367 --> 02:03:39.367
STUDIES OCCASIONALLY, AND DETERMINE AN IMPACT OF BUSINESS SECTORS

02:03:43.367 --> 02:03:45.367
ON THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING NEEDS OF OUR COMMUNITY, AND APPLY A FEE USUALLY.

02:03:48.367 --> 02:03:50.367
EQUITABLY ACROSS THE BOARD, THAT'S WHY WE DO THAT

02:03:54.300 --> 02:03:56.300
. LATELY, HOSPITALITY HAS BEEN STOOD UP AS THIS THING THAT SHOULD DO

02:03:58.300 --> 02:04:01.300
MORE, AND SOME HAVE DONE MORE.
GREAT EXAMPLES IN THE CITY OF NAPA , WHO BUILT SOME UNITS, AND IT IS

02:04:06.300 --> 02:04:08.300
A GREAT TREND. BUT I THINK ANYTHING ON TOP OF WHAT WE NORMALLY ASK

02:04:09.300 --> 02:04:11.300
FOR IS A PUBLIC BENEFIT. SO, WHATEVER HOUSING , PARTICULARLY DEED RESTRICTED HOUSING

02:04:16.300 --> 02:04:18.300
--[ INDESCERNIBLE ] IN GENERAL, WE HAVE SO

02:04:23.300 --> 02:04:25.300
FEW CL ZONED LANCE, I JUST THINK THIS IS AN OPPORTUNITY WE SHOULD TAKE TO

02:04:28.300 --> 02:04:30.300
LOOK FOR FUTURE REVENUES FOR THE COUNTY.

02:04:31.300 --> 02:04:33.300
WE ALWAYS HAVE TO KEEP OUR EYE ON THAT. WE WORRY ABOUT

02:04:36.300 --> 02:04:38.300
THE CARRYING CAPACITY OF ALL THESE DIFFERENT THINGS WE DO FOR WINERIES, BUT

02:04:40.300 --> 02:04:42.300
THIS IS ONE WAY CL IS SO LIMITED, I FEEL WE SHOULD TAKE ADVANTAGE

02:04:43.300 --> 02:04:45.300
OF THESE VERY FEW ZONED PROPERTIES. AND LAST, I WILL

02:04:49.300 --> 02:04:51.300
JUST SAY I THINK WE NEED TO TO BUILD MORE HOUSING. I DON'T

02:04:54.233 --> 02:04:56.233
KNOW WHAT THE NUMBER IS. THAT SHOULD REMAIN TO BE

02:04:58.233 --> 02:05:00.233
SEEN, BUT I DON'T KNOW HOW THAT WOULD FIT.

02:05:03.233 --> 02:05:05.233
MAYBE THIS IS A COMMENT AND QUESTION, HOW THAT

02:05:07.233 --> 02:05:09.233
FITS WITH THE PROJECT.

02:05:12.233 --> 02:05:14.233
>> I WAS STILL WRITING SOME NOTES HERE. WAS THE QUESTION ABOUT HOW

02:05:16.233 --> 02:05:19.133
-- >>
[ INDESCERNIBLE ]
>> RIGHT, I THINK WE SHOULD

02:05:24.233 --> 02:05:26.233
FIRST LOOK INTO EXISTING HOUSING POLICIES AT THE STATE LEVEL.

02:05:29.233 --> 02:05:31.233
AS YOU HAVE PROBABLY SEEN, FROM A REGULATORY PERSPECTIVE, THE RESTRICTIONS HAVE BEEN

02:05:35.233 --> 02:05:37.233
LISTENED A LOT.

02:05:38.233 --> 02:05:40.233
SO, THERE MAY BE EXISTING LEGISLATION THAT WE CAN RELY ON THAT LOOSENS

02:05:45.233 --> 02:05:47.233
THE RESTRICTIONS THAT WE HAVE AT A LOCAL LEVEL

02:05:50.233 --> 02:05:53.167
IN THE CL DISTRICT.
ABSENT THAT, I DON'T SEE ANY REASON WHY WE CAN'T EXPLORE

02:05:54.167 --> 02:05:56.167
HOW WE MIGHT BE ABLE TO CREATE SOME MORE FLEXIBILITY THROUGH THE CL

02:05:59.167 --> 02:06:01.167
ZONING DISTRICT, BUT ALSO DO WHAT

02:06:03.167 --> 02:06:06.167
SUPERVISOR GALLAGHER HAD MENTIONED, IN A WAY THAT DOESN'T HAVE RESIDENTIAL USES
CONFLICTING WITH AGRICULTURAL, THAT IS A GOOD POINT. [ INDESCERNIBLE ]

02:06:06.167 --> 02:06:08.167
>> WE ARE GOING TO BE RELATIVELY SOON, PROBABLY

02:06:15.167 --> 02:06:17.167
WITHIN THE NEXT SIX MONTHS, UNDERTAKEN A LOT OF CODE CHANGES UNDER

02:06:19.167 --> 02:06:22.167
ACTION ITEMS THAT WERE APPROVED BY THE BOARD
AND THE ADOPTION OF THE HOUSING ELEMENT BACK IN JANUARY. AND

02:06:26.167 --> 02:06:28.167
YOU KNOW, MOST OF THOSE ARE TO BRING OUR CODE

02:06:29.167 --> 02:06:31.167
UP TO COMPLIANCE WITH STATE LAW, SO AS PART OF THIS, WE WILL MAYBE NEED

02:06:33.167 --> 02:06:35.167
TO JUMP ON THAT A LITTLE EARLIER NOW TO LOOK AT WHAT

02:06:38.167 --> 02:06:40.167
EXISTING RULES ARE CONCERNING RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL ZONING.

02:06:41.167 --> 02:06:43.167
>> SUPERVISOR, ARE YOU DONE? OKAY, SUPERVISOR PEDROZA.

02:06:53.100 --> 02:06:55.100
>> OKAY, I AGREE A LOT WITH WHAT SUPERVISOR GREGORY SHARED. ON THE TRAFFIC, I DO WANT TO ENCOURAGE US

02:06:57.100 --> 02:06:59.100
OR ENCOURAGE APPLICANTS TO REACH OUT TO THE NAPA VALLEY

02:07:05.100 --> 02:07:07.100
TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY. I THINK WE HAVE TO BE CREATIVE, NOT JUST ASSUMING

02:07:08.100 --> 02:07:11.100
EVERYONE IS GOING TO DRIVE THEIR INDIVIDUAL CARS, AND START INCENTIVIZING
THE BEHAVIOR AND OUTCOME WE WANT TO SEE.

02:07:11.100 --> 02:07:13.100
THERE ARE A LOT OF TECHNOLOGIES, A LOT OF NEW

02:07:14.100 --> 02:07:16.100
PLATFORMS WHERE WE CAN ENCOURAGE THAT. MAYBE EVEN CONDITION. IT IS

02:07:17.100 --> 02:07:19.100
NOT EVERYONE DRIVING THEIR INDIVIDUAL CARS. SO, I

02:07:20.100 --> 02:07:22.100
THINK THAT IS PART OF IT.

02:07:24.100 --> 02:07:26.100
IT MIGHT MEAN REDUCING PARKING RATIOS, AND MIGHT BE CREATING MORE WAYS

02:07:27.100 --> 02:07:29.100
TO ENCOURAGE THAT OUTCOME. ON THE CL ZONING, WE DID THIS

02:07:32.100 --> 02:07:34.100
EXERCISE THREE YEARS AGO WHERE WE LAUGHED ALL THE CL

02:07:39.100 --> 02:07:41.100
ZONING IN NAPA COUNTY, SO I THINK WE HAVE JUST GOT TO BRING THAT BACK UP,

02:07:42.100 --> 02:07:45.100
I REMEMBER IT WASN'T THAT EXPENSIVE, BUT WE DID IT FOR ANOTHER PROJECT, SO THAT
INFORMATION IS OUT THERE, SO I THINK WE WOULD

02:07:47.100 --> 02:07:49.100
NEED TO LOOK AT IT AND I THINK SUPERVISOR GALLAGHER IS RIGHT,

02:07:50.100 --> 02:07:52.100
WHATEVER WE DO HERE NEEDS TO BE MINDFUL OF

02:07:53.330 --> 02:07:55.330
IS DEALING WITH THAT. WE WANT TO PROTECT AGRICULTURAL, EVERYBODY

02:07:59.330 --> 02:08:02.330
WANTS TO PROTECT SOMETHING.
BUT WE ALL TALK ABOUT THE PRESSURES AFFORDABLE HOUSING IS

02:08:05.330 --> 02:08:07.330
CREATING IN OUR COMMUNITIES.

02:08:10.330 --> 02:08:13.330
WE CAN'T HAVE IT ALL AND WE HAVE TO BE WILLING TO
MAKE FEASIBLE DECISIONS AND MAKE SURE WE UNDERSTAND THE IMPACTS AND MITIGATE

02:08:14.330 --> 02:08:16.330
IMPACTS, THAT IS PUBLIC POLICY. SO, I THINK WE HAVE AN

02:08:17.330 --> 02:08:19.330
APPLICANT HERE THAT IS WILLING TO BE AT THE TABLE WITH US, BUT THEY ARE

02:08:20.330 --> 02:08:22.330
WILLING TO DO MORE THAN THAT, TOO. THAT'S WHY I THINK

02:08:23.330 --> 02:08:25.330
WE HAVE AN INCREDIBLE OPPORTUNITY TO DO SOMETHING THAT IS DONE WITH

02:08:26.330 --> 02:08:28.330
THE COMMUNITY. [ INDESCERNIBLE ] SO, THANK YOU.

02:08:32.330 --> 02:08:34.330
>> MY QUESTIONS TO STAFF, OUR HOUSING FUND WAS ESTABLISHED IN 2010.

02:08:44.330 --> 02:08:46.330
OUR FEE IS WHERE LAST UPDATED WHEN?

02:08:50.330 --> 02:08:52.330
>> I AM GOING TO

02:08:55.967 --> 02:08:57.967
GO AHEAD AND INVITE MISS PALMER TO ANSWER THAT ONE FOR ME, PLEASE. I

02:08:58.967 --> 02:09:00.967
AM LOOKING IN OUR CODE HERE AND I'M LOOKING IN OUR ORDINANCE APPROVED 2010

02:09:01.967 --> 02:09:03.967
FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE FEELING --

02:09:06.967 --> 02:09:08.967
>> ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT LAST TIME WE

02:09:09.967 --> 02:09:11.967
DID THE NEXUS STUDY? I DON'T BELIEVE WE HAVE DONE A

02:09:12.967 --> 02:09:14.967
NEXUS STUDY IN THE LAST FIVE YEARS.
BRIAN AND I WERE LOOKING AT THAT JUST A COUPLE MONTHS AGO, I THINK

02:09:19.967 --> 02:09:22.933
IT HAS BEEN SIX OR SEVEN YEARS SINCE
WE HAVE DONE THE FULL NEXUS STUDY.

02:09:23.800 --> 02:09:25.800
>> THANK YOU, OKAY. OKAY, SO, I SEE A COUPLE OF --

02:09:28.967 --> 02:09:30.967
AM GOING TO SAY TIMING, WE HAVE A VERY INTERESTING

02:09:32.967 --> 02:09:35.967
SCENARIO HERE FROM A TIMING PERSPECTIVE.
YOU NEED SOME ANSWERS FOR US TO DO THE EIR, BUT

02:09:37.967 --> 02:09:39.967
SOME PEOPLE WANT THE EIR TO BE ABLE TO TELL YOU WHAT WE WANT TO

02:09:43.967 --> 02:09:45.967
DO, AND THEN HERE WE ARE WITH HAVING LOST

02:09:46.967 --> 02:09:48.967
30 YEARS OF OUR UNINCORPORATED HOUSING STOCK FOR FIRES , HAVING AN OLD HOUSING

02:09:52.900 --> 02:09:54.900
NEXUS STUDY , AND WORKING OFF A HOUSING IMPACT

02:09:58.900 --> 02:10:00.900
FEE PROGRAM THAT REALLY HASN'T CONTEMPLATED

02:10:04.900 --> 02:10:06.900
THIS, TO THE CREDIT OF OUR PUBLIC COMMENTARY, MR. SHANNON,

02:10:09.900 --> 02:10:11.900
WE KEEP ON TRYING TO MAKE DO WITH WHAT

02:10:13.900 --> 02:10:15.900
WE HAVE GOT. SO, I AM GOING TO START WITH --I AM GOING TO GO AHEAD AND START

02:10:19.900 --> 02:10:21.900
WITH THE HOUSING, THAT IS WHAT WE HAVE BEEN TALKING

02:10:22.900 --> 02:10:24.900
ABOUT. I APPLAUD THE FAMILY FOR WANTING TO INCORPORATE HOUSING HERE.

02:10:28.900 --> 02:10:30.900
I AM A LITTLE STUCK. I GET IT, THIS IS COMMERCIAL.

02:10:34.900 --> 02:10:36.900
BUT WHERE THE EXISTING HOUSING IS THAT IS NONCONFORMING

02:10:41.900 --> 02:10:43.900
ON AN AW PARCEL, CORRECT?

02:10:44.900 --> 02:10:46.900
EXTENDING COMMERCIAL IS NOT THE RIGHT MOVE HERE, AND

02:10:49.900 --> 02:10:51.900
TO LOOK AT INCREASING HOUSING IN A COMMERCIAL ZONING WHEN THE HOUSING IS

02:10:57.833 --> 02:10:59.833
ALREADY ON AN AW PARCEL DOESN'T GET US THERE. SO, I AM GOING TO --

02:11:04.833 --> 02:11:07.833
I HAVE HEARD EVERYONE'S SITE HERE, AND
I AM GOING TO SAY, I DON'T THINK THAT LOOKING AT ADDITIONAL HOUSING

02:11:11.833 --> 02:11:13.833
WITHIN THE PROJECT ITSELF IS NECESSARILY GOING TO BE

02:11:18.833 --> 02:11:20.833
THE BEST MOVE FOR US, BECAUSE IT IS GOING TO REQUIRE US TO LOOK AT

02:11:23.833 --> 02:11:25.833
THE AW PARCEL FOR EXTENSION OF ACL PARCEL,

02:11:29.833 --> 02:11:31.833
WHICH IS NOT , I THINK, WHERE ANYONE WANTS

02:11:34.833 --> 02:11:36.833
TO GO WITH THIS. BECAUSE WHAT I HEARD ON THIS SIDE WAS

02:11:39.833 --> 02:11:41.833
REALLY LOOKING AT THE CL DESIGNATION, THE COMMERCIAL LIMITED DESIGNATION

02:11:42.833 --> 02:11:44.833
ON ZONING, AND WHAT I HEARD ON THIS SIDE WAS, WE ARE ALL SURROUNDED BY AP

02:11:46.833 --> 02:11:48.833
AND AW, SO LET'S BE CAUTIOUS HERE.

02:11:53.767 --> 02:11:55.767
I AM GOING TO GO AHEAD AND SAY, I APPRECIATE THE THREE TIMES

02:11:58.767 --> 02:12:00.767
THE HOUSING IMPACT FEE VALUE , BUT WHEN I CAME TO THE BOARD,

02:12:11.767 --> 02:12:13.767
WHEN IT WAS COSTING US UNDER $500,000, I THINK WE

02:12:14.767 --> 02:12:17.767
HAD ONE QUEUE THAT WAS UP 432.
WE HAVE HAD SOME CUES THAT HAVE COST US UPWARDS OF

02:12:20.767 --> 02:12:22.767
$800,000 FOR A UNIT. I DO NOT --I DO NOT FEEL THAT THE C

02:12:26.767 --> 02:12:28.767
IS NECESSARILY GOING TO GET US WHERE WE NEED TO BE.

02:12:32.767 --> 02:12:34.767
I AM NOT SAYING THAT --HOW DO I SAY --

02:12:41.767 --> 02:12:43.767
THAT IS ON AUNTS.

02:12:44.767 --> 02:12:46.767
OUR FEE IS NOT REFLECTIVE OF OUR CURRENT MARKET CONDITIONS, IT HAS NO INFLATION IN

02:12:47.767 --> 02:12:49.767
THERE. IT HAS NO COVERT ADJUSTMENT, IT HAS NO

02:12:53.767 --> 02:12:55.767
THE WORLD STOPPED ADJUSTMENT, AND IT HAS NO WE HAVE EXPERIENCED TWO INCREDIBLY

02:13:02.767 --> 02:13:04.767
DEVASTATING FIRE SEASONS ADJUSTMENT IN THERE, THAT

02:13:05.767 --> 02:13:07.767
I WOULD IMAGINE IF WE WERE TO GO AND DO THE STUDY AGAIN, IT WOULD BE

02:13:08.767 --> 02:13:10.767
A LOT BIGGER. SO, I AM GOING TO GO AHEAD AND SAY, AND I HOPE --

02:13:14.767 --> 02:13:16.767
I SEE LIGHTS, THAT THIS SHOULD BE TURNED IN

02:13:20.767 --> 02:13:22.767
--NOT INTO A DOLLAR FIGURE, BUT INTO A COMMITMENT OF UNITS. A COMMITMENT OF UNITS

02:13:26.767 --> 02:13:28.767
THAT WORKS WITH THE COUNTY

02:13:32.767 --> 02:13:34.767
, FOR THE NEXT AVAILABLE SHOVEL READY, UNDERSTANDING

02:13:40.767 --> 02:13:42.767
THERE IS A TIMELINE PROCEDURE IN THIS, BUT UNITS ,

02:13:43.767 --> 02:13:45.767
IN ADDITION TO WHAT YOU ARE DOING ON-SITE FOR YOUR EMPLOYEES

02:13:47.767 --> 02:13:49.767
, ACTUAL UNITS IS GOING TO BE TAKING

02:13:55.700 --> 02:13:57.700
IT OUTSIDE OF THIS PROJECT AND WITHIN A MUNICIPAL AREA IS MORE CONSISTENT

02:14:02.700 --> 02:14:04.700
WITH CONDUCTIVITY AND RESOURCES AND TRANSPORTATION

02:14:08.700 --> 02:14:10.700
AND WHAT WE WANT TO BE ABLE TO OFFER , AS OPPOSED TO TRYING TO SQUEEZE SOMETHING INTO

02:14:17.700 --> 02:14:19.700
A RURAL AREA THAT IS NOT EVEN GOING TO HAVE A SIDEWALK TO GET SOMEONE

02:14:23.700 --> 02:14:25.700
TO A GROCERY STORE . SO, I WOULD JUST

02:14:28.700 --> 02:14:30.700
--I AM GOING TO PUT THAT OUT THERE AND HOPE THAT I SEE LIGHTS LIGHT UP AND

02:14:32.700 --> 02:14:34.700
YOU CAN TELL ME WHAT YOU THINK. NEXT, ON THE

02:14:35.700 --> 02:14:37.700
ZION TRAIL SHELTER EASEMENTS, AGAIN, I

02:14:40.700 --> 02:14:42.700
THINK THIS IS ON US. I VERY MUCH APPRECIATE THE OFFER AND THE ACKNOWLEDGMENT

02:14:47.700 --> 02:14:49.700
OF THE TIMELINE, FEE PROGRAM. AND AGAIN, OUR WORLD STOPPED.

02:14:56.633 --> 02:14:58.633
AND WE GOT OFF TRACK FROM THAT.

02:14:59.633 --> 02:15:01.633
BUT I THINK THAT THERE IS --

02:15:04.633 --> 02:15:06.633
THERE IS DEFINITELY A COMMUNITY RECOGNITION OR

02:15:11.633 --> 02:15:13.633
WHAT YOU HAVE DONE, BUT I DON'T THINK THAT THAT NECESSARILY IS

02:15:14.633 --> 02:15:16.633
A DOLLAR FIGURE THAT ENTERS THIS CONVERSATION. WHAT I DO SEE

02:15:20.633 --> 02:15:22.633
, AND THAT I WOULD LIKE THE FAMILY TO CONSIDER IN TERMS OF THIS

02:15:26.633 --> 02:15:28.633
, WE WENT THROUGH A VERY LARGE EXERCISE HERE

02:15:32.633 --> 02:15:34.633
IN TERMS OF WHAT IS THIS SEGMENT OF THE VINE

02:15:35.633 --> 02:15:37.633
TRAIL GOING TO ALLOW, BECAUSE IT IS IN FACT ON AGRICULTURAL LANDS,

02:15:38.633 --> 02:15:40.633
AND WE HAVE TO TALK ABOUT SCOOTERS, REMEMBER,

02:15:41.633 --> 02:15:43.633
SUPERVISOR PEDROZA, AND HOW WE DON'T WANT YOU ON

02:15:44.633 --> 02:15:46.633
THE SCOOTER ON THE VINE TRAIL, AND I THINK WE HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY

02:15:53.567 --> 02:15:55.567
AND YOUR OTHER PROJECTS, IF YOU CAN LOOK AT E-BIKE SUPPORT INTO THIS AREA

02:15:59.567 --> 02:16:01.567
, SAY E-BIKE CHARGING STATIONS , WORKING WITH THE BICYCLE COALITION, WE

02:16:05.567 --> 02:16:07.567
DON'T -- WE KNOW E-BIKES ARE ON THE VINE TRAIL, I GET PASSED

02:16:11.567 --> 02:16:13.567
BY THEM ALL THE TIME, I AM PERSONALLY POWERED. BUT THAT BEING THE TREND

02:16:18.567 --> 02:16:20.567
THAT IS GOING ON, I WOULD CERTAINLY

02:16:26.567 --> 02:16:29.567
ENCOURAGE THE FAMILY TO LOOK AT WORKING WITH THE NAPA BIKE
COALITION OF WHAT THAT MIGHT LOOK LIKE TO BE SUPPORTIVE, AS WE KNOW,

02:16:30.567 --> 02:16:32.567
THIS IS GOING TO BE A LONG STRETCH, 48 MILES, CALISTOGA.

02:16:33.567 --> 02:16:35.567
THE NEXT ONE --I GUESS I AM GOING TO ASK FOR CLARIFICATION

02:16:42.567 --> 02:16:44.567
AS TO WHY THIS IS HERE, AND IT IS FUNNY THAT SUPERVISOR

02:16:45.567 --> 02:16:47.567
GALLAGHER SAID I THINK THIS IS YOUR BENEFIT, NOT OUR BENEFIT,

02:16:48.567 --> 02:16:50.567
BUT THE WAY I READ THIS IS THAT THE RECOGNITION OF ALLOWING

02:16:53.500 --> 02:16:55.500
A HOTEL GUEST TO BE ABLE TO GO INTO THE AGRICULTURAL LANDS THAT WILL BE

02:17:00.500 --> 02:17:02.500
FARMED FOR USE AT THE HOTEL OR FARM TO TABLE IS BECAUSE

02:17:03.500 --> 02:17:05.500
THE HOTEL GUESTS ARE A COMMERCIAL USE THAT

02:17:08.500 --> 02:17:10.500
WOULD BE COMING INTO AN AGRICULTURAL ZONE PARCEL THAT IS

02:17:15.500 --> 02:17:17.500
NOT EVEN ACCESSORY TO

02:17:19.500 --> 02:17:22.500
THE AGRICULTURAL PARCEL, BUT IS ITS OWN SEPARATE COMMERCIAL USE TO THE
HOTEL, AM I GETTING THIS RIGHT? YES, PLEASE.

02:17:27.500 --> 02:17:29.500
IS THAT WHY YOU ARE ASKING FOR IT?

02:17:32.500 --> 02:17:34.500
>> HONESTLY, IT IS MOSTLY SO WE DON'T GET A LETTER SAYING YOUR HOTEL GUESTS ARE WALKING

02:17:37.500 --> 02:17:39.500
ACROSS THE PARCEL LINE, VISITING THIS PROPERTY.

02:17:43.500 --> 02:17:45.500
SO, TAKE ANOTHER EXAMPLE, JUST THINK ABOUT IT IN A DIFFERENT WAY,

02:17:46.500 --> 02:17:48.500
INSTEAD OF ME DRIVING UP THERE AND PARKING --THERE IS THE STRAWBERRY PLEASE

02:17:51.433 --> 02:17:53.433
ON THE TRAIL, I STOP IN THERE, I GET

02:17:54.433 --> 02:17:57.433
STRAWBERRIES WITH MY KIDS.
INSTEAD OF ME DOING THAT, I AM WALKING FROM MY HOTEL

02:18:00.433 --> 02:18:02.433
ROOM TO DO THAT, SAME THING.
SO, TO SUPERVISOR GALLAGHER, I THINK YOU KIND OF FRAMED

02:18:04.433 --> 02:18:06.433
IT REALLY WELL. IT IS NOT ACCESSORY TO THE WINERY, THAT'S NOT

02:18:07.433 --> 02:18:09.433
WHAT THIS IS ABOUT. IT IS GOING TO BE AN AGRICULTURAL USE.

02:18:12.433 --> 02:18:14.433
I ACTUALLY HONESTLY DIDN'T EXPECT TO TALK ABOUT IT THIS MUCH, BUT IT IS AN AGRICULTURAL USE,

02:18:18.433 --> 02:18:20.433
AND INSTEAD OF ME DRIVING TO IT, I CAN WALK TO IT

02:18:21.433 --> 02:18:23.433
FROM MY HOTEL. AND THAT IS IT. SO YOU KNOW, I TAKE THE POINT.

02:18:26.433 --> 02:18:28.433
THAT WOULD BE NICE FOR OUR GUESTS, FOR SURE.

02:18:29.433 --> 02:18:31.433
SO, IN THAT SENSE, IT IS A PUBLIC BENEFIT.

02:18:33.433 --> 02:18:35.433
IT IS ALSO AGRICULTURE.

02:18:36.433 --> 02:18:39.433
AND IT PROBABLY WOULDN'T JUST BE VINES, IT WOULD BE A DIFFERENT KIND
OF AGRICULTURE. AND WE LIKE TO SEE THAT

02:18:42.433 --> 02:18:44.433
IN NAPA COUNTY EVERY TIME THE CROP REPORT COMES OUT, IT IS MOSTLY

02:18:45.433 --> 02:18:47.433
GRAPES, BUT THERE ARE OTHER STUFF THAT I LIKE

02:18:48.433 --> 02:18:50.433
TO FIND A COOL STUFF THAT ARE SOME COOL STUFF THERE,

02:18:52.367 --> 02:18:54.367
AND I THINK IT BENEFITS US, IT BENEFITS THE COMMUNITY AS WELL. THAT IS

02:18:56.000 --> 02:18:58.367
KIND OF THE CLARIFICATION.
>> THANK YOU.

02:19:00.367 --> 02:19:02.367
THAT IS HELPFUL. TO THAT POINT NOW, I WILL

02:19:03.367 --> 02:19:06.367
TRANSITION OVER TO TRANSPORTATION, I AGREE WITH
SUPERVISOR PEDROZA, I THINK WE NEED TO MAKE

02:19:09.367 --> 02:19:11.367
SURE THAT THIS INCORPORATES NAPA VALLEY TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY,

02:19:15.367 --> 02:19:17.367
I THINK WE NEED TO BE VERY CAREFUL IN THIS INTERSECTION, AND

02:19:21.367 --> 02:19:23.367
LOOK AT DOING THINGS THAT ARE A BIT MORE INNOVATIVE AND

02:19:26.367 --> 02:19:28.367
ALERTING TO PEDESTRIAN MOVEMENT. I AM NERVOUS ABOUT THIS.

02:19:30.367 --> 02:19:33.367
I AM GOING TO JUST SAY THAT.
THE MOVEMENT BETWEEN NORTH AND SOUTH MAKES ME INCREDIBLY NERVOUS. ESPECIALLY

02:19:39.367 --> 02:19:41.367
UNDERSTANDING IT JUST THE LOADS ON THAT ROAD OF EXISTING USES.

02:19:45.367 --> 02:19:47.367
SO, I WOULD HOPE THAT WE LOOK AT THOSE MORE CREATIVE THINGS,

02:19:54.300 --> 02:19:56.300
THAT WE LOOK AT BETTER TYPES OF INGRESS AND EGRESS AND THE WIDENING

02:20:00.300 --> 02:20:02.300
AND SOUTH OF THAT AREA THAT ALLOWS FOR A CLEARER VIEW. AND I WOULD HOPE THAT WE ALSO

02:20:06.300 --> 02:20:08.300
COME FROM THE INTERIOR PART AND THE USE OF

02:20:11.300 --> 02:20:13.300
THE PROJECT, THAT YOU LOOK AT TIMING AS A CONSIDERATION.

02:20:15.300 --> 02:20:17.300
AND ALSO, LIGHTING IN THAT AREA, AS A CONSIDERATION, WITH RESPECT THAT

02:20:21.300 --> 02:20:23.300
YOU ARE IN MOSTLY SURROUNDED IN AN AGRICULTURAL ZONE, SO DON'T BE ALL SPOTLIGHTING

02:20:27.300 --> 02:20:30.300
AND HOLLYWOOD ON US, BUT REALLY BE COGNIZANT
OF THE FACT THAT THAT MOBILITY IS GOING TO NEED ADDITIONAL LIGHTING AND SAFETY

02:20:33.300 --> 02:20:35.300
CONCERNS.

02:20:38.300 --> 02:20:40.300
AND NEXT, WHAT I DON'T SEE ANYTHING OF , THAT I WOULD

02:20:42.300 --> 02:20:44.300
HOPE THAT THERE IS SOME CONSIDERATION OF, AND THAT IS JUST

02:20:48.300 --> 02:20:50.300
MORE GENERAL SUSTAINABILITY PRACTICES.

02:20:51.233 --> 02:20:53.233
YOU KNOW, YES, SOLAR IS GREAT, WATER REUSE IS GREAT,

02:20:57.233 --> 02:20:59.233
I WANT TO SEE THOSE.

02:21:00.233 --> 02:21:02.233
I WANT TO SEE THAT PROJECTS THAT HAVE

02:21:08.233 --> 02:21:10.233
--.DRAW THE ATTENTION IN TERMS OF THE

02:21:11.233 --> 02:21:13.233
IMPACTS THAT THEY HAVE ON OUR NATURAL RESOURCES ARE ACTUALLY MITIGATING THOSE

02:21:18.233 --> 02:21:20.233
ON-SITE TO THE EXTENT POSSIBLE, WHICH I KNOW IS CONSISTENT

02:21:23.233 --> 02:21:25.233
WITH THE FAMILY'S OVERALL PRACTICES, AND YOU DO THAT,

02:21:27.233 --> 02:21:29.233
BUT I DON'T SEE THAT PRESENT IN HERE.
AND I WOULD LIKE TO BE ABLE TO

02:21:33.233 --> 02:21:35.233
AT LEAST NO MORE, WHAT IS THE FAMILY COMMITTED TO, YOU KNOW,

02:21:39.233 --> 02:21:41.233
WHEN I THINK ABOUT THESE PROJECTS, YOU

02:21:43.233 --> 02:21:45.233
KNOW, THINGS THAT COME TO MIND, ZERO WATER FOOTPRINT TYPE OF AVAILABILITY.

02:21:49.233 --> 02:21:51.233
WHETHER THAT IS INVESTING IN RECYCLED WATER WITHIN

02:21:55.167 --> 02:21:57.167
THE PROJECT ITSELF OR OFFSETTING THOSE USES THAT YOU ARE GOING TO HAVE

02:22:02.167 --> 02:22:05.167
FROM THE CITY, JUST DRIVING UP THERE, THEY ARE ON A
CONSERVED WATER NOTICE RIGHT NOW BECAUSE OF PROBLEMS WITHIN THEIR SYSTEM, SO, LOOKING AT

02:22:09.167 --> 02:22:11.167
HOW YOU CAN BE AN ACTIVE PARTICIPANT TO HELP

02:22:17.167 --> 02:22:19.167
OFFSET WHAT THAT WATER USAGE -- NOTWITHSTANDING THE FACT THAT YOU HAVE THAT ENTITLEMENT,

02:22:20.167 --> 02:22:22.167
I RECOGNIZE THAT, BUT I DON'T THINK THAT PREVENTS YOU FROM WANTING TO DO

02:22:25.167 --> 02:22:27.167
MORE IN THAT AREA.

02:22:34.167 --> 02:22:36.167
>> MY DAD ACTUALLY

02:22:40.167 --> 02:22:42.167
WORKED WITH ANNE'S MOM AND HAD AN OFFICE THERE, AND I SPENT MANY

02:22:46.167 --> 02:22:48.167
DAYS AS A LITTLE GIRL WALKING AROUND THAT OAKTREE

02:22:49.167 --> 02:22:51.167
ON THE PROPERTY. AND SO, HAVING SEEN IT

02:23:09.167 --> 02:23:12.167
, IMPROVEMENTS ARE BETTER THAN DILAPIDATED, BUT I THINK THERE IS A BETTER
OPPORTUNITY TO BE A LEADER IN WHAT THIS LOOKS LIKE, SO I WOULD JUST ASK

02:23:15.167 --> 02:23:17.167
YOU TO REALLY DIG A LITTLE DEEPER WHEN IT COMES TO

02:23:18.167 --> 02:23:20.167
HOW YOU CAN PRODUCE SOME UNITS AS OPPOSED TO DOLLARS.

02:23:22.167 --> 02:23:24.167
ROOFS FOR FAMILIES IS FAR MORE MEANINGFUL

02:23:28.167 --> 02:23:30.167
TO ME AS A CONTRIBUTION TO THIS COMMUNITY.

02:23:34.167 --> 02:23:36.167
SUPERVISOR COTTRELL ?

02:23:37.167 --> 02:23:39.167
>> THANK YOU, CHAIR.

02:23:43.167 --> 02:23:45.167
AGAIN, I THINK WITH THE GOAL TO GIVE DIRECTION TO

02:23:46.167 --> 02:23:48.167
STAFF, AND ALSO BE ABLE TO HEAR FROM THE APPLICANT TEAM, I THINK, YOU KNOW,

02:23:49.167 --> 02:23:51.167
KEEPING IT HIGH-LEVEL, AND THIS CONVERSATION ABOUT CL,

02:23:58.100 --> 02:24:00.100
YOU KNOW, TAKING A VERY CAUTIOUS LOOK, I DON'T THINK IT HURTS TO LOOK AT THAT. I

02:24:01.100 --> 02:24:03.100
THINK SUPERVISOR GALLAGHER, YOU FRAMED IT VERY WELL,

02:24:07.100 --> 02:24:09.100
BUT WE HAVE TO BE AS CREATIVE AS WE CAN BE.

02:24:10.100 --> 02:24:12.100
SO, UNDERSTANDING THAT WE DON'T WANT TO

02:24:13.100 --> 02:24:15.100
BE URBANIZING ANYTHING IN THE AREA, SO, JUST IN GENERAL, MORE HOUSING, LESS

02:24:19.100 --> 02:24:21.100
WATER. AND I TIED THAT BACK TO OUR GSP, WHERE WE HAVE A

02:24:25.100 --> 02:24:27.100
BASIN WIDE GOAL OF A VOLUNTARY 10% REDUCTION OF GROUNDWATER USE,

02:24:33.100 --> 02:24:35.100
THIS PROJECT INVOLVES SOME GROUNDWATER, SO BEING ABLE TO SEE

02:24:36.100 --> 02:24:38.100
THAT, I THINK THAT TIES INTO SOME OF WHAT HE PROVIDES AROMAS WAS JUST TALKING
ABOUT, IN TERMS OF WATER USE. AND SUPERVISOR

02:24:42.100 --> 02:24:44.100
PEDROZA'S POINT, CREATIVITY , SEEN SOMEWHERE THAT WOULD BE GREAT. AND THEN

02:24:51.330 --> 02:24:53.330
I MENTIONED THE GROUNDWATER SUSTAINABILITY, WHICH WE ARE

02:24:55.330 --> 02:24:57.330
CONTINUING TO ROLL OUT, OUR CLIMATE ACTION PLAN, WE HAVE NOT EVEN STARTED

02:24:58.330 --> 02:25:00.330
YET, BUT THAT IS MEANT TO BE SOMETHING WE WOULD ASK ALL OF

02:25:02.330 --> 02:25:04.330
OUR RESIDENTS AND BUSINESSES TO BE A PART OF, AND SO, AS HAS BEEN POINTED OUT,

02:25:07.330 --> 02:25:09.330
JACKSON FAMILY IS KNOWN FOR HAVING STRONG SUSTAINABILITY PRINCIPLES,

02:25:13.330 --> 02:25:15.330
AND SO, BEING ABLE TO PULL SOME OF THOSE INTO ACTION ITEMS IN THIS

02:25:16.330 --> 02:25:18.330
DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT, I THINK WOULD BE VERY HOPE WILL AS WELL. AND

02:25:21.330 --> 02:25:23.330
FINALLY, I WOULD JUST POINT OUT FOR CONTEXT, UNDERSTANDING

02:25:25.330 --> 02:25:27.330
THAT IN THE CITY OF SAN MELINA, THE

02:25:30.330 --> 02:25:32.330
PARCEL --THERE WILL BE AN APPLICATION THERE FOR A HOTEL OF ABOUT 52 UNITS. AND

02:25:34.330 --> 02:25:36.330
FOR ANY APPLICANT TO BE ABLE TO FOLLOW THROUGH WITH SOMETHING,

02:25:40.330 --> 02:25:42.330
IT HAS TO MAKE SENSE FROM THEIR BUSINESS PERSPECTIVE, BUT

02:25:46.330 --> 02:25:48.330
ONE OF THE THINGS I AM CONCERNED ABOUT WITH THIS PROJECT, AS WE ARE TALKING ABOUT HOUSING AND THINGS

02:25:49.330 --> 02:25:51.330
LIKE THAT, IS AGAIN, SCALE AND INTENSITY OF USE.

02:25:52.167 --> 02:25:54.167
IS 79 THE RIGHT NUMBER, IS THERE FLEXIBILITY THERE?

02:25:55.433 --> 02:25:57.433
THAT IS SOMETHING I WOULD LIKE TO

02:25:57.533 --> 02:25:59.533
ASK STAFF TO ENGAGE IN A DISCUSSION ABOUT AS WELL.

02:26:00.500 --> 02:26:02.500
AND AGAIN, IT IS ON THE COMPARISON CHART,

02:26:06.967 --> 02:26:08.967
BUT I ALWAYS THINK OF THIS AS A GREAT EXAMPLE WHERE THEY WERE ABLE

02:26:09.967 --> 02:26:11.967
TO BUILD SOME UNITS RIGHT ON THE SITE, THAT MAKES IT

02:26:15.967 --> 02:26:17.967
KIND OF ALMOST A PLANNED UNIT, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT OPERATION.

02:26:18.967 --> 02:26:20.967
SO, THOSE ARE MY THOUGHTS AT THIS POINT.

02:26:24.967 --> 02:26:26.967
>> SUPERVISOR GREGORY?

02:26:29.967 --> 02:26:31.967
>> THANKS, SO I WILL WRAP UP MY THOUGHTS AND JUST

02:26:32.967 --> 02:26:34.967
START WITH SAYING THAT I SUPPORT THE TERMS THE

02:26:36.967 --> 02:26:38.967
D.A. PRESENTED TODAY WITH THE EXCEPTION OF DOING MORE ON-SITE

02:26:39.967 --> 02:26:41.967
HOUSING, AND IS HOPING THEY WILL FIGURE OUT HOW

02:26:42.967 --> 02:26:44.967
TO DO IT. I THINK THERE ARE VERY FEW PROJECTS WE HAVE SEEN IN OUR TIME

02:26:48.967 --> 02:26:50.967
THAT WE COULD SAY, YEAH, HOUSING ON THAT PROJECT SEEMS RIGHT, MAKES SENSE, MOST PROJECTS

02:26:55.900 --> 02:26:57.900
ARE OUT IN THE HILLS OR OUT IN THE MIDDLE OF NOWHERE, THIS IS CLOSE

02:26:58.900 --> 02:27:00.900
ENOUGH TO THE CITY, CONNECTED BY

02:27:02.900 --> 02:27:04.900
A TRAIL, THIS ONE MAKES SENSE. AND I WOULD LOVE TO SEE WHAT Y'ALL

02:27:06.900 --> 02:27:09.900
CAN DO WITH IT. I WOULD HATE TO GIVE YOU A NUMBER BECAUSE
YOU ALL NEED TO FIGURE OUT WHAT FITS.

02:27:12.900 --> 02:27:15.900
IT IS NOT A NO-BRAINER FEEDING AND HOUSING WITH
HOTELS, THEY ARE TWO DIFFERENT THINGS, SO RESPECT THAT AND NOT PIN YOU DOWN, BUT I WOULD

02:27:19.900 --> 02:27:21.900
LOVE TO SEE WHAT YOU GUYS CAN DO IF WE OFFER YOU THAT FLEXIBILITY. SO, THANK YOU.

02:27:28.900 --> 02:27:30.900
>> ANYBODY ELSE?

02:27:36.900 --> 02:27:38.900
>> YEAH, MAYBE I SHOULD ASK STAFF, HOW ARE YOU FEELING?
>> TWO PAGES OF

02:27:39.167 --> 02:27:40.867
NOTES.
>> I APPRECIATE THIS DISCUSSION AND I KNOW IT MAY

02:27:48.900 --> 02:27:50.900
NOT FEEL LIKE IT, BUT THIS IS VERY US, BUT PARTICULARLY ROB AND HIS TEAM

02:27:57.833 --> 02:28:00.833
TO GET THIS FEEDBACK. WE ARE IN THE STAGES OF DEVELOPING THE
DETAILS AROUND THESE TERMS, SO THE INTENT TODAY WASN'T TO WALK AWAY WITH

02:28:01.833 --> 02:28:03.833
A CLEAR SIGN OF D.A. TERMS AND ALL OF THAT,

02:28:04.833 --> 02:28:06.833
SO THIS IS VERY HELPFUL AND INFORMING OUR NEXT STEPS.

02:28:08.833 --> 02:28:10.833
I KNOW YOU HAVE DECISION-MAKING OPTIONS IN YOUR STAFF REPORT. I

02:28:13.833 --> 02:28:15.833
AM GETTING THE SENSE THAT YOU ARE CHOOSING THE ONE FOR US

02:28:16.833 --> 02:28:18.833
TO COME BACK AT A LATER DATE, TO SHARE WITH YOU SOME

02:28:19.833 --> 02:28:21.833
OF OUR IDEAS IN RESPONSE TO YOUR COMMENTS, SO

02:28:24.833 --> 02:28:26.833
WE ARE GOING TO DO THAT. WE ARE GOING TO WORK WITH THE

02:28:27.833 --> 02:28:29.833
APPLICANT ALONG THOSE LINES. WE WILL BE COMING BACK PROBABLY SOMETIME EARLY NEXT YEAR.

02:28:34.833 --> 02:28:36.833
>> SO, PROCEDURAL RIGHT NOW, I WILL ASK IF

02:28:37.833 --> 02:28:39.833
THE BOARD IS GOING TO COME

02:28:43.833 --> 02:28:45.833
--IF THE BOARD IS ASKING FOR US TO COME BACK, DO WE CONTINUE THIS PUBLIC HEARING

02:28:52.300 --> 02:28:55.330
IS NEW FOR ME.
>> I RECOMMEND YOU END

02:28:55.367 --> 02:28:57.600
THIS PUBLIC HEARING.
>> SO, WE WILL GO AHEAD, WE WILL CLOSE

02:29:01.767 --> 02:29:03.767
THE PUBLIC HEARING AND WE WILL -- AND BASED UPON

02:29:07.767 --> 02:29:09.767
WHAT STAFF BELIEVES THAT THEY HEARD FROM US, I AM GLAD YOU

02:29:10.767 --> 02:29:12.767
UNDERSTAND WHAT WE SAID. I WILL ASK FOR A MOTION

02:29:16.767 --> 02:29:18.767
DIRECTING STAFF TO CONTINUE TO WORK WITH THE APPLICANT AND RETURN TO THE BOARD

02:29:22.767 --> 02:29:24.767
AT A LATER DATE WITH AN UPDATE.

02:29:26.767 --> 02:29:28.767
WE HAVE A MOTION BY SUPERVISOR COTTRELL, SECOND BY SUPERVISOR GREGORY.

02:29:32.767 --> 02:29:34.767
MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY, THANK YOU SO MUCH TO THE APPLICANTS.

02:29:37.767 --> 02:29:39.767
THANK YOU, STAFF.

02:29:46.767 --> 02:29:49.767
>> I AM GOING TO GO AHEAD AND GIVE OUR PBS
STAFF A BREAK FOR A SECOND AND INVITE HOMELESS SERVICES, MS. JENNIFER PALMER,

02:29:52.700 --> 02:29:54.700
TO PROVIDE US A PRESENTATION . IT IS A REPEAT FOR SUPERVISOR PEDROZA AND MYSELF,

02:30:01.700 --> 02:30:03.700
THE NAPA HOUSING COMMITTEE, BUT THIS IS

02:30:07.700 --> 02:30:09.700
REALLY AN EXCITING PILOT PROJECT, MONEY COMING TO THE COUNTY OF NAPA.

02:30:11.670 --> 02:30:13.567
I WILL NOW RECOMMEND MS. PALMER.
>> GOOD MORNING, THANK YOU, CHAIR RAMOS,

02:30:16.700 --> 02:30:18.700
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS, I AM HAPPY TO BE HERE

02:30:22.700 --> 02:30:24.700
PROVIDING WHAT I THINK WILL BE A SHORT AND EASY PRESENTATION, SPECIFICALLY

02:30:28.700 --> 02:30:30.700
IN COMPARISON TO THE LAST ITEM, SO I HOPE THIS IS JUST RELAXING AND ENJOYABLE FOR EVERYBODY.

02:30:34.700 --> 02:30:36.700
I AM HERE TO TALK ABOUT THE $5 MILLION COMPETITIVE AWARD,

02:30:39.700 --> 02:30:41.700
THE COUNTY RECENTLY RECEIVED FROM THE BAY AREA HOUSING FINANCE AUTHORITY.

02:30:43.700 --> 02:30:45.700
THE AWARD IS A PILOT PROGRAM THAT WILL TAKE PLACE OVER FOUR YEARS,

02:30:48.700 --> 02:30:50.700
AND IT IS DESIGNED TO PREVENT HOMELESSNESS FOR EXTREMELY LOW INCOME SENIORS WHO ARE EXPERIENCING

02:30:55.633 --> 02:30:58.167
SEVERE HOUSING BURDEN.
TODAY'S PRESENTATION IS GOING TO GIVE YOU A LITTLE BIT OF AN OVERVIEW OF THE NUTS

02:31:00.167 --> 02:31:02.167
AND BOLTS OF BOTH THE DESIGN OF THE PROGRAM AND

02:31:03.167 --> 02:31:05.167
THE PILOT AS A WHOLE, AS WELL AS THE TIMING, THEN HOPEFULLY

02:31:06.167 --> 02:31:08.167
JUST ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU HAVE.

02:31:12.167 --> 02:31:15.167
BUT BEFORE I DO THAT, I THINK THERE IS A REASON
TO DO SOME SPECIAL LOCAL RECOGNITION OF KIND OF HOW WE GOT TO THE POINT

02:31:18.167 --> 02:31:20.167
OF RECEIVING THIS COMPETITIVE AWARD, IT WAS OPEN TO ALL NINE VERY COUNTY'S. AND

02:31:24.167 --> 02:31:26.167
NAPA IS THE SMALLEST OF THE NINE COUNTIES, AND THIS IS A REALLY HUGE AWARD.

02:31:31.167 --> 02:31:33.167
IF YOU CAN BEAR WITH ME FOR JUST A SECOND, FOR ANYBODY WHO IS LISTENING,

02:31:35.167 --> 02:31:37.167
THE BAY AREA HOUSING FINANCE AUTHORITY IS A REGIONAL AUTHORITY

02:31:38.167 --> 02:31:40.167
THAT WAS ESTABLISHED TO FOCUS ON HOUSING CHALLENGING THAT GOVERNING BOARD IS MADE UP OF THE MTC COMMISSIONERS.

02:31:51.100 --> 02:31:53.100
THE METROPOLITAN TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION COMMISSIONERS, AND THE ASSOCIATION

02:31:54.100 --> 02:31:56.100
OF BAY AREA GOVERNMENTS EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE. SO, THAT BOARD IS WHO DESIGNED THE RFP

02:32:01.100 --> 02:32:03.100
AND AUTHORIZED THE $5 MILLION PILOT TO BEGIN WITH.

02:32:07.100 --> 02:32:09.100
THAT TIMELINE, AND I WILL SAY A

02:32:11.100 --> 02:32:13.100
LITTLE BIT MORE ABOUT WHY THE TIMELINE MATTERS IN JUST A SECOND, BUT THE

02:32:16.100 --> 02:32:18.100
BOARD PASSED A RESOLUTION ESTABLISHING THIS PILOT PROGRAM ON MAY 24th. THE RFP

02:32:22.100 --> 02:32:24.100
WAS RELEASED ON AUGUST 15th WITH APPLICATIONS DUE ABOUT A MONTH LATER.

02:32:29.100 --> 02:32:31.100
I WANT TO HIGHLIGHT THIS BECAUSE THAT IS AN EXCEPTIONALLY SHORT APPLICATION WINDOW

02:32:34.100 --> 02:32:36.100
FOR WHAT WAS AN UNBELIEVABLY COMPLEX GRANT APPLICATION.

02:32:37.100 --> 02:32:40.100
IN ALL MY YEARS OF WORKING FOR THE COUNTY,
AND LEES SUMMIT 30 GRANT APPLICATIONS A YEAR, JUST FOR

02:32:44.100 --> 02:32:46.100
THE REGULAR FUNDING THAT COMES THROUGH HOUSING AND HOMELESS SERVICES, THIS

02:32:48.100 --> 02:32:50.100
WAS THE MOST COMPLICATED. SO, TO PULL THAT

02:32:51.100 --> 02:32:53.100
APPLICATION TOGETHER IN 30 DAYS WOULD HAVE BEEN IMPOSSIBLE.

02:32:55.100 --> 02:32:57.100
BUT WE HAD MORE THAN 30 DAYS, BECAUSE SUPERVISOR PEDROZA, I WANT TO THANK

02:32:58.100 --> 02:33:00.100
HIM FOR CHAMPIONING THIS SO EARLY,

02:33:03.100 --> 02:33:05.100
I THINK THE RFP --SORRY, THE RESOLUTION WAS PASSED BY THE BOARD ON THE 24th,

02:33:10.100 --> 02:33:12.100
THE VERY NEXT BOARD MEETING, SUPERVISOR PEDROZA
WAS ACKNOWLEDGING THAT THIS HAD HAPPENED, AND WITH WHOLEHEARTED SUPPORT, SAYING

02:33:16.100 --> 02:33:18.100
HE WANTED TO SEE THE NAPA COUNTY GO AFTER THIS. SO,

02:33:19.100 --> 02:33:21.100
THAT REALLY GAVE OUR TEAM EARLY PERMISSION TO

02:33:22.100 --> 02:33:24.100
BEGIN TO PULL TOGETHER PARTNERS AND KNOW THAT

02:33:26.100 --> 02:33:28.100
THE ENABLING ENVIRONMENT EXISTED FOR THAT. THE SECOND THING

02:33:30.100 --> 02:33:32.100
THAT I WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE IS JUST THAT WE HAVE TWO SUPERVISORS,

02:33:36.100 --> 02:33:38.100
BOTH SUPERVISOR PEDROZA ON NTC, AND SUPERVISOR RAMOS

02:33:40.100 --> 02:33:42.100
ON THE BOARD, WHO WERE A PART OF THE VISIONARY LEADERSHIP

02:33:43.100 --> 02:33:45.100
THAT CREATED THIS PILOT, SO, WHETHER OR NOT

02:33:51.330 --> 02:33:53.330
IT WAS AWARDED TO NAPA, FOR THE BAY AREA TO BE PUTTING OUT A

02:33:55.330 --> 02:33:57.330
$5 MILLION PILOT PROGRAM IS A HUGE STEP FORWARD. THIS IS A FIRST OF ITS

02:33:58.330 --> 02:34:00.330
KIND IN THE BAY AREA, I BELIEVE IT IS A

02:34:01.330 --> 02:34:03.330
FIRST OF ITS KIND IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA. SO, THAT KIND OF SUPPORT

02:34:06.330 --> 02:34:08.330
FROM OUR SUPERVISORS LOCALLY FOR A PROJECT LIKE THIS, THEN TO

02:34:09.330 --> 02:34:11.330
BE ABLE TO BRING IT BACK TO NAPA IS JUST HUGELY SATISFYING.

02:34:12.330 --> 02:34:14.330
THE LAST THING I WANT TO SAY IS FOR ALL OF THE SUPERVISORS,

02:34:16.330 --> 02:34:18.330
WHAT A PLEASURE IT IS FOR ME PERSONALLY, BUT ALSO OUR WHOLE TEAM,

02:34:22.330 --> 02:34:24.330
TO BE ABLE TO SIT BEFORE YOU AND BRING BACK AN

02:34:25.330 --> 02:34:27.330
AWARD LIKE THIS, BECAUSE WE HAVE LONG FELT LIKE THE SUPPORT THAT WE

02:34:28.330 --> 02:34:30.330
RECEIVE TO BE INNOVATIVE AND GO OUT AND PURSUE THESE UNIQUE THINGS HAS TOTALLY EXISTED

02:34:31.330 --> 02:34:33.330
FOR US, SO WHETHER THAT IS THE WHOLE PERSON

02:34:34.330 --> 02:34:36.330
CARE PILOT, WHETHER IT IS CALLAHAN, WHETHER IT IS PROJECT ,

02:34:40.330 --> 02:34:43.330
NOW THIS PILOT AND EVEN OUR AFFORDABLE ACCESSORY DWELLING
UNIT FORGIVABLE LOAN HER FAMILY, WE HAVE BEEN GIVEN PERMISSION TO BE INNOVATIVE

02:34:46.967 --> 02:34:48.967
AND LEAN INTO THINGS THAT HAVEN'T BEEN DONE BEFORE, AND I

02:34:51.967 --> 02:34:53.967
THINK WE ARE RECOGNIZED , CERTAINLY ACROSS OUR BAY AREA PARTNERS,

02:34:54.967 --> 02:34:56.967
BUT EVEN ACROSS THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA,

02:34:59.967 --> 02:35:01.967
OF BEING TRULY INNOVATIVE. SO, THIS AWARD IS EXTREMELY SATISFYING,

02:35:03.967 --> 02:35:05.967
BECAUSE IT FEELS LIKE A REAL PARTNERSHIP, NOT

02:35:06.967 --> 02:35:08.967
JUST WITH THE PARTNERS I'M GOING TO TALK ABOUT PUT TOGETHER THIS APPLICATION,

02:35:09.967 --> 02:35:11.967
BUT ALSO LITERALLY WITH OUR POLICYMAKERS HERE

02:35:12.967 --> 02:35:14.967
LOCALLY, SO THANK YOU. OKAY, SO NOW, IF WE COULD GO TO THE NEXT

02:35:20.967 --> 02:35:22.967
SLIDE, WHAT I WANT TO DO IS JUST TALK FOR A MINUTE ABOUT HOW THE

02:35:23.967 --> 02:35:25.967
BOARD DESIGNED THIS PILOT, HOW WE HAVE RESPONDED TO THAT DESIGN

02:35:27.967 --> 02:35:29.967
WITH OUR PROPOSAL AND WHAT THE TIMING IS GOING TO LOOK LIKE. SO, TO START

02:35:33.967 --> 02:35:35.967
WITH, THE NEED FOR PREVENTION. IN THE BAY AREA, THE REGIONAL

02:35:40.967 --> 02:35:42.967
POINT AND TIME COUNT ACROSS THE NINE BAY AREA COUNTIES IS JUST SHY

02:35:45.900 --> 02:35:47.900
OF 49 INDIVIDUALS EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS ON A
SINGLE NIGHT IN JANUARY OF LAST YEAR.

02:35:48.900 --> 02:35:50.900
OF THAT, NAPA HAD ABOUT 500 OF THAT COUNTS.

02:35:57.900 --> 02:36:00.900
SO, COMPARED TO THAT HUGE SCALE, OUR NUMBERS ARE
PRETTY SMALL. ON A PER CAPITA, WE ARE NOT TERRIBLY DISSIMILAR FOR MOST OF

02:36:02.900 --> 02:36:04.900
OUR COUNTIES, WE JUST HAVE A MUCH SMALLER POPULATION SIZE.

02:36:05.900 --> 02:36:07.900
THAT AT-RISK NUMBER, WHICH IS NOT COUNTED IN THE

02:36:08.900 --> 02:36:10.900
POINT AND TIME COUNT IS ESTIMATED TO BE 10 TO 15

02:36:12.900 --> 02:36:14.900
TIMES WHATEVER THE COMMUNITIES POINT TIME COUNT IS, SO THOSE ARE

02:36:15.900 --> 02:36:17.900
PEOPLE HANGING ON BY THE SKIN OF THEIR FINGERNAILS

02:36:21.900 --> 02:36:24.900
TO STAY IN HOUSING, THAT HAS BECOME INCREASINGLY DIFFICULT AS INFLATION IS MAKING THE
COST OF FOOD, UTILITIES, EVERYTHING ELSE GO UP. AMONG

02:36:25.900 --> 02:36:27.900
OLDER ADULTS, THE MOST COMMON TRIGGERING EVENTS FOR AN EPISODE OF HOMELESSNESS IS

02:36:30.900 --> 02:36:32.900
A FINANCIAL CRISIS, MEANING THEIR RETIREMENT

02:36:33.900 --> 02:36:35.900
JUST SIMPLY HAS NOT KEPT PACE AND THEY HAVE NO

02:36:36.900 --> 02:36:38.900
OTHER INCOME STREAMS, OR ONE-TIME OR REOCCURRING MEDICAL EVENTS, MEDICAL BILLS

02:36:40.900 --> 02:36:42.900
HAVE BECOME INCREASINGLY EXPENSIVE.

02:36:47.833 --> 02:36:49.833
AND THEN SENIORS ARE THE FASTEST GROWING POPULATION OF INDIVIDUALS EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS,

02:36:52.833 --> 02:36:54.833
MORE THAN 100% INCREASE SEEN ACROSS ALL NINE COUNTIES. I DO WANT

02:36:56.833 --> 02:36:58.833
TO SAY ONE WORD ABOUT WHAT IS A TRIGGERING EVENT FOR US AS A

02:37:02.833 --> 02:37:04.833
ROOT CAUSE OF HOMELESSNESS. I WANT TO SAY THIS BECAUSE THERE ARE

02:37:05.833 --> 02:37:07.833
A LOT OF MISUNDERSTANDINGS ABOUT WHAT CAUSES HOMELESSNESS VERSUS WHAT ARE THE

02:37:10.833 --> 02:37:12.833
TRIGGERING EVENTS THAT CAUSE SOMEONE TO FALL INTO HOMELESSNESS?

02:37:13.833 --> 02:37:15.833
THE EASIEST EXAMPLE THAT I CAN GET TO THIS IS MUSICAL CHAIRS. SO,

02:37:17.833 --> 02:37:19.833
WE HAVE THREE AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNITS FOR EVERY 10 INDIVIDUALS WHO NEED

02:37:25.833 --> 02:37:27.833
AFFORDABLE HOUSING, SO IF YOU CAN IMAGINE, WE ARE DOING

02:37:30.833 --> 02:37:32.833
MUSICAL CHAIRS AND THERE ARE 10 OF US WALKING AROUND AND THERE
ARE THREE CHAIRS. THE MUSIC STOPS, THE THREE

02:37:38.833 --> 02:37:41.833
PEOPLE WHO GET TO THOSE CHAIRS ARE GOING TO BE THE MOST ABLE-BODIED, FIT, AND
YOUNG INDIVIDUALS, BECAUSE THEY CAN HUSTLE, THEY CAN GET THERE, THEY ARE

02:37:45.767 --> 02:37:48.767
JUST PHYSICALLY LESS CHALLENGED. THE OTHER SEVEN ARE GOING TO
BE ANYBODY WITH A DISABILITY AND THE ELDERLY, JUST SIMPLY BECAUSE

02:37:52.767 --> 02:37:54.767
THEY CAN'T MOVE AS FAST.

02:37:55.767 --> 02:37:58.767
SO, THE ROOT CAUSE OF HOMELESSNESS IS THE LACK OF HOUSING
UNITS. THE TRIGGERING EVENTS THAT CAUSE

02:38:00.767 --> 02:38:02.767
PEOPLE TO FALL INTO HOMELESSNESS ARE THINGS LIKE DISABILITIES

02:38:07.767 --> 02:38:09.767
OR SIMPLY AGING AND LOSING PACE WITH THE FINANCIAL MARKET,

02:38:10.767 --> 02:38:12.767
SO THE SENIORS WHO ARE FALLING IN, THERE TRIGGERING EVENT, VERY DIFFERENT

02:38:16.767 --> 02:38:18.767
FROM WHAT WOULD BE THE ROOT CAUSE. SO, WITH THAT, A PILOT FOCUSED ON PREVENTION

02:38:22.767 --> 02:38:24.767
IS LOOKING AT WHAT IS THE RETURN ON INVESTMENT

02:38:27.767 --> 02:38:29.767
TO KEEP VULNERABLE INDIVIDUALS HOUSED WHERE

02:38:30.767 --> 02:38:32.767
THEY ARE, RATHER THAN HAVE THEM FALL INTO HOMELESSNESS AND ALL

02:38:33.767 --> 02:38:35.767
THE WORK IT TAKES TO GET FOLKS BACK INTO STABLE HOUSING.

02:38:37.767 --> 02:38:39.767
A LOT OF WHAT WE DO IN HOMELESS SERVICES IS GETTING FOLKS READY TO

02:38:40.767 --> 02:38:43.767
GET BACK INTO HOUSING, KEEPING THEM TEMPORARILY HOUSED IN
THE EMERGENCY SHELTER, THEN FINDING UNITS.

02:38:45.700 --> 02:38:47.700
THAT IS A VERY EXPENSIVE PROPOSITION, WE ARE

02:38:48.700 --> 02:38:50.700
REALLY GOOD AT IT, AND OUR NUMBERS GET BETTER EACH YEAR, BUT IT

02:38:52.700 --> 02:38:54.700
IS NOT THE BEST USE OF MONEY.
THE LEAST EXPENSIVE INVESTMENT WE CAN MAKE IS JUST HELPING PEOPLE HANG

02:38:57.700 --> 02:39:00.700
ON TO WHERE THEY ARE. THIS IS A CHANCE FOR US TO DEMONSTRATE THAT WITH
FUNDING THAT IS AVAILABLE AT A REGIONAL LEVEL, IT IS NOT AN ASK OF THE GENERAL

02:39:05.700 --> 02:39:07.700
FUND TO DO THAT, SO ABSOLUTELY WORTHWHILE IN GOING AFTER THESE FUNDS.

02:39:11.700 --> 02:39:13.700
THE PROGRAM GOALS ARE OBVIOUSLY PREVENTION OF HOMELESSNESS FOR EXTREMELY LOW INCOME SENIORS. THE

02:39:14.700 --> 02:39:16.700
OTHER THING THE BOARD REALLY WANTS TO DO IN THE DESIGN PROPOSAL, THERE

02:39:19.700 --> 02:39:21.700
IS A LOT OF LEARNING, SO WE WILL HAVE TWO ADVISORY COMMISSIONS MADE

02:39:28.700 --> 02:39:31.700
UP OF INDIVIDUALS WITH LIVED EXPERIENCE AND SOCIAL SERVICE PROVIDERS
WHO ARE REGULARLY PROVIDING INPUT OVER THE COURSE OF THE

02:39:33.700 --> 02:39:35.700
FOUR YEARS, NOT JUST TO US, BUT ALSO TO THE BOARD STAFF,

02:39:36.700 --> 02:39:39.700
WITH THE END GOAL BEING OUR PROGRAM IS DESIGNING A BLUEPRINT
FOR ALL OTHER BAY AREA COUNTIES, SO WE WILL HAVE MANUALS, WE WILL

02:39:41.700 --> 02:39:43.700
HAVE FORMS, WE ARE GOING TO BUILD AN

02:39:50.633 --> 02:39:52.633
ONLINE APPLICATION PORTAL, WE ARE GOING TO DO ALL OF THOSE THINGS AND DOCUMENT ALL

02:39:54.633 --> 02:39:57.633
OF THOSE THINGS, SO OTHER COMMUNITIES DON'T HAVE TO REINVENT THE WHEEL. WE ARE
GOING TO INVENT THE WHEEL AND THEN WE ARE GOING TO SHARE IT WITH EVERYBODY,

02:40:00.633 --> 02:40:02.633
AND THAT IS BAKED INTO PART OF THIS PROPOSAL. THE PROGRAM

02:40:03.633 --> 02:40:06.633
ELEMENTS ARE REALLY EQUITY AND TRYING TO REACH THE FOLKS WHO AREN'T REACHED
RIGHT NOW. ALL THE DATA SHOWS THAT IF YOU ARE READILY ABLE TO CONNECT

02:40:13.633 --> 02:40:15.633
TO THIS RESOURCE, YOU ARE PROBABLY THE LEAST MEETING OF IT.

02:40:22.633 --> 02:40:24.633
WE HAVE A LIMITED ENGLISH PROFICIENCY AND EXTREMELY LOW
INCOME POPULATION THROUGHOUT OUR VERY RURAL COUNTY, AND THIS PROGRAM WILL

02:40:25.633 --> 02:40:27.633
BE DESIGNED TO FIND THOSE FOLKS, SO THAT IS GOING TO BE

02:40:28.633 --> 02:40:30.633
A HUGE PART OF THE EARLY EFFORT. THE INTERVENTION IS

02:40:31.633 --> 02:40:33.633
48 MONTHS OF RENTAL ASSISTANCE, SOMEWHERE BETWEEN 500 AND $800 A MONTH

02:40:34.633 --> 02:40:36.633
FOR THE INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE ENROLLED.

02:40:46.567 --> 02:40:48.567
AND OVER THE COURSE OF THE FOUR YEARS, WE NEED TO FIGURE OUT HOW WE REMOVE AS MANY

02:40:49.567 --> 02:40:52.567
OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE BARRIERS THAT WE POSSIBLY CAN
TO MAKE THIS AS EFFICIENT AS POSSIBLE, NOT ONLY FOR EVERYBODY WHO GETS

02:40:54.567 --> 02:40:56.567
ENROLLED, THAT HUMANS AT THE CENTER OF THE PROJECT, BUT A LOT OF TIMES, THESE PROGRAMS

02:40:58.567 --> 02:41:00.567
HAVE HUGE ADMINISTRATIVE BURDENS ON WHAT WOULD OTHERWISE BE SMALL NONPROFITS, SO

02:41:04.567 --> 02:41:06.567
OUR GOAL IS TO FIGURE OUT HOW WE MAKE IT

02:41:11.567 --> 02:41:13.567
EASIER AND EASIER OVER THE COURSE OF THE FOUR YEARS.

02:41:19.567 --> 02:41:21.567
SO, IF WE GOT TO THE NEXT SLIDE, THAT WAS HOW THE BOARD ENVISIONED THE SPRINT

02:41:24.567 --> 02:41:26.567
WHAT I HAVE UP HERE IS THE GRAPHIC THAT WE HAVE SUBMITTED AS PART

02:41:27.567 --> 02:41:29.567
OF OUR APPLICATION, HOW WE ENVISION THIS WORKING.
WHEN I SAY THAT AS OF EARLY JUNE,

02:41:34.567 --> 02:41:36.567
WHEN WE FIRST HEARD ABOUT THE RFP THAT WAS DUE OUT IN AUGUST,

02:41:37.567 --> 02:41:39.567
WE BEGAN TO CONVENE WITH ALL OF THE COMMUNITY PARTNERS

02:41:40.567 --> 02:41:42.567
WHO HAVE BEEN A PART OF EMERGENCY RENTAL ASSISTANCE,

02:41:46.500 --> 02:41:48.500
A LEVEL OF EXPERTISE IN GOING BACK TO THE 2017 FIRES, WHEN WE

02:41:51.500 --> 02:41:53.500
FIRST HAD TO REALLY QUICKLY ROLL OUT RENTAL ASSISTANCE AND EMERGENCY FINANCIAL AID. UP VALLEY

02:41:58.500 --> 02:42:00.500
FINANCIAL CENTER ON THE MOVE, NAPA VALLEY COMMUNITY FOUNDATION, FAIR HOUSING,

02:42:02.500 --> 02:42:04.500
HSS EIGHT, OUR TEAM, ALL IMMEDIATELY AT

02:42:05.500 --> 02:42:07.500
THE TABLE TO TALK ABOUT HOW DO WE PUT TOGETHER A PROPOSAL.

02:42:09.500 --> 02:42:11.500
THESE ARE FOLKS WHO HAVE WORKED TOGETHER FOR A REALLY LONG TIME,

02:42:14.500 --> 02:42:16.500
SO IT WAS ALSO A PLEASURE TO BRING PEOPLE TOGETHER AND TO SAY AT THE START,

02:42:20.500 --> 02:42:22.500
[ INDESCERNIBLE ] IS GOING TO TAKE A LOT OF TRUST, WE ARE NOT GOING

02:42:23.500 --> 02:42:25.500
TO HAVE WORKED OUT ALL THE FINANCIAL AGREEMENTS BEFORE WE

02:42:28.500 --> 02:42:30.500
SUBMIT THIS APPLICATION, WE ARE JUST GOING TO HAVE

02:42:31.500 --> 02:42:34.500
TO HAVE SOME HANDSHAKES TO FIGURE OUT HOW WE
DO IT. TO A PERSON, EVERYONE SITTING AROUND THE ROOM IS LIKE HOW DO WE

02:42:36.500 --> 02:42:38.500
DO IT, HOW DO WE PUT IT TOGETHER?

02:42:41.500 --> 02:42:44.500
WHAT YOU ARE SEEING HERE IS OUR PROGRAM DESIGN. IF YOU HAVE SEEN ANY
OF MY PREVIOUS PRESENTATIONS, YOU KNOW I LOVE COLOR

02:42:45.500 --> 02:42:47.500
AND GRAPHICS. THE YELLOW PIECES OF THIS ARE THE PARTS THAT

02:42:53.500 --> 02:42:55.500
THIS IS OUR ADMINISTRATIVE ENTITY SIDE OF THINGS, WE ARE GOING TO BE

02:42:56.500 --> 02:42:59.500
THE GRANT ENTITY LEAD, WE TAKE AND ALL THE MONEY, WE ARE GOING
TO BE RESPONSIBLE FOR ALL THE CONTRACTS AND

02:43:01.500 --> 02:43:04.500
PROCESS ALL THE RENTAL PAYMENTS. WE ARE GOING TO BE THE PRIMARY
PARTNERS WITH THE BOARD AS AN ORGANIZATION, SO

02:43:06.500 --> 02:43:08.500
WE ARE GOING TO HAVE A COUNTERPART AND KEEP COMMUNICATION FLOWING. WE

02:43:09.500 --> 02:43:11.500
ARE ALSO GOING TO SUPPORT THE ELIGIBILITY AND ADVISORY

02:43:12.500 --> 02:43:14.500
COMMITTEE AND EQUITY AND LIVED EXPERIENCE ADVISORY.

02:43:17.500 --> 02:43:19.500
BOTH OF THESE ARE MANDATORY COMPONENTS OF THE GRANT.

02:43:20.500 --> 02:43:22.500
AND BOTH WILL HAVE INDIVIDUALS WITH LIVED EXPERIENCE AND IMMUNITY MEMBERS WHO ARE PART OF IT.

02:43:28.500 --> 02:43:30.500
AND WE HAVE ALSO BROUGHT IN OUR PUBLIC HEALTH PARTNERS TO ENVISION HOW WE

02:43:32.500 --> 02:43:34.500
ARE GOING TO DO AN EVALUATION OF THE PROJECT, SO REALLY

02:43:36.500 --> 02:43:38.500
NOT ONLY LOOKING AT WHAT ARE THE FINANCIAL OUTCOMES FROM IT, BUT WHAT CHANGED

02:43:41.500 --> 02:43:44.500
FOR THE INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE ENROLLED, AS FAR AS THEIR
SENSE OF PERSONAL HEALTH AND WELL-BEING, SO WE CAN REALLY TALK ABOUT, WHAT DOES IT MEAN

02:43:49.433 --> 02:43:52.433
WHEN COMMUNITIES DO A PROJECT LIKE THIS, HOW
DO WE QUANTIFY THE BENEFIT FOR THIS?

02:43:53.433 --> 02:43:55.433
HOW DO PEOPLE FEEL MORE CONNECTED TO THEIR COMMUNITY

02:43:56.433 --> 02:43:58.433
? HOW DO THEY FEEL SAFER?

02:44:01.433 --> 02:44:04.433
GOING TO THE ORANGE AND BLUE SECTIONS, THESE ARE THINGS THAT ARE
GOING TO HAPPEN REALLY EARLY IN THE PILOT. THIS IS OUTREACH AND

02:44:06.433 --> 02:44:09.433
THE APPLICATION AND ENROLLMENT PORTION.
THESE ARE TWO FUNCTIONS THAT ARE REALLY CRITICAL TO THE SUCCESS

02:44:14.433 --> 02:44:16.433
OF THE PILOT, BUT THEY ARE ALMOST ONE TIME. THEY ARE GOING

02:44:17.433 --> 02:44:19.433
TO BE IN THE FIRST SIX MONTHS OF THE PILOT. AND WE HAVE

02:44:22.433 --> 02:44:24.433
DIFFERENT PARTNERS WHO ARE GOING TO DO APPLICATION AND

02:44:26.433 --> 02:44:29.433
ENROLLMENT SUPPORT AND DIFFERENT CONTRACT STRUCTURES FOR THOSE. THE GREEN IS
REALLY THE THRUST OF THE PROGRAM.

02:44:29.433 --> 02:44:31.433
WAS HE THE CLIENT IS REALLY AT THE CENTER.

02:44:34.433 --> 02:44:36.433
THE INTENT OF OUR PROGRAM DESIGN WAS TO BE AS

02:44:37.433 --> 02:44:40.433
HUMAN CENTERED AS POSSIBLE AND THINK ABOUT HOW DO WE
MAKE THIS EASY FOR FOLKS WHO NEED THE HELP, SO WE ARE REACHING THEM

02:44:41.433 --> 02:44:43.433
WHERE THEY WHO IS PROVIDING ALL OF THE APPLICATION

02:44:50.367 --> 02:44:52.367
SUPPORT THAT THEY NEED, SO IF THEY HAVE NO COMPUTER FLUENCY

02:44:53.367 --> 02:44:55.367
AND THIS IS GOING TO BE AN ONLINE APPLICATION, WE ARE

02:44:56.367 --> 02:44:58.367
PAYING STAFF WHO ARE GOING TO HELP THEM FILL OUT THE APPLICATION,

02:44:59.367 --> 02:45:01.367
SUBMIT ALL THEIR PAPERWORK, THEN STICK WITH THEM OVER THE COURSE OF THEIR

02:45:03.367 --> 02:45:05.367
ENROLLMENT. EVERY ENROLLED INDIVIDUAL IN THE PROGRAM IS GOING TO HAVE A

02:45:06.367 --> 02:45:08.367
CASE MANAGER ASSIGNED TO THEM, THEY'RE GOING TO BE WITH THEM AT LEAST ONCE A MONTH,

02:45:11.367 --> 02:45:13.367
CHECKING IN TO SEE THAT WE GOT OUR RENTAL PAYMENT

02:45:14.367 --> 02:45:17.367
MADE ANY ISSUES WITH THE LANDLORD THAT WE
NEED TO IRON OUT , ARE YOU ELIGIBLE FOR BENEFITS YOU

02:45:20.367 --> 02:45:23.367
ARE NOT CURRENTLY ENROLLED IN?
MEDI-CAL BENEFITS ARE GOING TO BE AVAILABLE FOR UNDOCUMENTED INDIVIDUALS PRETTY SHORTLY.

02:45:26.367 --> 02:45:28.367
WE WANT TO MAKE SURE EVERY ONE OF OUR CLIENTS

02:45:29.367 --> 02:45:31.367
IS GETTING ALL THE ASSISTANCE THEY NEED, TOO. THE CASE MANAGERS ARE

02:45:32.367 --> 02:45:35.367
GOING TO DO MORE THAN JUST THE HOUSING SUPPORT,
THEY'RE GOING TO PROVIDE A LEVEL OF WRAPAROUND SOCIAL SUPPORT TO KEEP

02:45:35.367 --> 02:45:37.367
THOSE FOLKS HOUSED. THAT IS THE OTHER

02:45:40.367 --> 02:45:42.367
ESSENTIAL COMPONENT OF KEEPING VULNERABLE INDIVIDUALS WHERE THEY ARE AT. WHAT WE

02:45:49.300 --> 02:45:51.300
ARE ELIGIBLE FOR BENEFITS THAT THEY ARE NOT TAKING ADVANTAGE

02:45:52.300 --> 02:45:54.300
OF, SIMPLY BECAUSE THE PROCESS IS SO CUMBERSOME TO APPLY, SO WE WANT THEM TO

02:45:55.300 --> 02:45:57.300
KIND OF HAVE A TEAM WORKING ON THEIR BEHALF TO REMOVE SOME OF THOSE COMPLEXITIES.

02:46:02.300 --> 02:46:04.300
SO, THE OTHER THING I WANT TO SAY ABOUT TIMELINE,

02:46:05.300 --> 02:46:07.300
IN THE YELLOW SECTION, THIS IS GOING TO BE THE FIRST SIX MONTHS OF

02:46:08.300 --> 02:46:10.300
THE WORK, SO AS SOON AS THIS ANNOUNCEMENT WENT OUT, I ALREADY HAD

02:46:11.300 --> 02:46:13.300
PEOPLE CALLING TO SAY, HOW DO I APPLY, WHERE IS MY RENTAL ASSISTANCE, WE CAN'T WAIT

02:46:14.300 --> 02:46:16.300
TO HAVE ALL THOSE ANSWERS, BUT WE HAVE TO SIGN THE CONTRACT FIRST,

02:46:20.300 --> 02:46:22.300
SO I WILL BE BACK PROBABLY IN JANUARY WITH THE
CONTRACT FOR THE BOARD TO APPROVE. THEN WE NEED ABOUT SIX MONTHS

02:46:26.300 --> 02:46:29.300
TO PUT ALL THE SYSTEMS IN PLACE, SO WE
ARE GOING TO DESIGN AN ONLINE PORTAL, WE HAVE TO ESTABLISH THE ADVISORY COMMITTEE

02:46:31.300 --> 02:46:33.300
IS, WE ARE GOING TO WORK WITH OUR AUDITOR CONTROLLER AND FIGURE OUT

02:46:35.300 --> 02:46:37.300
HOW WE ARE GOING TO DO THE RENTAL PAYMENTS, WE NEED

02:46:38.300 --> 02:46:40.300
ALL OF THESE THINGS AND IT IS GOING TO BE AN ABSOLUTE SPRINT, BUT

02:46:41.300 --> 02:46:43.300
WE NEED SIX MONTHS TO DO THAT. SO, YELLOW IS SIX MONTHS. AFTER THAT,

02:46:53.233 --> 02:46:55.233
[ INDESCERNIBLE ] OVER THE COURSE OF THE FOUR YEARS,

02:47:00.233 --> 02:47:02.233
WE EXPECT THAT TO BE AROUND 250 TO 300 INDIVIDUALS. NOT EVERYBODY IS

02:47:03.233 --> 02:47:05.233
GOING TO NEED THE SAME AMOUNT OF ASSISTANCE, SO

02:47:11.233 --> 02:47:14.233
SORT OF LIKE THE ATU PROGRAM, WE CAN'T QUITE KNOW WHAT PEOPLE
WANT TO BUILD, WE CAN'T KNOW WHAT PEOPLE ARE GOING TO NEED HERE, SO

02:47:16.233 --> 02:47:19.233
IT IS A BIT OF ARRANGEMENT JUST TO DEFINED TERMS, EXTREMELY LOW INCOME, THAT
IS AN ACTUAL AGE CD TERM, THAT MEANS

02:47:27.233 --> 02:47:29.233
30 TO 50% OF AREA MEDIAN INCOME, IT'S A REALLY LOW ECONOMIC THRESHOLD.

02:47:30.233 --> 02:47:32.233
SEVERELY. AND, ALSO AN H CD TERM. SEVERELY BURDENED

02:47:37.233 --> 02:47:39.233
MEANS MORE THAN 70% OF YOUR INCOME IS BEING SPENT ON YOUR HOUSING. BELIEVE IT

02:47:42.233 --> 02:47:44.233
OR NOT, THAT COMBINATION, WE BELIEVE WE

02:47:46.167 --> 02:47:48.167
HAVE MORE THAN 200 58 HOUSEHOLDS RIGHT NOW IN NAPA THAT ARE

02:47:51.167 --> 02:47:53.167
LIVING UNDER THOSE CONDITIONS. WE WILL LIKELY HAVE MORE FOLKS ELIGIBLE

02:47:54.167 --> 02:47:56.167
FOR THE PROGRAM THEN WE CAN ENROLL, SO PART OF

02:47:58.167 --> 02:48:00.167
WHAT IS GOING TO HAPPEN IN THE YELLOW SECTION, WE ARE GOING

02:48:01.167 --> 02:48:04.167
TO WORK WITH FOLKS WITH LIVED EXPERIENCE AND THE PEOPLE WHO SERVE THOSE INDIVIDUALS
TO FIGURE OUT HOW DO WE DETERMINE WHO IS ELIGIBLE

02:48:06.167 --> 02:48:08.167
AND ENROLLED AND WHAT EXACTLY THAT CRITERIA LOOKS LIKE. GO TO THE NEXT SLIDE.

02:48:12.167 --> 02:48:14.167
THIS IS JUST A QUICK LOOK AT THE CHART

02:48:21.167 --> 02:48:23.167
. THESE ARE ALL THE HUMAN BEINGS THAT ARE INVOLVED IN

02:48:24.167 --> 02:48:27.167
IT, AND I WON'T GO THROUGH ALL THESE INDIVIDUAL POSITIONS. I DO JUST
WANT TO HIGHLIGHT THE PARTNERS THAT WERE

02:48:29.167 --> 02:48:31.167
AT THE TABLE AS CORE PROGRAM DESIGN AND DELIVERY PARTNERS.

02:48:33.167 --> 02:48:36.167
THOSE ARE COLLABORATIVE CARE, FAIR HOUSING NAPA
VALLEY, UP VALLEY FAMILY CENTER, HEALTH AND

02:48:37.167 --> 02:48:39.167
HUMAN SERVICES FOR THE COUNTY, THE NAPA COUNTY RECOVERY CENTER, WHICH IS

02:48:41.167 --> 02:48:44.167
A JOINTLY FUNDED PROJECT THROUGH ON THE
MOVE AND NAPA VALLEY COMMUNITY FOUNDATION, AND THEN ON THE MOVE. NOT SHOWN ON HERE

02:48:50.100 --> 02:48:52.100
IS THE NAPA VALLEY COMMUNITY FOUNDATION. I WANT TO HIGHLIGHT THEM

02:48:54.100 --> 02:48:56.100
AS A SERVICE DELIVERY PARTNER, NOT BECAUSE

02:48:57.100 --> 02:48:59.100
THEY ARE ACTUALLY GOING TO BE PROVIDING THE SERVICE, BUT BECAUSE SINCE 2017, THEY HAVE BEEN

02:49:03.100 --> 02:49:06.100
THE ONES TO FIND ALL THE POSITIONS PROVIDING EMERGENCY RENTAL
ASSISTANCE IN THE VALLEY, CALLING EVERY ONE OF OUR DISASTERS.

02:49:08.100 --> 02:49:10.100
SO, IT IS BECAUSE THEY HAVE DONE THAT FUNDING THAT WE

02:49:12.100 --> 02:49:14.100
HAVE THE CAPACITY THAT EXISTS TO REALLY POSITION OURSELVES TO APPLY FOR THIS AID.

02:49:18.100 --> 02:49:20.100
SO, WE ARE LEVERAGING INVESTMENTS THAT THE COMMUNITY FOUNDATION HAS

02:49:21.100 --> 02:49:23.100
ME GOING BACK SIX YEARS IN ORDER TO BE ABLE TO REALLY COMPETE FOR THESE FUNDS.

02:49:27.100 --> 02:49:29.100
WE CAN GO TO THE FINAL FIVE.

02:49:30.100 --> 02:49:32.100
THIS IS JUST TO SHARE A LITTLE BIT OF THE
DATA THAT WE SHARED DURING OUR INTERVIEWS.

02:49:39.100 --> 02:49:41.100
WE SUBMITTED THE GRANT APPLICATION, WE WERE SELECTED AS ONE OF THE FINALISTS, AND

02:49:42.100 --> 02:49:44.100
WE HAD A PRETTY INTENSIVE INTERVIEW WHERE ALL OF THE

02:49:45.330 --> 02:49:47.330
WHY NOT? AND I THINK WE HAVE A REALLY GREAT CASE

02:49:48.330 --> 02:49:50.330
FOR WHY NOT. I JUST WANT TO CLOSE WITH THIS, FIRST AND FOREMOST,

02:49:51.330 --> 02:49:53.330
I WANT TO TOUCH BACK ON THE ENABLING ENVIRONMENT.

02:49:56.330 --> 02:49:58.330
THIS ISN'T ANY ONE OF THE 134, BUT NAPA REALLY DOES HAVE A UNIQUE

02:50:02.330 --> 02:50:04.330
LEVEL OF SUPPORT, WE ARE SORT OF THE ENVY OF A LOT OF OUR PARTNERS

02:50:06.330 --> 02:50:09.330
IN OTHER COUNTIES, WITH OUR SUPERVISORS AND OUR NAPA CITY
COUNCIL HAVE REALLY GIVEN PERMISSION FOR THE HOUSING STAFF TO BE INNOVATIVE.

02:50:14.330 --> 02:50:16.330
SO, THAT, FIRST AND FOREMOST, IS REALLY WHAT GAVE NOT ONLY OUR TEAM, BUT

02:50:18.330 --> 02:50:20.330
ALSO OUR COMMUNITY PARTNERS FAITH THAT WE WERE GOING TO PUT TOGETHER

02:50:21.330 --> 02:50:23.330
A REALLY GREAT APPLICATION AND IT WAS GOING TO HAVE THE SUPPORT THAT IS

02:50:24.330 --> 02:50:26.330
NEEDED INTERNALLY TO BE SUBMITTED. SO, BEYOND THAT,

02:50:27.330 --> 02:50:29.330
THE CASE FOR NAPA, WE HAVE A SIGNIFICANTLY HIGHER RATE OF OLDER ADULTS

02:50:33.330 --> 02:50:35.330
THAN THE STATEWIDE RATES, SO WE SKEW OLDER.
LOTS OF PEOPLE COME HERE TO RETIRE.

02:50:39.330 --> 02:50:41.330
AND THAT COMES WITH A LOT OF OTHER CHALLENGES. SO,

02:50:44.967 --> 02:50:46.967
WE HAVE A REALLY HIGH POPULATION. NAPA

02:50:47.967 --> 02:50:50.967
COUNTY HAS HAD THE HIGHEST NUMBER OF RECENT DISASTERS
IN THE STATE I KNOW WE KNOW THIS, BUT I THINK THE DATA POINT

02:50:52.967 --> 02:50:54.967
IS REALLY IMPORTANT HERE. BETWEEN 2011 AND 2021, THERE WERE 25 FEDERALLY DECLARED DISASTERS

02:50:59.967 --> 02:51:01.967
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA.

02:51:02.967 --> 02:51:05.967
NINE OF THEM OCCURRED IN NAPA.
WE HAVE THE HIGHEST NUMBER OF ANY COUNTY IN

02:51:08.967 --> 02:51:10.967
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA. THIS IS TO ALL OF US WHO HAVE LIVED THROUGH

02:51:11.967 --> 02:51:13.967
THAT, THAT FEELS RIGHT.

02:51:14.967 --> 02:51:16.967
IT ALSO IS IN THIS INTERESTING WAY, IT

02:51:17.967 --> 02:51:19.967
HAS CREATED A LEVEL OF EXPERTISE AND CONNECTION AMONG COMMUNITY PARTNERS

02:51:20.967 --> 02:51:22.967
THAT DOES POSITION US TO DO SOMETHING LIKE THIS REALLY WELL.

02:51:26.967 --> 02:51:28.967
THE PARTNERS WHO CAME TOGETHER, WE HAVE BEEN IN THE TRENCHES WITH ONE ANOTHER, GOING BACK

02:51:31.967 --> 02:51:33.967
SEVEN, EIGHT, NINE YEARS. THERE IS AN ENORMOUS AMOUNT OF TRUST THAT

02:51:34.967 --> 02:51:36.967
EXISTS THERE, AND THAT IS PART OF WHAT GETS NAPA TO BE REALLY COMPETITIVE,

02:51:41.967 --> 02:51:43.967
TO BE ABLE TO LEVERAGE THAT COME TOGETHER AND KNOW WHICH ENTITY

02:51:46.900 --> 02:51:48.900
IS HAVE MUCH EXPERIENCE, AND KNOW THAT WE ARE BETTER AS A WHOLE TOGETHER.

02:51:50.900 --> 02:51:53.900
THE THIRD IS THAT PHILANTHROPIC AID IN NAPA
COUNTY IS SIGNIFICANTLY LOWER PER CAPITA, THIS WAS A STAGGERING STATISTIC,

02:51:56.900 --> 02:51:58.900
THAT WE ARE $812 PER PERSON COMPARED TO SOME OF OUR BAY AREA COUNTIES

02:51:59.900 --> 02:52:01.900
THAT ARE $11,000 PER PERSON.

02:52:08.900 --> 02:52:10.900
WE ARE THE LOWEST AMONG THE BAY AREA COUNTIES. SO,
THE CASE TO SAY THAT PHILANTHROPIC OR GRANT MONEY LIKE THIS BELONGS IN

02:52:12.900 --> 02:52:14.900
NAPA, BECAUSE WE NEED TO BE EQUITABLE ABOUT WHERE

02:52:16.900 --> 02:52:18.900
THOSE FUNDS GO, MEANT A LOT TO THE REVIEWERS FOR THE GRANT. AND FINALLY,

02:52:21.900 --> 02:52:23.900
JUST TO END WITH, I THINK WHAT

02:52:28.900 --> 02:52:31.900
CHRIS DANA TALLEY WAS TOUCHING ON IN HIS PUBLIC COMMENTS EARLIER ON,
INNOVATION MOVES AT THE SPEED OF TRUST. THE

02:52:34.900 --> 02:52:37.900
KIND OF TRUST THAT EXISTS AMONG COMMUNITIES THAT HAVE REALLY DEALT WITH DISASTER
AND HAD TO FIND IN THE FABRIC OF THERE

02:52:38.900 --> 02:52:41.900
BEING THE KIND OF RESILIENCE THAT NAPA
COUNTY HAS, CREATE RELATIONSHIPS AND THE PARTNERSHIPS THAT MAKE THINGS

02:52:43.900 --> 02:52:45.900
LIKE THIS POSSIBLE. SO, WITH THAT, I WILL STOP FOR ANY QUESTIONS

02:52:53.900 --> 02:52:55.900
THAT WE HAVE, AND I WANT TO THANK THE SUPERVISORS FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO

02:52:57.900 --> 02:53:00.900
APPLY FOR IT, I AM VERY PROUD TO BRING THOSE BACK.
>> THANK YOU, AND I KNOW WE WERE

02:53:02.900 --> 02:53:04.900
INCREDIBLY PROUD TO BE IN THAT MEETING, KNOWING THIS WAS COMING BACK TO

02:53:06.900 --> 02:53:08.900
US. JUST ONE COMMENT.

02:53:09.900 --> 02:53:11.900
I REALLY DO LOVE THE EPIDEMIOLOGICAL SURVEY.

02:53:17.900 --> 02:53:19.900
THAT IS GOING TO RESULT FROM THIS.

02:53:21.900 --> 02:53:23.900
AND WHAT I WOULD SUGGEST IS THAT WE REALLY

02:53:27.900 --> 02:53:29.900
LOOK AT THE FIVE PILLARS WITHIN THE STATE'S MASTER PLAN ON AGING.

02:53:33.900 --> 02:53:35.900
OF WHICH THIS ACTUALLY NEEDS FOUR OF THOSE PILLARS,

02:53:36.900 --> 02:53:38.900
BECAUSE THAT IS ONE OF THE THINGS THAT THE STATE IS DOING,

02:53:45.833 --> 02:53:47.833
ALSO SETTING OUT THESE GOALS OF AFFORDABILITY FOR

02:53:48.833 --> 02:53:50.833
HOUSING, FOR SENIOR STABILITY, HEALTH INITIATIVES, AND THAT IS

02:53:53.833 --> 02:53:55.833
PART OF THE MASTER PLAN OF WHICH WE HAVE BEEN -- THROUGH HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES, INVOLVED

02:53:57.833 --> 02:53:59.833
IN, BECAUSE AS WE KNOW, WE HAVE MORE AGING PEOPLE IN PLACE HERE

02:54:03.833 --> 02:54:05.833
IN NAPA COUNTY, SO I REALLY THINK IF WE KIND OF

02:54:08.833 --> 02:54:10.833
FRAME THAT YOU DEEM ILLOGICAL DATA THAT IS COMING, IT IS GOING TO COME FROM OTHER AGENCIES AS WELL,

02:54:18.833 --> 02:54:20.833
WILL SERVE ALL OF US. AND CONGRATULATIONS AND
GREAT WORK. X SUPERVISOR GALLAGHER.

02:54:24.833 --> 02:54:26.833
>> THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THE PRESENTATION AND

02:54:30.833 --> 02:54:32.833
IT IS REALLY EXCITING TO BE ABLE TO CREATE A PROGRAM LIKE THIS, RIGHT?

02:54:33.833 --> 02:54:35.833
THE PUBLIC HEALTH DATA, WILL THAT ALSO INCLUDE --CAN WE ALSO

02:54:39.833 --> 02:54:41.833
LOOK AT SORT OF THE EFFECT ON SOCIAL DETERMINANTS OF HEALTH IN ADDITION

02:54:44.767 --> 02:54:46.767
TO THE HEALTH IMPACTS AND THINGS LIKE THAT?

02:54:48.767 --> 02:54:50.767
MAYBE EXPAND THAT A LITTLE BIT MORE, SO WE CAN GET MORE

02:54:51.767 --> 02:54:53.767
DATA? DO YOU HAVE WHAT YOU NEED IN TERMS OF ITS STAFF?

02:54:57.767 --> 02:54:59.767
>> I MEAN, I WOULD IMAGINE THAT PART OF THE GRANT,

02:55:00.767 --> 02:55:02.767
THIS PART OF THE GRANT COVERS STAFFING AND MEDIA TELL US

02:55:03.767 --> 02:55:05.767
A LITTLE MORE ABOUT THAT.

02:55:08.767 --> 02:55:11.767
>> IN THE INTEREST OF TRYING TO BE BRIEF,
I DIDN'T EVEN TOUCH ON THE FINANCING STRUCTURE FOR THIS, BUT THE BOARD

02:55:12.767 --> 02:55:14.767
MADE $5 MILLION AVAILABLE.

02:55:15.767 --> 02:55:17.767
ONE OF THE FIRST THINGS THAT WE DID WITH THOSE PARTNERS IN THE DESIGN MEETING

02:55:21.767 --> 02:55:23.767
IS WHAT DOES THE STAFFING MODEL NEED TO LOOK LIKE?

02:55:26.767 --> 02:55:28.767
HOW MANY CASE MANAGERS, WHAT IS THE CLIENT TO CASE MANAGER

02:55:29.767 --> 02:55:31.767
RATIO, WHAT KIND OF ADMIN NEEDS TO BE IN PLACE? AND CAME

02:55:32.767 --> 02:55:34.767
UP WITH A TOTAL NUMBER, AND THE 5 MILLION WAS GOING TO BE MORE THAN 50% EATEN UP

02:55:39.767 --> 02:55:41.767
WITH THOSE COSTS, WHICH WE DON'T WANT TO DO,

02:55:42.767 --> 02:55:44.767
BECAUSE THE HARDEST MONEY TO GET YOUR HANDS ON IS THE RENTAL ASSISTANCE MONEY.

02:55:45.700 --> 02:55:47.700
SO, WE ALL COME ACROSS ALL OF THE PARTNERS THERE, TOOK A LOOK

02:55:48.700 --> 02:55:51.700
AT WHAT ARE THE FINDING SOURCES WE HAVE,
WHO IS FINDING WHAT, WHO CAN COMMIT TO CONTINUING TO FIND WHAT, AND

02:55:56.700 --> 02:55:58.700
WHAT OTHER FUNDING SOURCES DO WE HAVE THAT WE CAN BRING IT IN HERE?

02:56:03.700 --> 02:56:06.700
SO, IN ADDITION TO THE $5 MILLION, WE HAVE A COMMITMENT FROM THOSE PARTNERS OF
AN ADDITIONAL $1.6 MILLION, AND THAT IS WHAT IS LARGELY

02:56:08.700 --> 02:56:10.700
GOING TO FIND THAT I'M INSIDE OF IT AND THE

02:56:13.700 --> 02:56:15.700
CASE MANAGEMENT THAT IS GOING ALONG WITH THAT, TOO. BAKED INTO THE PROPOSAL, WE DID ENVISION,

02:56:18.700 --> 02:56:20.700
BECAUSE THESE THINGS ARE A HUGE LIFT, AND WE HAVE GOT

02:56:21.700 --> 02:56:23.700
TO BE ABLE TO SUSTAIN THIS FOR 4 1/2 YEARS. AND TO THAT END,

02:56:24.700 --> 02:56:26.700
I THINK THERE IS AN ITEM THAT IS GOING TO BE COMING BACK TO YOU THROUGH HR

02:56:30.700 --> 02:56:33.700
WHERE WE ARE GOING TO BE HIRING ONE MORE STOP FOR
OUR TEAM WILL BE FULLY DEDICATED TO THIS, AND WE ARE ALREADY STARTING

02:56:33.700 --> 02:56:35.700
TO WORK ON THE M.O. USE WITH ALL OF THE

02:56:36.700 --> 02:56:38.700
PARTNERS TO BE ABLE TO GET THEM TO HIRE THE STAFF. THIS IS FOR

02:56:39.700 --> 02:56:41.700
EVERY ONE OF THE PARTNERS, BUT IT IS ALL FUNDED

02:56:42.700 --> 02:56:44.700
THROUGH EITHER THE GRANT FUNDS OR THE BRAIDED FUNDS THAT ARE

02:56:46.330 --> 02:56:48.667
COMING IN.
>> THANKS.
SUPERVISOR PEDROZA?

02:56:49.670 --> 02:56:51.670
>> THANK YOU, CHAIR.

02:56:54.633 --> 02:56:56.633
I JUST WANT TO THANK YOU AND THE TEAM, HE MOVED VERY QUICKLY

02:56:57.633 --> 02:56:59.633
TO MAKE SOMETHING HAPPEN. THE REWARD IS A HISTORIC INVESTMENT FOR OUR COMMUNITY, SO

02:57:03.633 --> 02:57:05.633
I THINK THE OPPORTUNITY IS HOW DO WE MEASURE SUCCESS?

02:57:09.633 --> 02:57:11.633
FOR NAPA COUNTY, WE ARE COMPETING WITH A LOT OF COUNTIES THAT HAVE A

02:57:12.633 --> 02:57:15.633
LOT OF INFRASTRUCTURE TO TELL THEIR STORY.
WE WANT TO BE PRIVILEGED ENOUGH TO TRY TO COMPETE

02:57:18.633 --> 02:57:21.633
WITH RESOURCES IN THE FUTURE, WE WANT TO MAKE
SURE WE USE THIS AS A SPRINGBOARD AND A STORYBOARD TO TELL PEOPLE

02:57:24.633 --> 02:57:27.633
HOW WE CHANGE LIVES. SO, ANY IDEA ON HOW
YOU ARE GOING TO BE MEASURING THIS OR WHAT TYPE

02:57:29.633 --> 02:57:31.633
OF REPORTING BACK YOU MIGHT DO TO THE BOARD?
>> I WILL HAPPILY COME BACK AS OFTEN

02:57:33.633 --> 02:57:35.633
AS HE WOULD LIKE TO HEAR ABOUT IT.

02:57:42.633 --> 02:57:44.633
I WOULD SAY WE ARE SO EXCITED TO GET STARTED ON THIS WORK, BECAUSE

02:57:45.567 --> 02:57:47.567
AS YOU SAID, THIS IS A HISTORIC OPPORTUNITY AND IT IS A REALLY UNIQUE

02:57:48.567 --> 02:57:50.567
POSITION FOR NAPA TO GET TO LEAD US IN THE BAY AREA, SO WE LOOK

02:57:51.567 --> 02:57:53.567
FORWARD TO GETTING TO SHARE IT WITH OTHER COUNTIES. WE ARE REALLY

02:57:54.567 --> 02:57:56.567
EXCITED TO GETTING TO WORK WITH OTHER ADVISORY AGENCIES, AND

02:58:00.567 --> 02:58:02.567
BEGINNING TO CHEW ON SOME OF THE ISSUES AROUND EQUITY AND ACCESS

02:58:04.567 --> 02:58:06.567
TO THIS KIND OF THING. SO, I THINK THE STORYTELLING COMPONENT IS

02:58:07.567 --> 02:58:09.567
AN ESSENTIAL PART OF WHAT WE NEED TO DO, AND THAT

02:58:11.567 --> 02:58:13.567
WAS PART OF THE REASON TO COME HERE TODAY, TO JUST GIVE A PRESENTATION ON

02:58:15.567 --> 02:58:17.567
WHAT WE ARE DOING, BECAUSE THIS IS REALLY GREAT THAT NAPA HAS GONE INTO COMPETE FOR THIS

02:58:20.567 --> 02:58:22.567
AND THAT WE WERE AWARDED IT AND IT IS GOING TO BE TERRIFIC FOR

02:58:23.567 --> 02:58:25.567
OUR CITIZENS, SO I WILL JUST SAY I WILL HAPPILY COME BACK AS OFTEN

02:58:27.200 --> 02:58:28.533
--
>> I APPRECIATE THAT. ALSO, MAKING SURE WE SEE WHERE WE ARE INVESTING, WHERE PEOPLE LIVE,

02:58:34.567 --> 02:58:37.567
IF IT IS IN DIFFERENT CITIES. WE HAVE SOME
COUNCILMEMBERS RIGHT NOW THAT ARE VERY FOCUSED ON WHAT

02:58:38.567 --> 02:58:40.567
IS HAPPENING WITHIN THEIR CITIES.
WE HAVE TO REMEMBER, WE HAVE TO BE REGIONAL. IF YOU ARE A RESIDENT IN NAPA COUNTY,

02:58:46.500 --> 02:58:48.500
WE ARE MAKING A DIFFERENCE IN YOUR LIVES. WE JUST NEED

02:58:52.500 --> 02:58:54.500
TO BREAK AWAY FROM THE PRETENTIOUS MENTALITY ON

02:58:55.500 --> 02:58:57.500
SOME OF THESE REGIONAL THINGS.
THIS IS NAPA COUNTY BRINGING RESOURCES TO EVERYONE IN OUR COMMUNITY. THAT IS

02:59:01.500 --> 02:59:03.500
OUR JOB AS LEADERS TO BE ON THESE REGIONAL COMMITTEES.

02:59:06.500 --> 02:59:08.500
SO, PART OF THAT STORYTELLING, I THINK IT IS GOING TO BE CRITICAL.

02:59:13.500 --> 02:59:15.500
I JUST APPRECIATE EVERYTHING YOU AND YOUR STAFF DID AND WILL CONTINUE TO

02:59:16.500 --> 02:59:18.500
DO, BECAUSE THE REAL WORK IS ABOUT TO START THANK YOU FOR THAT

02:59:19.500 --> 02:59:22.500
>> SEEING NO OTHER QUESTIONS FROM THE
BOARD, I WILL GO TO PUBLIC COMMENT.

02:59:24.500 --> 02:59:26.500
I WILL GO TO THE PHONE LINE. THANK YOU.

02:59:28.500 --> 02:59:30.500
NOW I WILL CLOSE PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD AND I WILL SAY THANK YOU AND CONGRATULATIONS.

02:59:33.500 --> 02:59:35.500
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. AND UNFORTUNATELY, WE ARE BEHIND ON TIME, SO I APOLOGIZE TO STAFF. BECAUSE

02:59:45.433 --> 02:59:47.433
MOVE INTO CLOSED SESSION, AND WHAT I ANTICIPATE IS SUPERVISOR GREGORY'S ESTIMATION OF

02:59:54.433 --> 02:59:56.433
FLOOD THIS AFTERNOON, I THINK WE WILL COME BACK AT 2:00. DO YOU THINK

03:00:00.433 --> 03:00:02.433
WE WILL BE DONE WITH FLIGHT AT 3:00, BY HALF AN HOUR?

03:00:03.433 --> 03:00:06.433
OKAY, SO WE WILL HAVE AN ESTIMATE FOR
STAFF TO RETURN FOR OUR FINAL ITEM OF 11 C AT 2:00

03:00:12.433 --> 03:00:14.433
, AND MY APOLOGIES AGAIN FOR THAT. I WILL NOW TURN IT OVER

03:00:15.433 --> 03:00:17.433
TO COUNTY COUNCIL TO ANNOUNCE OUR CLOSED SESSION ITEMS.

03:00:22.433 --> 03:00:24.433
THANKS THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR.

03:00:25.433 --> 03:00:27.433
TODAY, THERE ARE TWO ITEMS ON CLOSED SESSION, 14 EIGHT AND 14B. 14 A

03:00:30.433 --> 03:00:32.433
WILL NOT BE HEARD TODAY. ITEM 14 B , LABOR NEGOTIATORS [ INDESCERNIBLE ]

03:00:37.433 --> 03:00:40.267
549 , 576, THIS
, CHRISTINE.

03:00:40.833 --> 03:00:42.833
>> THANK YOU. I WILL OPEN PUBLIC COMMENT ON CLOSED SESSION ITEMS JUST ANNOUNCED.

03:00:54.367 --> 03:00:56.367
NONE IN THE BOARD ROOM, ANY ON THE PHONE LINE?

03:00:57.367 --> 03:00:59.367
NO ONE ON THE LINE, I WILL GO AHEAD AND CLOSE PUBLIC COMMENT AND WE WILL

03:01:00.367 --> 03:01:02.367
REASSESS INTO CLOSED SESSION, THANK YOU.

03:03:48.467 --> 03:03:50.467
>>> THANK YOU, WE ARE NOW BACK FROM

03:03:50.800 --> 03:03:52.800
CLOSED SESSION. THIS TIME, I'LL ASK THE COUNTY COUNCIL

03:03:54.900 --> 03:03:56.900
TO REPORT OUT ON OUR CLOSED SESSION ITEMS

03:03:58.900 --> 03:04:00.900
>> THANK YOU. AGENDA ITEM 14 A WAS

03:04:01.900 --> 03:04:04.900
NOT CONSIDERED BY THE BOARD TODAY.
AGENDA ITEM 14 E, CONFERENCE WITH LABOR NEGOTIATORS

03:04:09.833 --> 03:04:11.833
WAS GIVEN. NO REPORTABLE ACTION.

03:04:12.833 --> 03:04:14.833
>> THANK YOU. NOW FOR OUR FINAL ITEM

03:04:15.833 --> 03:04:17.833
OF THE DAY, WE ARE ACTUALLY GOING TO GET

03:04:18.833 --> 03:04:20.833
TO IT RIGHT NOW. I'VE BEEN PROMISING THIS,

03:04:24.833 --> 03:04:26.833
IT FEELS LIKE, ALL DAY. OUR NEXT ITEM IS ITEM 11 C. THE DIRECTOR OF

03:04:27.833 --> 03:04:29.833
PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES WILL PROVIDE AN UPDATE

03:04:33.833 --> 03:04:35.833
ON THAT PROGRAM FOR FISCAL YEAR 22-'23. THESE TWO FROM THE COUNTY COUNCIL

03:04:39.833 --> 03:04:42.833
WILL LEAD OUR JOURNEY.
>> GOOD AFTERNOON, CHAIR RAMOS AND MEMBERS

03:04:46.833 --> 03:04:48.833
OF THE WARD. I AM A CHIEF BUILDING OFFICIAL FOR THE COUNTY.

03:04:51.833 --> 03:04:53.833
I WAS GOING TO GET STARTED WITH OUR PRESENTATION.

03:05:00.833 --> 03:05:02.833
OKAY. SO, STARTING OUT WITH WHAT COMPLIANCE DOES. SORT

03:05:05.767 --> 03:05:07.767
OF AN OVERVIEW OF THE PROGRAM, SOME HIGHLIGHTS OF

03:05:09.767 --> 03:05:11.767
WHAT HAS HAPPENED. I USED TO, PEER EVERY YEAR. IT'S BEEN A WHILE SINCE

03:05:12.767 --> 03:05:14.767
I'VE DONE THAT. KIND OF DOING A CATCH-UP PROGRAM HERE. ONCE

03:05:15.767 --> 03:05:17.767
I AM FINISHED WITH GOING OVER

03:05:23.767 --> 03:05:25.767
THE PROGRAM, JASON JULIE IS GOING TO

03:05:26.767 --> 03:05:28.767
GO OVER SOME THINGS THAT WILL BE PRESENTING TO THE BOARD OVER THE NEXT --

03:05:30.767 --> 03:05:32.767
IN 2024 IS THE PLAN. LET ME JUST GO OVER WHAT WE DO.

03:05:36.767 --> 03:05:38.767
SO WE HAVE A NUMBER OF CODES THAT WE ENFORCE

03:05:39.767 --> 03:05:41.767
AS A TEAM. PROBABLY THE MOST PROMINENT

03:05:42.767 --> 03:05:44.767
IS THE BUILDING COMPLIANCE COMPONENT, UNDER LEGAL CONSTRUCTION,

03:05:50.767 --> 03:05:52.767
UNPERMITTED NEXT --CONSTRUCTION THAT OCCURS IN THE VALLEY. SUBSTANDARD HOUSING. IF SOMEONE

03:05:54.767 --> 03:05:56.767
HAS A PROBLEM WITH THE HOME THAT THEY ARE RENTING, THEY WILL

03:05:57.767 --> 03:05:59.767
GO OUT AND DOING ACTIONS

03:06:03.767 --> 03:06:05.767
ON THAT. MAKE SURE THAT THEY ARE MEETING AND SAFETY CODE

03:06:08.700 --> 03:06:10.700
FROM CALIFORNIA. AND DANGEROUS BUILDINGS.
USUALLY BUILDINGS THAT HAVE BEEN IMPACTED BY SOMETHING LIKE

03:06:15.700 --> 03:06:17.700
AN EVENT, OR THEY ARE JUST OLD.

03:06:18.700 --> 03:06:20.700
THE GONE BEYOND THE USE --THEIR USEFULNESS AND THEY ARE

03:06:23.700 --> 03:06:25.700
FALLING APART. THEN WE HAVE ZONING COMPLIANCE

03:06:27.700 --> 03:06:29.700
USE PERMITS WHICH WE ISSUE ALL THE TIME IN

03:06:30.700 --> 03:06:32.700
THE COUNTY AND HAVE ISSUED FOUR YEARS, SO WE DID THE COMPLIANCE WITH

03:06:33.700 --> 03:06:35.700
THOSE CONDITIONS.

03:06:36.700 --> 03:06:38.700
CONSERVATION REGULATIONS. WE ALSO

03:06:42.700 --> 03:06:44.700
LOOK OVERSEAS FOR LABOR UNITS AND THE PERMITTING

03:06:48.700 --> 03:06:50.700
OF THOSE.

03:06:51.700 --> 03:06:54.700
VERY COMMON. NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. PROPERTY NUISANCES.
THIS IS SORT OF THE ROOT OF CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR

03:06:59.700 --> 03:07:01.700
MOST JURISDICTIONS. SLOPPY PROPERTIES, YOU MIGHT CALL THEM. CARS PARKED ON FRONT
LAWNS.

03:07:03.700 --> 03:07:05.700
DEBRIS BUILDUP.

03:07:08.633 --> 03:07:10.633
HOUSEHOLD GOODS IN FRONT OF THE PROPERTIES. HOARDING.
WE HANDLE THAT. THEN GRADING AND FLOODPLAIN

03:07:12.633 --> 03:07:14.633
VIOLATIONS CONDUCTED WITHIN THE FLOOD PLANE AND

03:07:15.633 --> 03:07:17.633
FLOOD WAYS. AND OUR

03:07:21.633 --> 03:07:23.633
ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH VIOLATIONS WHICH WE OFTEN SEE WITH

03:07:27.633 --> 03:07:29.633
WELL AND SEPTIC ISSUES AND THEN ALSO, OUR CONSUMER PROTECTION PROGRAM, WE DO

03:07:30.330 --> 03:07:32.233
PROVIDE SUPPORT FOR THEM ON OCCASION.
WE HAVE FIVE CODED --CODE AND COMPLIANCE OFFICERS

03:07:33.633 --> 03:07:35.633
WITH ONE ASSISTANT. AND WE

03:07:39.633 --> 03:07:41.633
ARE CURRENTLY RECRUITING FOR A COMPLIANCE MANAGER WHICH IS

03:07:42.633 --> 03:07:44.633
MY PRIOR ROLE.

03:07:49.633 --> 03:07:51.633
OVERALL --NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. OVERALL, WE REALLY

03:07:52.633 --> 03:07:54.633
ENCOURAGE VOLUNTARY COME LANES. OFTENTIMES,

03:07:55.633 --> 03:07:57.633
YOU WILL PROBABLY HEAR FROM CONSTITUENTS

03:08:03.633 --> 03:08:05.633
BY THE TIME THEY GET TO YOU, WE HAVE PROBABLY EXHAUSTED OURSELVES TRYING

03:08:07.567 --> 03:08:09.567
TO HELP THEM OUT. TO GET THEM INTO COMPLIANCE. A LOT OF EDUCATION

03:08:13.567 --> 03:08:15.567
WITH FOLKS.

03:08:16.567 --> 03:08:18.567
SOMETIMES IT'S DIFFICULT TO GET THINGS PERMITTED

03:08:23.567 --> 03:08:25.567
WITH THERE WERE LAND-USE POLICIES THAT WE HAVE HERE. AND THE

03:08:26.567 --> 03:08:29.567
STRICT BUILDING CODES THAT THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA HAS. WE ALWAYS DO AN
INITIAL LETTER, IDENTIFY WITH THE VIOLATION IS AND

03:08:31.567 --> 03:08:33.567
GIVE A CORRECTION DATE.

03:08:34.567 --> 03:08:36.567
REASONABLE TIMEFRAME. WE ARE ALSO ALWAYS AVAILABLE TO MEET

03:08:37.567 --> 03:08:39.567
AND WORK WITH A PERSON. WE HAVE A POLICY MANUAL

03:08:40.567 --> 03:08:42.567
WE ADOPTED BACK IN 2017 THAT THE

03:08:44.567 --> 03:08:46.567
BOARD ADOPTED ALONG WITH STANDARDIZED FORMS THAT WE USE ON

03:08:50.567 --> 03:08:53.567
EVERY CASE. WE ALWAYS FOLLOW THAT CODE COMPLIANCE POLICY PROCEDURES
MANUAL. HOW WE DOING?

03:09:00.567 --> 03:09:02.567
OH, AND I APPEAR? OKAY, CAN I JUST GO BACK TO

03:09:06.500 --> 03:09:09.500
TEAM APPROACH? SO WE ALSO TAKE A TEAM APPROACH.
WE WORK WITH ALL OF THE DEPARTMENTS AND DIVISIONS IN THE COUNTY. OFTENTIMES,

03:09:10.500 --> 03:09:12.500
WE FIND OURSELVES IN ALL SORTS OF DIFFERENT

03:09:15.500 --> 03:09:17.500
CODE ISSUES THAT WE TRY TO WORK THROUGH WITH

03:09:19.500 --> 03:09:21.500
MULTIPLE DEPARTMENTS. SO WE HAVE THE PROBLEM OF POLICING, WHICH

03:09:24.500 --> 03:09:26.500
ARE SHERIFF'S DEPUTIES ASSIGNED TO THE UNIT.

03:09:27.500 --> 03:09:29.500
THEY TAKE A MORE NEIGHBORHOOD APPROACH TO POLICING. IT'S

03:09:33.500 --> 03:09:35.500
A GREAT PROGRAM. WE WORKED WITH THEM OVER

03:09:36.500 --> 03:09:38.500
THE YEARS. CODE ENFORCEMENT GOES HAND-IN-HAND WITH IT. OFTENTIMES, WE

03:09:41.500 --> 03:09:43.500
CAN HELP THE SHERIFFS WITH ISSUES THAT COME UP

03:09:46.500 --> 03:09:48.500
IN NEIGHBORHOODS. THEN WE ALSO WORK WITH

03:09:49.500 --> 03:09:51.500
THE OTHER DIVISION SUCH AS ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH, CONSERVATION,

03:09:52.500 --> 03:09:54.500
FIRE, COUNTY COUNSEL PLAYS A HUGE ROLE. HER DISTRICT ATTORNEY

03:09:58.500 --> 03:10:00.500
ON OCCASION AND THEN FILLING IN PLANNING. CAN GO TO THE NEXT SLIDE.

03:10:05.433 --> 03:10:07.433
I ARITY WENT THROUGH. WE CAN GO TO THE NEXT SLIDE

03:10:10.433 --> 03:10:12.433
PLEASE. OKAY.

03:10:13.433 --> 03:10:15.433
COMPLAINT INTAKE. MOST CASES ARE THROUGH COMPLAINT BASED. WE HAVE ONLINE

03:10:16.433 --> 03:10:18.433
FORMS THAT YOU CAN FILL OUT. SOME

03:10:20.433 --> 03:10:22.433
PEOPLE WRITE LETTERS. A LOT OF STUFF COMES

03:10:24.433 --> 03:10:26.433
THROUGH EMAIL. THIS IS TYPICALLY HOW MOST OF

03:10:28.433 --> 03:10:30.433
OUR CASES ORIGINATE. SO A LOT OF THAT

03:10:31.433 --> 03:10:33.433
IS JUST COMMUNITY MEMBERS. AND THEN WE DO

03:10:34.433 --> 03:10:36.433
HAVE PROACTIVE ENFORCEMENT. PROACTIVE ENFORCEMENT

03:10:37.433 --> 03:10:39.433
IS ASSOCIATED USUALLY WITH HEALTH AND

03:10:40.433 --> 03:10:42.433
SAFETY OF LEASE TOP PROJECTS THAT ARE

03:10:45.433 --> 03:10:47.433
UNDER CONSTRUCTION IF THEY DON'T HAVE A PERMIT AND THERE IS A COUPLE OF

03:10:49.433 --> 03:10:51.433
REASONS FOR THAT. OBVIOUSLY WANT TO MAKE SURE

03:10:52.433 --> 03:10:54.433
THE BUILDING IS BEING DIRECTED ACCORDING TO

03:10:58.433 --> 03:11:00.433
CODE. IT WILL ALSO SAVE THE PERSON, THE OWNER SOME MONEY IF

03:11:01.433 --> 03:11:03.433
THEY ARE GOING DOWN THE WRONG ROAD AND

03:11:04.433 --> 03:11:06.433
NOT HAVING ENGINEERING DONE ON, SAY, THE BUILDING WOULD WANT

03:11:07.433 --> 03:11:09.433
TO BUILD IT

03:11:12.433 --> 03:11:14.433
, AS WE HAVE EXPERIENCED, IT IS VERY DIFFICULT SOMETIMES TO GET BUILDINGS
TO COMPLY WITH CURRENT CODE AFTER THEY HAVE BEEN

03:11:16.433 --> 03:11:19.433
BUILT.
IT CAN BE VERY COSTLY TO TRY TO TEAR THINGS APART AND

03:11:22.433 --> 03:11:24.433
GO BACK AND RETRO THAT. THEN

03:11:28.433 --> 03:11:30.433
I WANTED TO GO OVER OUR COMPLAINT PRIORITY IN OUR

03:11:34.433 --> 03:11:36.433
NEXT SLIDE.

03:11:37.433 --> 03:11:39.433
TWO PRIORITIES. ONE IS SAFETY-RELATED AND THAT WILL

03:11:40.433 --> 03:11:42.433
DETERMINE OUR RESPONSE TIME. IF IT'S LIFE SAFETY, BUILDINGS WITHOUT PERMITS, UNSAFE

03:11:46.433 --> 03:11:48.433
STRUCTURES, ENVIRONMENTAL HAZARDS AND

03:11:54.433 --> 03:11:56.433
WE WILL RESPOND TO THOSE AS QUICKLY AS WE CAN. THEN WE HAVE

03:11:57.433 --> 03:11:59.433
PRIORITY TWO, WHICH IS PROPERTY NEW SINCE WITH A CAR PARKED ON THE LAWN

03:12:01.433 --> 03:12:03.433
OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT THAT THE NEIGHBORS ARE

03:12:05.367 --> 03:12:07.367
CALLING ABOUT. WE ARE PROBABLY SEVERAL DAYS BEFORE WE WILL GET TO THOSE.

03:12:14.367 --> 03:12:16.367
NEXT SLIDE.

03:12:17.367 --> 03:12:19.367
THIS IS A BREAKDOWN OF WHAT WE GET HERE AS FAR AS COMPLAINTS

03:12:23.367 --> 03:12:25.367
AND CASES 38%

03:12:30.367 --> 03:12:33.367
, THAT'S THE ILLEGAL CONSTRUCTION.
OR THE UNPERMITTED WORK,

03:12:37.367 --> 03:12:39.367
BASICALLY. ZONING COMES IN SECOND AND THEN WHEN WE GET

03:12:41.367 --> 03:12:43.367
TO PROPERTY NUISANCES

03:12:49.367 --> 03:12:51.367
, YOU CAN SEE THE BREAKDOWN, GRADING, CONSERVATION, SUBSTANDARD BUILDINGS. ONCE

03:12:52.367 --> 03:12:54.367
IN A WHILE, WE GET COMPLAINTS ON THAT.
WE SEEM TO SEE MORE SUBSTANDARD BUILDINGS IN

03:12:55.367 --> 03:12:58.367
THE WINTER WHEN FOLKS EITHER DON'T HAVE A HEATER WORKING OR SOME
PROBLEMS MAYBE WITH THE ROOF FOR A TENANT, SO WE WILL GET INVOLVED WITH

03:12:59.367 --> 03:13:01.367
THAT.

03:13:03.367 --> 03:13:05.367
NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. JUST ON THE PERMIT ENFORCEMENT, SOME STATISTICS.

03:13:08.300 --> 03:13:10.300
LAST YEAR IN 2020 -- 2022-'23,

03:13:14.300 --> 03:13:16.300
WE HAD OVER $3.26 MILLION WORTH OF WORK ON THE

03:13:20.300 --> 03:13:22.300
VALLEY THAT WE BROUGHT IN UNDER OUR CASES. NOT THAT

03:13:25.300 --> 03:13:27.300
MUCH MONEY. THAT'S THE EVALUATION OF THE WORK.

03:13:35.300 --> 03:13:38.300
WE HAVE BUILDING INVESTIGATION FEES. THAT'S THE FOUR-TIME
FEE THAT WHEN SOMEONE DOES WORK WITHOUT A PERMIT, THEY ARE HIT WITH THAT UNDER

03:13:41.300 --> 03:13:43.300
THE CALIFORNIA BUILDING CODE.

03:13:50.300 --> 03:13:52.300
THAT IS TOTALING $501,222 IN THE LAST YEAR.

03:13:54.300 --> 03:13:56.300
UNPERMITTED CONSTRUCTION. HERE IS AN EXAMPLE.

03:14:07.233 --> 03:14:09.233
THIS IS TRICKY WITH THE STAFF BECAUSE WE ARE WELL AWARE OF

03:14:10.233 --> 03:14:12.233
OUR IMPENDING HOUSING NEEDS. THERE HAS BEEN

03:14:14.233 --> 03:14:16.233
A STRONGER FOCUS ON TRYING TO GET

03:14:20.233 --> 03:14:22.233
THESE SUBMITTED. THEY ARE IMPORTANT TO GET

03:14:26.233 --> 03:14:28.233
IN LINE. A LOT OF ADDITIONS

03:14:32.233 --> 03:14:34.233
ON HOMES. MAIN DRAWINGS THAT

03:14:37.233 --> 03:14:39.233
ARE LEFT IN THE VALLEY. PARTICULARLY IN THE AREAS WHERE NOBODY IS

03:14:41.233 --> 03:14:43.233
COMING TO YOU DO IT. JUST

03:14:45.233 --> 03:14:47.233
WANTED TO SPEAK ABOUT THAT. SUBSTANDARD BILLING, NEXT SLIDE. THIS IS

03:14:50.233 --> 03:14:52.233
VERY COMMON ISSUE THAT WE WILL SEE WITH WIRING. COMPLETELY UNFAMILIAR

03:14:53.233 --> 03:14:55.233
WITH HOW TO WIRE

03:14:59.233 --> 03:15:01.233
A HOME. A HUGE HAZARD. THIS IS A

03:15:08.167 --> 03:15:10.167
FIRE HAZARD. THE LARGE FIRES THAT ARE INCURRED --OCCURRED WAS BECAUSE

03:15:14.167 --> 03:15:16.167
OF A POORLY WIRED HOT TUB. THAT'S WHAT TOOK OUT A FAIR AMOUNT

03:15:17.167 --> 03:15:19.167
OF LAND UP THERE. IT IS IMPORTANT THAT WE

03:15:23.167 --> 03:15:25.167
STAY ON TOP OF THESE.

03:15:26.167 --> 03:15:28.167
THE NEXT SLIDE

03:15:32.167 --> 03:15:34.167
PLEASE. FIRST, THE SINK BATHTUB COMBO. JUST

03:15:37.167 --> 03:15:39.167
KIND OF AN INTERESTING WAY TO DRAIN YOUR

03:15:43.167 --> 03:15:45.167
SINK. NOTICED THE PLUNGER THERE. THAT'S PROBABLY BEEN NEEDED

03:15:47.167 --> 03:15:49.167
ON OCCASION. IN YOUR TYPICAL SORTER FROM YOUR EXAMPLE OF CARS PARKED

03:15:50.167 --> 03:15:52.167
IN THE FRONT YARD, BROKEN WINDOWS,

03:15:56.167 --> 03:15:58.167
FRONT LIGHTS. THE GRASS OVERGROWN A

03:16:02.167 --> 03:16:04.167
LITTLE BIT. THINGS LIKE THAT. THE NEXT SLIDE IS AN EXAMPLE OF OUR CREEK

03:16:13.100 --> 03:16:16.100
CONSERVATION RAGS. THIS IS AN EXAMPLE OF ACTUALLY --THIS WAS A BRIDGE THAT
WAS FAILING. NOT SHOWING YOU THE BRIDGE

03:16:18.100 --> 03:16:20.100
PART, BUT THIS WAS UP ON THE NORTH SIDE OF THE

03:16:24.100 --> 03:16:26.100
BRIDGE THAT OBVIOUSLY FAILED. AND SEE WHERE THE

03:16:27.100 --> 03:16:29.100
FENCE GETS PULLED BACK.

03:16:36.100 --> 03:16:38.100
SO IF DEBRIS IS NOT MANAGED, OBVIOUSLY, THERE WAS A LOT OF DEBRIS ON THE EDGE OF

03:16:39.100 --> 03:16:41.100
THE BANK YEAR, WHICH IS WHAT IS CAUSING THE FAILURES HERE. WE WILL

03:16:42.100 --> 03:16:44.100
GET INVOLVED IN THAT. USUALLY WORKING WITH QUALITY CONTROL BOARD

03:16:48.100 --> 03:16:50.100
AND FISH AND WILDLIFE ON THESE ISSUES. NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

03:16:56.100 --> 03:16:59.100
ONE OF THE FOCUSES THIS PAST YEAR OR SO IS
TO REALLY FOCUS ON OUR CASE BACKLOG.

03:17:02.100 --> 03:17:04.100
THE COVID ALONG WITH THE FIRE HAS REALLY SET AS BACK

03:17:08.330 --> 03:17:10.330
A BIT AS WELL AS KEEPING UP WITH CASES AND NOT BEING ABLE TO

03:17:12.330 --> 03:17:14.330
FOLLOW THROUGH. 50 TO 300 CASES PER YEAR THAT

03:17:15.330 --> 03:17:17.330
HAVE OPENED UP. STAFF THAT

03:17:21.330 --> 03:17:23.330
IS REALLY ABLE TO CLOSE 1 TO

03:17:25.330 --> 03:17:27.330
200. IT'S BEEN DIFFICULT TO TRY TO STAY UP ON

03:17:30.330 --> 03:17:32.330
THE CASES. FOCUSED ON GETTING THOSE. MULTIPLE STRUCTURE.

03:17:36.330 --> 03:17:38.330
ONE THAT WE FINALLY JUST CLOSED. SOMETIMES THEY TAKE

03:17:39.330 --> 03:17:41.330
3 TO 5 YEARS OR MORE. I THINK WE HAD ONE CASE THAT TOOK

03:17:45.330 --> 03:17:47.330
10 YEARS.
THEY FINALLY CLOSED IT. IT WAS BRUTAL TO GET THEM ACROSS THE FINISH LINE.

03:17:49.330 --> 03:17:52.330
COULD YOU GO TO THE NEXT LIGHT, PLEASE?
HERE IS AN EXAMPLE OF A CASE

03:17:55.330 --> 03:17:57.330
THAT WAS CLOSED. SUBSTANDARD PROPERTY BEFORE

03:18:00.330 --> 03:18:02.330
AND AFTER. AS YOU CAN SEE, A SIMILAR AREA, ALL CLEANED UP. THESE

03:18:05.967 --> 03:18:07.967
ARE GREAT TO DO AND GREAT FOR BEFORE AND AFTER PHOTOS.

03:18:11.967 --> 03:18:13.967
NEXT SLIDE. THIS HAPPENED SOME TIME AGO.

03:18:17.967 --> 03:18:19.967
IT'S IN GREGORY'S DISTRICT. WE HAD A LARGE LANDSLIDE

03:18:23.967 --> 03:18:25.967
THAT OCCURRED . THIS IS PROBABLY AN EXAMPLE WHERE WE

03:18:26.967 --> 03:18:28.967
HAD MULTIPLE DEPARTMENTS, PUBLIC WORKS, COUNTY COUNSEL, ENGINEERING

03:18:29.967 --> 03:18:31.967
DIVISION, CODE ENFORCEMENT ALL WORKING ON THIS OVER A NUMBER OF YEARS.

03:18:32.967 --> 03:18:34.967
THE PROPERTY OWNER FAILED TO

03:18:41.967 --> 03:18:43.967
CORRECT THIS IS THE RESULT OF SOME GRADING THAT
OCCURRED BELOW THE DWELLING THERE.

03:18:44.967 --> 03:18:46.967
IF YOU WANT TO GO TO THE NEXT SLIDE. AND THIS IS WHEN IT IS

03:18:50.967 --> 03:18:52.967
RESTORED. THIS IS WHERE WE WENT IN AND ACTUALLY GOT AN ABATEMENT

03:18:53.967 --> 03:18:55.967
AND WERE ABLE TO UPDATE THIS THROUGH THE
COURTS, GO IN AND THE BOARD APPROVED THE REPAIR OF

03:18:59.967 --> 03:19:01.967
THIS HILLSIDE. SO IT'S A SUCCESS IN

03:19:04.900 --> 03:19:06.900
THE RESPECT THAT WE WERE ABLE TO GET THIS FIXED SO IT WASN'T

03:19:09.900 --> 03:19:11.900
THREATENING THE ROAD BELOW, WHICH IS THE COUNTY ROAD, WHICH SERVES A LOT

03:19:14.900 --> 03:19:16.900
OF PEOPLE UP THERE. JUST WANTED TO SHOW

03:19:17.900 --> 03:19:19.900
THAT AS AN EXAMPLE. AND OUR NEXT SLIDE ,

03:19:26.900 --> 03:19:28.900
I WANTED TO TALK QUICKLY ABOUT A NEIGHBORHOOD IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM THAT WE HAVE DONE

03:19:30.600 --> 03:19:33.233
OVER THE YEARS. THIS IS PROACTIVE.
WE GO OUT AND IDENTIFY SOME OF

03:19:35.900 --> 03:19:37.900
THE NEIGHBORHOOD IN THE VALLEY. WE HAVE THE ESTATES

03:19:41.900 --> 03:19:44.900
AND ISLANDS.
MILTON ROAD. THOSE AREAS THAT ARE A LITTLE

03:19:48.900 --> 03:19:50.900
MORE DENSE THAN HAVE SOME SORT OF QUALITY NEIGHBORHOOD

03:19:51.900 --> 03:19:53.900
ISSUES WHERE PEOPLE WERE STORING MATERIALS

03:19:54.900 --> 03:19:56.900
OUT FRONT. SO WHAT WE DO, IT'S A GREAT TIME FOR THE CODE

03:19:57.900 --> 03:19:59.900
ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS TO GO

03:20:02.900 --> 03:20:04.900
OUT ON IT AND KIND OF EDUCATE AND WE DO DOOR HANGERS. NOBODY

03:20:09.833 --> 03:20:11.833
IS HOME. TO CREATE A MORE HEALTHY NEIGHBORHOOD IS WHAT IT BOILS DOWN TO. WE'VE SEEN

03:20:12.833 --> 03:20:14.833
IT WORK PRETTY WELL IN THE PAST. WE'VE GOT SOME AREAS IN TOWN

03:20:15.833 --> 03:20:17.833
THAT WE WILL GO OUT

03:20:21.833 --> 03:20:23.833
TO. BASIC, EASY STUFF THAT THEY CAN ACHIEVE. NOT OPENING A CAN OF WORMS

03:20:27.833 --> 03:20:29.833
FOR VIOLATIONS ON EIGHT MAJOR PROPERTY.

03:20:33.833 --> 03:20:36.833
THINGS LIKE THE CAR PARKED, SOME TRASH STORED IN THE
FRONT YARD, MAYBE SOME CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS

03:20:37.833 --> 03:20:39.833
THEY HAVE BEEN MEANING TO USE BUT THEY HAVE NOT. SO THAT'S A

03:20:42.833 --> 03:20:44.833
GREAT PROGRAM.
WE WERE PLANNING ON CONTINUING THAT PROGRAM

03:20:47.833 --> 03:20:49.833
IN 2024. NOW WE ARE KIND OF GETTING OUR HEADS ABOVE

03:20:51.833 --> 03:20:53.833
THE WATER. NEXT SLIDE, JUST A QUICK

03:20:57.833 --> 03:20:59.833
STAFF APPRECIATION.
DURING COVID, THERE WERE THE HEALTH ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS. JUST WANTED TO

03:21:03.833 --> 03:21:05.833
RECOGNIZE THEY DID A GREAT JOB THEY WERE AVAILABLE

03:21:06.833 --> 03:21:08.833
SEVEN DAYS A WEEK.

03:21:09.833 --> 03:21:11.833
IT'S A TERRIBLE JOB TO DO. NOT EVERYBODY AGREED AND THEY WERE

03:21:15.833 --> 03:21:17.833
CONSTANTLY CHANGING. AND SO WE WERE OUT THERE TRYING TO EDUCATE PEOPLE

03:21:18.833 --> 03:21:20.833
ON WEARING MASKS ALL THE WAY TO BUSINESSES THAT

03:21:24.833 --> 03:21:26.833
ARE OPERATING.
VERY CHALLENGING. I CANNOT RECALL A MORE CHALLENGING TIME IN MY CAREER

03:21:27.833 --> 03:21:29.833
FROM AN OR CEMENT PERSPECTIVE. GREAT

03:21:32.833 --> 03:21:34.833
JOB WITH THAT. THEN ALSO THE FIRES RIGHT IN THE MIDDLE OF THAT. THAT

03:21:35.833 --> 03:21:37.833
TEAM WAS A HUGE PLAYER IN ASSISTING THE STATE AND THEIR CONTRACTORS TO

03:21:39.833 --> 03:21:41.833
GET THE PROPERTY

03:21:45.833 --> 03:21:48.833
CLEANED UP.
GOT PUT INTO THE BACK HILLS OF THE COUNTY. FOUR-WHEEL-DRIVE AND WE WOULD

03:21:51.833 --> 03:21:53.833
HAVE TO TAKE THE CREWS OUT THERE TO CLEAN UP. SO THAT WAS ANOTHER THING

03:21:54.833 --> 03:21:56.833
THAT WAS A GREAT THING GETTING THROUGH THE

03:21:57.833 --> 03:21:59.833
CLEANUP. I REALLY APPRECIATE THE TEAM FOR REALLY WORKING

03:22:05.767 --> 03:22:07.767
I WANTED TO GO TO THE NEXT SECTION WITH

03:22:09.767 --> 03:22:11.767
JASON HERE WITH TOWN AND COUNTY COUNCIL.

03:22:12.767 --> 03:22:14.767
>> GOOD AFTERNOON.

03:22:16.767 --> 03:22:18.767
JASON DOOLEY, DEPUTY COUNTY COUNSEL.
I HAVE THE PLEASURE OF OVERS BEING THE CODE AND OR

03:22:21.767 --> 03:22:23.767
CEMENT TEAM OR COUNTY AND COUNCIL.

03:22:27.767 --> 03:22:29.767
OUR FOCUS IS ON SUPPORTING AND EMPOWERING THE CODE ENFORCEMENT TEAM

03:22:30.767 --> 03:22:32.767
TO BE ABLE TO DO WHAT THEY DO WHAT THEY HAVE SHOWN YOU.

03:22:36.767 --> 03:22:38.767
WE HAVE AN ADVISORY ROLE THAT WE

03:22:41.767 --> 03:22:43.767
HELP WITH PROCESSES AND PROCEDURES.
WE HOPE WITH GENERAL ADVICE ON CASE

03:22:49.767 --> 03:22:51.767
MANAGEMENT REQUEST. WE ARE USUALLY INVOLVED ONLY WHEN THE CASES

03:22:55.767 --> 03:22:57.767
ARE DIFFICULT.

03:22:58.767 --> 03:23:00.767
WE ARE OFTEN FACING THE MORE COMPLEX CASES. WE ALSO HAVE A TRANSACTION

03:23:01.767 --> 03:23:03.767
OVERALL.

03:23:04.700 --> 03:23:06.700
ONE OF THE REQUIREMENTS

03:23:07.700 --> 03:23:09.700
IN THE CODE ENFORCEMENT PROCEDURES MANUAL IS THAT ANY VOLUNTARY

03:23:11.700 --> 03:23:14.700
COMPLIANCE IS DOCUMENTED IN SOME WAY.
OFTEN TIMES, THROUGH

03:23:17.700 --> 03:23:19.700
COMMUNICATIONS BETWEEN CODE ENFORCEMENT STAFF AND THE

03:23:22.700 --> 03:23:24.700
PROPERTY OWNERS. BUT IT CAN TAKE THE FORM OF A COMPLIANCE AGREEMENT WHICH IS

03:23:25.700 --> 03:23:27.700
A MORE FORMAL RESOLUTION OR AGREEMENT TO

03:23:29.700 --> 03:23:31.700
RESOLVE COMPLIANCE MATTERS AND WE ASSIST

03:23:34.700 --> 03:23:36.700
IN PREPARING THOSE AGREEMENTS.

03:23:40.700 --> 03:23:43.700
THEN OUR KIND OF MOST PROMINENT ROLE IS
THE ADVOCACY ROLE, WHEN MATTERS GET TOO DIFFICULT

03:23:46.700 --> 03:23:48.700
FOR OUR INFORMAL METHODS OF COMPLIANCE AND SOME OF OUR MORE

03:23:49.700 --> 03:23:51.700
FORMAL ONES LIKE CITATIONS. WE END UP REPRESENTING THE

03:23:55.700 --> 03:23:57.700
DEPARTMENT AND THE DIVISION IN COURT WITH THEM AND THAT CAN RANGE FROM

03:23:59.700 --> 03:24:01.700
OBTAINING UPS INSPECTION WARRANTS TO GETTING COURT ORDERS TO ALLOW

03:24:07.633 --> 03:24:09.633
OF VIOLATIONS TO NUISANCE ACTIONS WHERE WE ARE SEEKING A COURT ORDER

03:24:12.633 --> 03:24:14.633
TO DETERMINE IF THE VIOLATION IS A PUBLIC NUISANCE

03:24:16.633 --> 03:24:18.633
AND NEEDS TO BE EVADED. THAT PROVIDES ADDITIONAL TOOLS

03:24:19.633 --> 03:24:21.633
FOR STAFF TO TRY TO RESOLVE THOSE

03:24:25.633 --> 03:24:27.633
VIOLATIONS AND GET THEM INTO COMPLIANCE. AND OUR OFFICE PLAYS A

03:24:28.633 --> 03:24:30.633
ROLE IN THAT. LIKE I SAID, OUR MAIN GOAL IS

03:24:34.633 --> 03:24:36.633
TO EQUIP AND EMPOWER STAFF TO DO

03:24:42.633 --> 03:24:44.633
THEIR JOBS. THERE'S A LOT OF CASES THAT THE COUNTY COUNSEL HAS BEEN INVOLVED
IN. WE ARE OBVIOUSLY HAPPY

03:24:49.633 --> 03:24:52.633
WITH THAT.
PROBABLY MORE PROUD OF THE CASES THAT DON'T EVEN COME TO

03:24:55.633 --> 03:24:57.633
OUR OFFICE. WE HAVE HAD THE TOOLS AND THE ABILITY

03:24:58.633 --> 03:25:00.633
TO REACH THOSE RESOLUTIONS WITHOUT RESORTING TO

03:25:04.567 --> 03:25:06.567
FROM OUR OFFICE. AS WE GO TO THE

03:25:10.567 --> 03:25:12.567
NEXT SLIDE. I DO WANT TO TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT WAYS THAT WE WANT

03:25:13.567 --> 03:25:15.567
TO EMPOWER STAFF THAT WE PLAN TO BRING

03:25:19.567 --> 03:25:21.567
BACK TO THE BOARD IN THE NEAR FUTURE. GOING TO START IN

03:25:22.567 --> 03:25:24.567
THE MIDDLE.

03:25:25.567 --> 03:25:27.567
THE UPDATE TO FINES

03:25:31.567 --> 03:25:34.567
AND PENALTIES.
THE STATE ACTUALLY SETS THE FINES AND PENALTIES FOR ADMINISTRATIVE FINES.

03:25:36.567 --> 03:25:38.567
CITATIONS. THERE IS A STATE STATUTE THAT SETS THAT AMOUNT.

03:25:45.567 --> 03:25:47.567
RECOMMENDS THAT THE COUNTY ADOPT A RESOLUTION TO ESTABLISH THOSE FINES

03:25:49.567 --> 03:25:51.567
AND PENALTIES. THE LAST TIME THE COUNTY HAS ADOPTED SUCH A

03:25:52.567 --> 03:25:54.567
RESOLUTION WAS 2005. THERE HAVE BEEN THREE OR

03:25:56.567 --> 03:25:58.567
FOUR UPDATE SINCE THAT TIME. WE

03:26:02.567 --> 03:26:04.567
ARE PLANNING ON THE 19th TO FINES AND PENALTIES TO REFLECT CURRENT

03:26:08.500 --> 03:26:10.500
STATE LAW. THERE ARE A COUPLE OF AREAS WHERE THERE ARE NEW

03:26:11.500 --> 03:26:13.500
FINES AND PENALTIES THAT ARE AUTHORIZED BY

03:26:16.500 --> 03:26:18.500
STATE LAW. FOR SPECIFIC TYPES OF VIOLATION.

03:26:20.500 --> 03:26:22.500
IN PARTICULAR, FOR EVENT ORDINANCE

03:26:24.500 --> 03:26:26.500
VIOLATIONS. AND FOR SHORT-TERM RENTAL VIOLATIONS. BOTH

03:26:28.500 --> 03:26:30.500
OF THOSE HAVE DETERMINED THAT THE ADDITIONAL INCENTIVE OF THE FINES

03:26:35.500 --> 03:26:37.500
ABOVE THE TENDERED LINE IS APPROPRIATE FOR INCENTIVIZING

03:26:41.500 --> 03:26:43.500
AND DETERRING THOSE WHO VIOLATE THOSE ORDINANCES. THAT WILL BE ON

03:26:47.500 --> 03:26:49.500
THE AGENDA FOR THE NEXT MEETING. WE ARE ALSO LOOKING

03:26:50.500 --> 03:26:52.500
AT KIND OF A LARGER UPDATE TO THE

03:26:55.500 --> 03:26:57.500
CODE ENFORCEMENT, TO A CODE ENFORCEMENT MECHANISM

03:26:59.500 --> 03:27:01.500
THAT WE DON'T USE VERY MUCH.

03:27:04.433 --> 03:27:07.433
THE ADMINISTRATIVE ABATEMENT PROCEDURES, WE HAVE A
CHAPTER IN OUR CODE FOR THAT. IT IS ACTUALLY A VERY AFFECT THE WAY

03:27:11.433 --> 03:27:13.433
TO EMPOWER STAFF TO GET --TO HAVE

03:27:17.433 --> 03:27:19.433
ABATEMENT BE DONE WITHOUT GOING TO COURT.

03:27:29.433 --> 03:27:32.433
HAVEN'T HAD ONE SINCE I BELIEVE 2014 OR
2015. WE HAVE OPTED FOR OTHER MECHANISMS. WE ARE LOOKING AT

03:27:35.433 --> 03:27:37.433
PROVIDING WERE HEARING OFFICER PROCEDURE. THAT WOULD ALLOW

03:27:38.433 --> 03:27:40.433
THEM TO GO TO A HEARING OFFICER RATHER

03:27:41.433 --> 03:27:43.433
THAN TO THE BOARD. AND WILL ALLOW STAFF TO HAVE

03:27:44.433 --> 03:27:46.433
THOSE ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS WHICH MAY

03:27:47.433 --> 03:27:49.433
MAKE IT LESS COMMON

03:27:53.433 --> 03:27:55.433
TO GO TO COURT FOR NUISANCE ORDERS. THAT WILL BE A

03:28:01.433 --> 03:28:03.433
LONGER-TERM APPROACH. THAT WILL INVOLVE AMENDMENTS TO OUR

03:28:08.367 --> 03:28:10.367
LOOKING AT -- MR. JUDAS, HE MENTIONS THE POLICIES AND PROCEDURES

03:28:11.367 --> 03:28:13.367
MANUAL WHICH WAS ADOPTED

03:28:17.367 --> 03:28:20.367
IN 2017. IT HAS BEEN A GOOD WAY TO FOCUS
THE EFFORTS OF STAFF. IN THE LAST SEVEN YEARS , WE HAVE ENCOUNTERED

03:28:26.367 --> 03:28:28.367
SOME AREAS IN WHICH WE NEED TO ADDRESS OR CHANGE THOSE SINS

03:28:29.367 --> 03:28:31.367
THEY WERE REPORTED ADOPTED.

03:28:39.367 --> 03:28:41.367
OUR APPROACH, WE ARE LOOKING AT THE IDEA OF SEPARATING THE

03:28:45.367 --> 03:28:47.367
POLICIES AND GOALS ASPECTS

03:28:51.367 --> 03:28:53.367
ESTABLISHING WHAT THOSE GOALS AND POLICIES ARE FROM THE DAY

03:28:55.367 --> 03:28:57.367
TODAY PROCEDURES ELEMENTS THAT ARE IN

03:29:00.367 --> 03:29:02.367
THIS MANUAL.

03:29:06.300 --> 03:29:08.300
MANUAL ESTABLISHES THE CASE IN A CERTAIN SOFTWARE. A

03:29:12.300 --> 03:29:14.300
LOT OF EVERYDAY DETAIL IN THEIR THAT

03:29:16.300 --> 03:29:18.300
IS, WE THINK, MORE APPROPRIATE FOR A STAFF

03:29:24.300 --> 03:29:26.300
LEVEL DOCUMENT.
WE ARE LOOKING AT WHAT APPROACH IS BEST AS FAR AS ENSURING THAT THE GOALS

03:29:28.300 --> 03:29:30.300
AND PRIORITIES ARE CLEARLY SET FORTH FOR THE BOARD

03:29:33.300 --> 03:29:35.300
TO ADDRESS. THE STAFF IS EMPOWERED

03:29:39.300 --> 03:29:41.300
TO EXECUTE DUTIES IN A WAY THAT MAKES

03:29:42.300 --> 03:29:44.300
SENSE FOR

03:29:48.300 --> 03:29:50.300
THEM. THOSE ARE THE MAIN ITEMS THAT WE HAVE COMING

03:29:54.300 --> 03:29:56.300
FOR YOU. WITH THAT WE ARE HAPPY TO ANSWER

03:30:00.300 --> 03:30:03.300
ANY QUESTIONS.
>> THANK YOU FOR THAT. I WILL FIRST TURN TO SUPERVISOR

03:30:06.330 --> 03:30:07.867
COTTRELL.
>> THANK YOU MR.

03:30:12.233 --> 03:30:14.233
CHAIR. THAT WAS A REALLY HELPFUL PRESENTATION. I THINK THERE

03:30:15.233 --> 03:30:17.233
WAS A LOT OF TOUGH JOBS AT THE COUNTY. FOLKS

03:30:20.233 --> 03:30:22.233
WORKING IN CODE ENFORCEMENT HAVE SOME OF THE TOUGHEST JOBS. CHAIR

03:30:24.233 --> 03:30:26.233
GREGORY GET FOLKS

03:30:29.233 --> 03:30:31.233
TO BE COMPLIANT AND ALSO RECOGNIZING OUR BUILDING LIFE AND SAFE

03:30:33.233 --> 03:30:35.233
THE REQUIREMENTS AND ALSO HELPING PEOPLE WHO, FOR WHATEVER SET OF REASONS,

03:30:36.233 --> 03:30:39.233
NEED TO COME IN TO COME BY AND.
I JUST WANT TO SAY THANK YOU FOR THE WORK AND PARTICULARLY MR.

03:30:42.233 --> 03:30:44.233
BOARD AUNE, I AM ON A CALL WE BE ABOUT QUESTIONS I HAVE

03:30:46.233 --> 03:30:49.233
FROM RESIDENTS WERE TRYING TO FIGURE THINGS OUT AND I APPRECIATE THE TIME
THAT YOU GUYS WENT ON THAT. I'M HAPPY TO

03:30:54.233 --> 03:30:56.233
HEAR ABOUT THE UPDATE TO THE POLICIES AND PROCEDURES. I LIKE

03:30:57.233 --> 03:30:59.233
THAT KIND OF DIVIDING IT INTO THE POLICIES VERSUS THE KIND OF MORE

03:31:03.233 --> 03:31:05.233
DETAILED PIECES AND LOOKING FORWARD TO

03:31:06.233 --> 03:31:08.233
OUR PARTICIPATION IN THAT. GETTING THIS LINE BETWEEN

03:31:09.233 --> 03:31:11.233
MAKING SURE WE ARE MEETING OUR LIFE AND

03:31:14.233 --> 03:31:16.233
SAFETY GOALS AND HELPING FOLKS WHO, FOR WHATEVER REASON YOU LOOK IS PARTICULARLY
IN DISTRICT THREE. WE'VE SEEN A LOT

03:31:20.233 --> 03:31:22.233
OF REBUILT PROJECTS. A LOT OF THE RURAL AREAS.

03:31:23.233 --> 03:31:25.233
WE WILL SEE WHAT YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT, TO.
ONE OF THE THINGS FOR RESIDENTS WHO

03:31:28.233 --> 03:31:30.233
ARE NEEDING TO COME INTO COMPLIANCE, THEY ARE

03:31:33.233 --> 03:31:36.233
EXPERIENCING IT AS ONE INDIVIDUAL WITH THE COUNTY AND
NOT MAYBE SEEING THE BIGGER PICTURE ABOUT HOW THERE

03:31:39.233 --> 03:31:41.233
IS AN ORGANIZED SORT OF SCHEME TO HELP

03:31:46.233 --> 03:31:48.233
EVERYONE COMPLY.

03:31:49.233 --> 03:31:51.233
CAN FEEL TARGETED, SO HOW WE MAKE PEOPLE

03:31:52.233 --> 03:31:54.233
UNDERSTAND THAT THIS IS A BROAD SET OF POLICIES THAT WE WANT EVERYONE

03:31:55.233 --> 03:31:57.233
TO COMPLY WITH. THAT'S THE MESSAGE I

03:31:58.233 --> 03:32:00.233
WANT TO BRING TODAY. I

03:32:02.233 --> 03:32:04.233
APPRECIATE THE POINT ABOUT THE OUTREACH AND EDUCATION EFFORTS. WHETHER

03:32:07.167 --> 03:32:09.167
WE ARE TALKING ABOUT HELPING A RESIDENTIAL BUILDER GET INTO

03:32:13.167 --> 03:32:15.167
COMPLIANCE OR A WINERY OPERATION COME INTO COMPLIANCE. THE

03:32:16.167 --> 03:32:18.167
MORE PEOPLE UNDERSTAND WHAT RULES WE ARE ASKING TO

03:32:23.167 --> 03:32:26.167
BE COMPLIED WITH, THE CLEARER IT IS FOR EVERYONE. I GUESS I JUST WANT
TO SUPPORT WHAT ELSE WE CAN DO

03:32:29.167 --> 03:32:31.167
TO HELP THESE KIND OF GROUPS UNDERSTAND THE RULES THAT ARE APPLIED

03:32:32.167 --> 03:32:35.167
TO THEM. THANKS FOR BEING HERE TODAY.
>> SUPERVISOR GALLAGHER.

03:32:37.167 --> 03:32:39.167
>> HI. THANKS SO MUCH FOR THE PRESENTATION AND ALL THE HARD

03:32:40.167 --> 03:32:42.167
WORK THAT YOU AND YOUR COWORKERS DO TO DO THE

03:32:46.167 --> 03:32:48.167
HARD WORK OF CODE COMPLIANCE. A COUPLE

03:32:50.167 --> 03:32:52.167
QUESTIONS. FIRST, DO YOU HAVE A PLAN FOR HOW TO HANDLE THE BACKLOG

03:32:54.167 --> 03:32:56.167
OF CASES? IT SOUNDS REALLY OVERWHELMING AT THIS POINT. I

03:32:57.167 --> 03:32:59.167
AM SURE IT IS FOR YOU AND YOUR STAFF.

03:33:04.100 --> 03:33:06.100
TO MAKE YOUR WAY THROUGH ALL OF THOSE CASES.

03:33:07.100 --> 03:33:09.100
>> SO ONE

03:33:13.100 --> 03:33:15.100
OF THE THINGS WE HAVE DONE IN THE LAST SEVERAL MONTHS IS TO SIT

03:33:16.100 --> 03:33:18.100
DOWN WITH STAFF AND WORK OUT WITH THEM SORT

03:33:19.100 --> 03:33:21.100
OF A WORK PROGRAM FOR THAT.

03:33:27.100 --> 03:33:30.100
SO AS A CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER YOU'RE GETTING ASSIGNED CASES AS THEY
COME IN. WE REALLY NEVER KNOW HOW MANY WE ARE GOING TO GET AT ANY GIVEN

03:33:31.100 --> 03:33:34.100
TIME.
SO IT IS HOW YOU BALANCE BEING THE FIRST RESPONSE AND GETTING THOSE GOING. AND

03:33:37.100 --> 03:33:39.100
THEN YOU GET THESE CASES GOING FOR

03:33:41.100 --> 03:33:44.100
A WHILE. IT HAS BEEN PARTICULARLY ON THE BUILDING PERMIT AND, IT IS
HARD TO GET CONTRACTORS LIKE DESIGNERS

03:33:49.100 --> 03:33:51.100
AND ARCHITECTS TO SUDDENLY JUMP ON A PROJECT.

03:33:57.100 --> 03:33:59.100
WHAT HAPPENS IS IT PUSHES THESE CASES OUT.
THEY CAN TAKE SEVERAL MONTHS BEFORE WE

03:33:59.900 --> 03:34:02.600
SEE ANY SORT OF PERMIT APPLICATION.
WE ARE NOT CLOSING THEM OUT AND IT IS

03:34:05.330 --> 03:34:08.330
VERY DIFFICULT TO CLOSE THINGS OUT.
TAKES SOMETIMES A YEAR TO GET THAT

03:34:13.330 --> 03:34:15.330
BUILDING PERMIT OR RESOLVE SOME VIOLATIONS. STAFF REALLY WANTS TO

03:34:21.330 --> 03:34:23.330
CIRCLE BACK, GETTING INTO A PROGRAM OR AFTER 30 OR 60 DAYS

03:34:24.330 --> 03:34:27.330
WE ARE GOING BACK IN TOUCH IN THOSE CASES AND MAKING SURE THEY ARE BEING
PUSHED BECAUSE WHAT HAPPENS IS WE WILL SEE THE

03:34:31.330 --> 03:34:33.330
STAFF BACK OFF AND HAVE TO DO THESE OTHER THINGS. X MONTHS AGO,

03:34:38.330 --> 03:34:40.330
NOTHING HAPPENS.

03:34:41.330 --> 03:34:43.330
WITH THAT, GOING TO EVALUATE STAFFING AND

03:34:45.330 --> 03:34:47.330
MAYBE HOW TO REQUEST ADDITIONAL STAFFING TO JUSTIFY

03:34:50.330 --> 03:34:52.330
HELPING WITH THE BACKLOG A COUPLE OF THINGS WHERE

03:34:53.330 --> 03:34:55.330
WE ARE GOING BACK AND LOOKING AT CASE

03:34:55.100 --> 03:34:56.833
MANAGEMENT.
>> I WANT TO HIGHLIGHT WHAT HE ALLUDED TO. SOME OF THOSE CASES, WE

03:35:02.330 --> 03:35:04.330
HAVE THE NUMBERS THAT WE CAN GET TO. SOME OF THEM

03:35:06.967 --> 03:35:09.967
HAVE PERMIT APPLICATIONS TO RESOLVE IT.
APPLICATIONS ARE CONSIDERED RESOLVED ONCE FINAL. WHICH MEANS, ANY WORK

03:35:17.967 --> 03:35:20.967
THAT IS NEEDED TO GET THEM TO COMPLIANCE IS DONE. YOU COULD HAVE A VERY COOPERATIVE
PROPERTY OWNER WHO HAS APPLIED FOR

03:35:25.967 --> 03:35:27.967
THE PERMITS AND HAS A REQUEST FOR

03:35:29.967 --> 03:35:31.967
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION BUT JUST HAS NOT GOTTEN TO THE

03:35:34.967 --> 03:35:36.967
END THERE. THOSE ARE THE GOOD CASES THAT MIGHT SHOW UP AS PART

03:35:37.967 --> 03:35:39.967
OF THE BACKLOG. THE

03:35:41.967 --> 03:35:44.967
OTHER THING I WANTED TO MENTION WAS THAT THE ADMINISTRATIVE ABATEMENT
OPTION IS FOCUSED AND WILL HELP MOST IN THOSE

03:35:46.967 --> 03:35:48.967
CASES THAT ARE IN THE 2 TO

03:35:51.967 --> 03:35:53.967
5 YEAR RANGE WHERE IT IS HARD TO GET THE PARTY AND THE WAY THAT WE NEED

03:35:58.967 --> 03:36:00.967
THEM TO COMPLY. SO THAT THE

03:36:04.900 --> 03:36:06.900
HEARING PROCESS CAN EXPEDITE, SO THOSE ARE REALLY

03:36:10.900 --> 03:36:12.900
FOCUSED ON THOSE MIDRANGE CASES THAT WE HAVE TROUBLE GETTING TO. SO

03:36:13.900 --> 03:36:15.900
HOPEFULLY THAT, IN ADDITION TO STAFFING WILL BE A WAY

03:36:19.900 --> 03:36:21.900
OF ADDRESSING THE LONGER-TERM CASES AND REALLY WHITTLING DOWN

03:36:24.330 --> 03:36:26.330
THE BACKLOG.
>> THANK YOU.

03:36:28.900 --> 03:36:31.900
I HAVE ANOTHER QUESTION. SOMETHING THAT
YOU DID NOT GO OVER. I THINK THIS FITS WITHIN

03:36:36.900 --> 03:36:38.900
THE DISCUSSION. COMPLIANCE ISSUES THAT

03:36:40.900 --> 03:36:42.900
REALLY AFFECT THE NAPA BRAND, AND

03:36:46.900 --> 03:36:48.900
THEREFORE OUR ECONOMY. I WANT TO UNDERSTAND BETTER COMPLIANCE WITH

03:36:52.900 --> 03:36:54.900
THE 75% RULE. IF YOU COULD TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THAT. I KNOW

03:36:55.600 --> 03:36:58.200
IT IS NOT A LIFE AND SAFETY ISSUE.
I THINK IT IS SOMETHING THAT IN PARTICULAR NEEDS

03:37:01.900 --> 03:37:03.900
TO BE PROACTIVE DEEPLY AND FORCED --AND FORCED, RATHER THAN

03:37:10.833 --> 03:37:12.833
COMPLAINT DRIVEN.

03:37:13.833 --> 03:37:15.833
>> THERE REALLY HAS NOT BEEN AN

03:37:18.833 --> 03:37:20.833
ACTIVE PROCESS FOR THAT. A NUMBER OF YEARS AGO USED TO DO AUDITS WITH THE

03:37:23.833 --> 03:37:25.833
DIFFERENT USE PERMITS.

03:37:56.833 --> 03:37:58.833
AND AS A RESULT OF THAT, I THINK WE HAD A REPORT COME OUT FROM WHAT WAS

03:37:59.833 --> 03:38:01.833
IT, THE AIPAC 2017, 2018

03:38:07.767 --> 03:38:10.767
, I CAN'T SAY WHAT IT WAS. WITH APRIL HOST
WE ACTUALLY DO A BROADER PROGRAM , LIKE AN AUDIT.

03:38:14.767 --> 03:38:16.767
AND FOR THE SELF REPORTING PROGRAM , AND ANNUALLY

03:38:20.767 --> 03:38:22.767
UPLOAD OF YOUR DATA ,

03:38:24.767 --> 03:38:26.767
WHICH ARE TT FORMS, WHICH THEY FILE WHICH WOULD BE HELD CONFIDENTIAL.

03:38:29.767 --> 03:38:31.767
AND THEY WOULD UPLOAD THIS INFORMATION AND THEN WE
WOULD CROSS REFERENCE THAT WITH OUR DATABASE AND OUR GIS UNIT AND BE ABLE

03:38:32.767 --> 03:38:34.767
TO COME OUT WITH THE SORT OF COMPLIANCE THAT WE HAD,

03:38:38.767 --> 03:38:40.767
SO THAT WOULD BE A VERY PROACTIVE PROGRAM. COVID HIT, FIRES HIT AND

03:38:41.767 --> 03:38:43.767
IT DIDN'T GET IMPLEMENTED. SO IT IS SOMETHING WE COULD GO DOWN THE

03:38:47.767 --> 03:38:49.767
ROAD, WE HAD A COMPANY THAT YOU WOULD SIMPLY GO ON AND LOGON AND WE WOULD HAVE

03:38:53.767 --> 03:38:55.767
ONE OF THE WINERY MANAGERS AND HAVE THEM DESIGNATE THIS INFORMATION AND WE

03:38:56.767 --> 03:38:58.767
WOULD JUST CHECK THAT AGAINST THEIR USE PERMIT

03:39:05.700 --> 03:39:07.700
CONDITIONS ARE AND GO FROM THERE.
SO, IF THERE WAS A VIOLATION WE WOULD FOLLOW THROUGH.

03:39:08.700 --> 03:39:10.700
>> LOTS OF SELF REPORTING, WAS THE SUGGESTED

03:39:14.700 --> 03:39:16.700
, BACK IN 2017.

03:39:17.700 --> 03:39:19.700
>> OKAY I JUST THINK WOULD BE GREAT FOR

03:39:20.700 --> 03:39:22.700
FUTURE DISCUSSION. THANK YOU.

03:39:26.700 --> 03:39:28.700
SUPERVISOR ?

03:39:29.700 --> 03:39:31.700
>> THANK YOU, CHAIR AND YOU ALL HAVE TOUGH JOBS.

03:39:33.700 --> 03:39:36.700
AND, JUST IT'S APPRECIATED, YOU GET PUT IN SOME TOUGH SITUATIONS BUT YOU ARE
TRYING TO DO

03:39:43.700 --> 03:39:45.700
THE RIGHT THING AND THAT'S BRING PEOPLE INTO COMPLIANCE. THE ONE AREA I HAVE LEARNED DURING THE FIRE
THE DISCREPANCY BETWEEN WHAT IS ON OUR PROPERTY TAX ROLLS

03:39:47.700 --> 03:39:49.700
AND WHAT PEOPLE BELIEVE IS PERMITTED, I THINK

03:39:50.700 --> 03:39:52.700
THAT IS AN ONGOING ISSUE THAT WE HAVEN'T BEEN ABLE TO RECTIFY AND

03:39:53.700 --> 03:39:55.700
IT CAME TO LIGHT WHEN FOLKS WERE LIVING AND PAYING

03:39:56.700 --> 03:39:58.700
PROPER TAXES ON A PROPERTY THAT IS 5000 SQUARE FEET

03:39:59.700 --> 03:40:01.700
THEY CAME TO REBUILD THE COUNTY SAYS 2000 SQUARE FEET. I

03:40:04.633 --> 03:40:06.633
DON'T SEE THAT AS SOMEONE DOING THAT TO CONTINUE

03:40:09.633 --> 03:40:12.633
INTENSELY OUT OF COMPLIANCE. BUT THAT'S GOOD TO BE AN AREA OF FOCUS. ANOTHER
ONE IS, WHEN PEOPLE BUY PROPERTY AND THEY

03:40:17.633 --> 03:40:19.633
UNCOVER SOMETHING THAT WAS DONE WITH THAT PERMIT

03:40:20.633 --> 03:40:23.633
AFTER THEY BUY.
AND I STILL HAVE CHALLENGES WITH THOSE, BECAUSE IT IS NOT SOMEONE

03:40:24.633 --> 03:40:26.633
THAT INTENTIONALLY GUNS SOMETHING IT SHOULD'VE COME UP DURING THE

03:40:29.633 --> 03:40:31.633
DUE DILIGENCE.

03:40:32.633 --> 03:40:34.633
AND WE ARE TRYING TO RETROACTIVE WE SAY

03:40:35.633 --> 03:40:37.633
WE WILL GO TALK TO THE RETAILER , AND ENGAGE IN LITIGATION. BUT

03:40:41.633 --> 03:40:43.633
THAT DOESN'T GO ANYWHERE. WHETHER IT'S WORKING WITH

03:40:44.633 --> 03:40:46.633
THE RETAILERS OR SOME TYPE OF DISCLOSURE , THOSE TWO CATEGORIES

03:40:50.633 --> 03:40:52.633
ARE SEPARATE FROM SOMEONE BUILDING SOMETHING INTENSELY KNOWING THEY HAVE TO GET A PERMIT.

03:40:58.633 --> 03:41:01.633
THAT'S A DIFFERENT CATEGORY THAN WHAT WE ARE SEEING. SO I STILL THINK THAT'S A
DIFFERENT AREA THAT I WOULD LIKE TO EXPLORE MORE ON TO ENSURE THAT WE ARE NOT TRANSFERRING A

03:41:02.633 --> 03:41:04.633
PROBLEM TO SOMEONE ELSE THAT WAS NOT

03:41:07.633 --> 03:41:10.633
PART OF CREATING THAT PROBLEM. SO I DON'T KNOW IF YOU HAVE ANY COMMENTS ON
THOSE.
>> I CAN SAY IT'S BUYER BEWARE KIND OF ISSUE.

03:41:14.633 --> 03:41:16.633
IT IS HARD, I REALLY WISH THERE WAS MORE DUE DILIGENCE DONE

03:41:19.633 --> 03:41:21.633
ON THE FRONT OF THE PROPERTY PURCHASE WITH THE REALTOR

03:41:23.633 --> 03:41:26.633
, COME IN. THE INFORMATION IS HERE, YOU CAN
FIND OUT IF THAT BUILDING WAS PERMITTED OR NOT.

03:41:29.633 --> 03:41:31.633
PRIOR TO THE PURCHASE, AND SO, YOU KNOW,

03:41:35.633 --> 03:41:37.633
I THINK I BROUGHT THIS UP BEFORE, I CAME FROM

03:41:41.633 --> 03:41:43.633
NEVADA WHO HAD A RESALE PROGRAM. AND SO WHEN YOU
TRANSACTED A HOME THERE, YOU WENT INTO THE CITY AND HAD A

03:41:47.633 --> 03:41:49.633
REPORT DONE ON YOUR PROPERTY , OR ON THE PROPERTY SO THAT YOU WOULD

03:41:59.633 --> 03:42:01.633
THEN HAVE TO DISCLOSE THIS REPORT. IN THE CITY WOULD
JUST CHECK FOR PERMITS TO MAKE SURE EVERYTHING WAS PERMITTED AND THEY

03:42:03.567 --> 03:42:05.567
THAT WERE DISCOVERED, THEY HAD BEEN DOING IT FOR YEAR AT US.

03:42:08.567 --> 03:42:10.567
THE ONE THING I LOVED ABOUT IT WAS, IT KEPT THE HOUSING STOCK

03:42:11.567 --> 03:42:14.567
THEY'RE VERY HEALTHY.
BECAUSE, AS THOSE HOT PROPERTIES TURNED OVER, WE WERE MAKING SURE THAT THOSE WERE

03:42:17.567 --> 03:42:19.567
SAFE BUILDINGS, SO , I DON'T KNOW IF THAT IS SOMETHING

03:42:23.567 --> 03:42:25.567
, THAT THE BOARD WOULD CONSIDER. BUT THAT IS ONE PROGRAM THAT WE DIDN'T HAVE A

03:42:26.567 --> 03:42:28.567
PROBLEM AT ALL WITH PEOPLE COMING IN AND GOING, GEE I

03:42:35.567 --> 03:42:38.567
BOUGHT THIS AND I DID KNOW WAS PERMITTED, IT WAS ALWAYS PUT ON THE
TABLE AT THE TIME THEY WERE TRANSACTION THE BUILDING. AND THEN THERE IS

03:42:40.567 --> 03:42:42.567
ALSO THIS, WE CAN WORK WITH MAYBE A PROGRAM THAT

03:42:44.567 --> 03:42:46.567
WE REALIZE THAT THESE THINGS ARE HAPPENING TO

03:42:47.567 --> 03:42:49.567
FOLKS AND THAT'S ALWAYS A POSSIBILITY. YOU KNOW,

03:42:53.567 --> 03:42:55.567
WE ARE BASICALLY RIGHT NOW WE ARE FOLLOWING THE BUILDING
CODES, AND THIS COMMENCED WITHOUT A BUILDING

03:43:01.567 --> 03:43:03.567
PERMIT AND HAVING THESE FINES AND EVERYTHING. BUT THAT FOR SOME FLEXIBILITY FOR THOSE?

03:43:05.500 --> 03:43:07.500
>> WHAT WE NEED TO BE CAREFUL OF IS THAT

03:43:09.500 --> 03:43:11.500
WE ARE NOT

03:43:15.500 --> 03:43:18.500
PUT IN A POSITION WHERE WE HAVE TO TRACK ALL THE TRANSACTIONS IN THE
COUNTY. WHICH, WE HAVE STAFFING ISSUES ALREADY, BUT THE RESALE THING IS MORE ON,

03:43:24.500 --> 03:43:26.500
IT'S AN OBLIGATION OF BUYER OR SELLER IN THAT PROCESS AND

03:43:27.500 --> 03:43:29.500
NOT THE COUNTY TRACKING THOSE. AND IN THAT CASE,

03:43:30.500 --> 03:43:32.500
WE WOULD STILL WANT TO CONSIDER

03:43:35.500 --> 03:43:37.500
WHAT SORT OF LIABILITY THE COUNTY MIGHT HAVE IF WE DON'T, IF

03:43:39.500 --> 03:43:42.500
WE MISS SOMETHING IN THAT PROCESS. THAT IS A DISCUSSION
IF SOMETHING LIKE THAT COMES FORWARD.

03:43:45.500 --> 03:43:47.500
THE CIVIL CODE PROVIDES THAT THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY, EVEN IF

03:43:50.500 --> 03:43:53.500
THEY BOUGHT THE PROPERTY WITH THE VIOLATION,
THEY HAVE THE LEGAL RESPONSIBILITY FOR ABATING THE NEW

03:43:57.500 --> 03:43:59.500
CENSUS, SO WE HAVE , WE HAVE TO FOLLOW THROUGH TO ABATE,

03:44:03.433 --> 03:44:05.433
TO BRING THEM INTO COMPLIANCE SOMEHOW.

03:44:06.433 --> 03:44:08.433
THE QUESTION THAT, THE KIND OF SECONDARY QUESTION IS

03:44:11.433 --> 03:44:13.433
WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR PAYING FOR THAT,

03:44:14.433 --> 03:44:16.433
OR PAYING FINES AND FEES AND THAT SHIFTS INTO A

03:44:17.433 --> 03:44:19.433
SITUATION WHERE WE ARE ACTING AS AN ARBITER

03:44:21.433 --> 03:44:23.433
BETWEEN PARTIES. THERE IS LOT OF AREAS TO LOOK AT

03:44:28.433 --> 03:44:31.433
IN ADDRESSING THAT QUESTION. BUT IT IS CERTAINLY AN AREA THAT WE CAN EXPLORE.
YOUR FIRST POINT ABOUT

03:44:35.433 --> 03:44:37.433
ASSESSMENT RECORDS, THAT IS ANOTHER AREA WHERE THE ASSESSOR TAXES

03:44:40.433 --> 03:44:42.433
BASED ON WHAT IS THERE, REGARDLESS OF WHETHER IT IS PERMITTED OR

03:44:45.433 --> 03:44:47.433
NOT. SO, THEY, AND I CALL IT THE AL CAPONE RULE.

03:44:48.433 --> 03:44:50.433
>> THIS IS A SORE SUBJECT.

03:44:51.433 --> 03:44:53.433
>> CALL IT THE AL CAPONE RULE,

03:45:00.433 --> 03:45:02.433
THE TAXES ARE WHAT IS GOING TO GET YOU.
>> BUT WE HAVE HAD THE BENEFIT OF TIME AND WE ARE ASKING PEOPLE

03:45:03.367 --> 03:45:05.367
TO REBUILD SOMETHING THEY DIDN'T.

03:45:06.367 --> 03:45:08.367
WE DIDN'T START THE FIRE I THINK IT'S HUGELY UNFAIR AND WE SHOULD

03:45:09.367 --> 03:45:11.367
REFUND PEOPLE'S PROPERTY TAXES.

03:45:15.367 --> 03:45:18.367
I JUST DON'T WANT TO GO DOWN THAT ROAD, BECAUSE
WE'VE LOST A LOT OF HOMES IN THE FLYERS AND IT WAS VERY UNFORTUNATE

03:45:21.367 --> 03:45:23.367
FOR PEOPLE WHO HAD TO REBUILD NOT TO GET THE BENEFIT THAT THEY WERE PAYING TAXES

03:45:27.367 --> 03:45:30.367
ON. SO, I'M JUST GOING TO IN THAT AT THAT POINT.
>> WE DON'T HAVE TO GET INTO IT, BUT THE BUILDING PERMIT RECORDS

03:45:33.367 --> 03:45:35.367
ARE WHAT DETERMINES AND DEFINES WHAT AN ENTITLEMENT IS FOR

03:45:42.367 --> 03:45:44.367
OUR CODE. THE TAX RECORDS MIGHT BE EVIDENCE OF THAT,

03:45:48.367 --> 03:45:50.367
BUT THE BUILDING CODE RECORDS IS WHERE THAT INFORMATION IS.

03:45:53.367 --> 03:45:56.367
>> I THINK THE CHALLENGE IS WHEN
A CONSTITUENT COMES TO THE COUNTY, THEY

03:45:58.367 --> 03:46:01.367
DON'T --THEY LOOK AT BOTH OF US AS THE COUNTY.
SO WHEN THEY SAY THERE IS ONE

03:46:05.300 --> 03:46:08.300
DIVISION WHETHER INDEPENDENTLY OR NOT, THEY LOOK AT
US AS A COUNTY. AND THEY ARE SAYING THIS GROUP HAS A DIFFERENT ASSESSMENT,

03:46:09.300 --> 03:46:11.300
DIFFERENT SIZE, AND THIS GROUP YOU'RE NOT

03:46:12.300 --> 03:46:14.300
TALKING TO EACH OTHER.
THAT'S AN INTERNAL ISSUE, NOT FOR THE PUBLIC, I THINK THAT'S ANOTHER

03:46:15.300 --> 03:46:17.300
AREA THAT WE SHOULD SPEND SOME ADDITIONAL TIME ON TRYING TO

03:46:18.300 --> 03:46:20.300
RECTIFY FOR THE BENEFIT OF THAT RESIDENT THAT'S ALL, BUT I APPRECIATE

03:46:21.300 --> 03:46:23.300
YOUR EXPLAINING IT AND WE HAVE DEALT WITH

03:46:24.300 --> 03:46:26.300
THE ALLOTTED 2017 , AND 2019, 2020. THANK YOU FOR THOSE

03:46:31.233 --> 03:46:33.600
QUESTIONS.
>> SUPERVISOR

03:46:33.600 --> 03:46:35.200
COTTRELL?
>> JUST TO FOLLOW UP ON SUPERVISOR TRENT EIGHT POINT COME

03:46:39.300 --> 03:46:41.300
I THINK THERE A LOT OF PEOPLE WHO COME IN

03:46:42.300 --> 03:46:44.300
AS SUBSEQUENT PROPERTY OWNERS ON PROPERTY CONSTRUCTION, I THINK ONE

03:46:45.300 --> 03:46:47.300
OF THE QUESTIONS AND OPPORTUNITIES IS TO JUST

03:46:48.300 --> 03:46:50.300
HELP PEOPLE UNDERSTAND WITH THE COUNTY POLICY IS.

03:46:51.300 --> 03:46:53.300
IT IS AS THINGS COME IN AS YOU WERE SAYING, LARGELY BASED

03:46:54.300 --> 03:46:56.300
ON COMPLAINT , SO

03:47:00.300 --> 03:47:02.300
JUST THAT PEOPLE HAVE MORE CLARITY SO THEY DON'T FEEL SO

03:47:03.233 --> 03:47:05.233
IS THERE . I THINK THE OTHER THING THAT I HAVE HEARD THINGS

03:47:07.233 --> 03:47:09.233
ABOUT OUR I SUBMITTED SOMETHING, GOT IT BACK FOR RESUBMITTAL ,

03:47:12.233 --> 03:47:14.233
I SUBMITTED IT IT AGAIN AND THEN THERE WERE OTHER CHANGES.

03:47:15.233 --> 03:47:17.233
SO, HOW WE CAN KIND OF MAKE SURE THAT WE ARE GIVING ALL

03:47:18.233 --> 03:47:20.233
THE -- AND EVERYONE NEEDS A SECOND READ

03:47:24.233 --> 03:47:26.233
SOMETIMES, BUT SOMETIMES HOW WE DO THAT PEOPLE DON'T FILE OR

03:47:27.233 --> 03:47:29.233
JUST IN THE CIRCULAR SUBMITTAL CYCLE. AND THEN I JUST WANTED

03:47:30.233 --> 03:47:32.233
TO SHARE YOU KNOW, I APPRECIATE WHAT SUPERVISOR

03:47:33.233 --> 03:47:35.233
GALLAGHER WAS SAYING TO GO IN TERMS OF THE USE PERMITS.

03:47:37.233 --> 03:47:39.233
I REMEMBER GOING DOOR-TO-DOOR AND TALKING TO

03:47:41.233 --> 03:47:43.233
A VINTNER IN NORTH NAPA WHO SAID TO ME AT

03:47:44.233 --> 03:47:46.233
BUGS ME WHEN I FEEL LIKE I'M FOLLOWING THE RULES

03:47:52.233 --> 03:47:55.233
AND OTHER PEOPLE OUT THERE AREN'T. AND I THINK THAT IS KIND OF A GOOD LESSON TO
KEEP IN MIND, THAT IS THE REASON TO DO A LOT THIS

03:47:56.233 --> 03:47:58.233
OUTREACHING TO HELP PEOPLE UNDERSTAND, OR MOST PEOPLE
COMPLYING? WELL, LET'S MAKE THAT KNOWN, TOO. DO SOMETHING TO

03:48:03.167 --> 03:48:05.167
SHARE. THANKS.

03:48:09.167 --> 03:48:11.167
>> I WILL ADD TO THAT, I THINK THAT IS AN INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT PART

03:48:12.167 --> 03:48:14.167
OF COMPLIANCE , COMPLIANCE ISN'T

03:48:20.167 --> 03:48:22.167
--IT SHOULDN'T BE FOCUSED ON THE BAD ACTORS . COMPLIANCE IS

03:48:24.167 --> 03:48:26.167
ABOUT INTEGRITY WITH THE RULES THAT WE

03:48:27.167 --> 03:48:29.167
HAVE ESTABLISHED AN CONFIDENCE THAT THE MAJORITY

03:48:32.167 --> 03:48:34.167
OF PEOPLE ARE, IN FACT FOLLOWING THE RULES.

03:48:36.167 --> 03:48:38.167
AND BASED UPON THE EMAIL I I GET, I UNDERSTAND THERE

03:48:42.167 --> 03:48:45.167
IS A HEFTY AMOUNT OF PEOPLE THAT ARE NOT FOLLOWING
THE RULES [ESPECIALLY IN A PORTION OF MY DISTRICT. BUT I THINK

03:48:48.167 --> 03:48:50.167
THAT BEING ABLE TO GET , TO TAKE THIS TIME TO

03:48:54.167 --> 03:48:56.167
REALLY SOLIDIFY WHAT OUR INTENT IS IN COMPLIANCE , I DON'T

03:49:00.167 --> 03:49:02.167
, BY ANY MEANS SEE ," AS MUCH AS, HOW CAN WE SAY WITH

03:49:11.100 --> 03:49:14.100
CONFIDENCE WITH SOMEONE SAYING TO US, I DON'T THINK OTHERS ARE FOLLOWING
THE RULES. WE DON'T HAVE THAT DATA TO BE ABLE TO SAY YES,

03:49:18.100 --> 03:49:20.100
THEY ARE. AND HERE'S OUR CONFIDENCE PERCENTAGE, RIGHT? WHETHER OR

03:49:25.100 --> 03:49:27.100
NOT IT'S A 90% CONFIDENCE THAT PEOPLE ARE COMPLYING WITH THEIR USE PERMITS.

03:49:30.100 --> 03:49:32.100
AND WE HAVE BEEN ABLE TO MASTER THIS YOU KNOW, MY HAT IS OFF TO YOU AND

03:49:36.100 --> 03:49:38.100
TRYING TO MANAGE THAT TYPE OF A BACKLOG, BUT TO BE

03:49:39.100 --> 03:49:41.100
ABLE TO , WE HAVE A PATH ON

03:49:46.100 --> 03:49:49.100
NOT JUST HOW WE ARE PRIORITIZING THESE CODE COMPLIANCE CASES, BUT ALSO HOW
WE ARE DISPOSING OF THEM. AND MAKING SURE

03:49:51.100 --> 03:49:53.100
THAT IT IS COMMON DOESN'T FEEL TARGETED I THINK, SOMETIMES IT

03:49:54.100 --> 03:49:56.100
JUST DOES FEEL TARGETED. I THINK OTHER TIMES

03:50:00.100 --> 03:50:02.100
THE VARIOUS GEOGRAPHICAL ISSUES

03:50:12.330 --> 03:50:15.330
THAT AND TOPOGRAPHY ISSUES THAT ARE ON CERTAIN PROPERTIES ACTUALLY
COMPLICATE THAT, BECAUSE WE END UP WITH OTHER

03:50:17.330 --> 03:50:19.330
JURISDICTIONAL AGENCIES INVOLVED.
AND SO I THINK REALLY LOOKING AT HOW WE

03:50:21.330 --> 03:50:23.330
CAN DO A BETTER JOB OF EDUCATING WHO MIGHT

03:50:24.330 --> 03:50:26.330
BE INVOLVED , THAT IT IS NOT ALWAYS THE COUNTY, I THINK

03:50:30.330 --> 03:50:33.330
THAT THAT COULD REALLY HELP US, WE WOULD
DEFINITELY BENEFIT , AND THIS IS JUST A YEAR AND

03:50:36.330 --> 03:50:38.330
SUMMARY. I THINK WE WOULD BENEFIT BEING

03:50:40.330 --> 03:50:42.330
ABLE TO HAVE A MORE ROPE BUST DISCUSSION OF HOW

03:50:46.330 --> 03:50:48.330
WE WANT THIS OUTREACH AND THIS PROGRAM

03:50:52.330 --> 03:50:54.330
TO LOOK. AND I THINK PART OF IT ALSO YOU

03:50:58.330 --> 03:51:00.330
KNOW, REALLY MAYBE, EVEN STARTS IN FACT WITH THE

03:51:06.330 --> 03:51:08.330
NAME OF WHAT OUR OBJECTIVE IS, BECAUSE COMPLIANCE IS A REALLY
UNFORTUNATELY AND VERY NEGATIVE TONE TO IT, AND OUR COMMUNITY.

03:51:12.330 --> 03:51:14.330
AND SO, I JUST LEAVE THAT AS A THOUGHT OUT THERE.

03:51:16.330 --> 03:51:18.330
SO WE ARE GOING OPEN PUBLIC COMMENT ON

03:51:22.330 --> 03:51:24.330
THIS ITEM.
SEEING NONE OF THE BOARD ROOM I'M GOING TO GO TO THE PHONE LINES.

03:51:28.330 --> 03:51:30.330
NO ONE IS ON THE LINE. I AM GOING TO CLOSE PUBLIC

03:51:31.330 --> 03:51:33.330
COMMENTS AND WE , I THINK WE HAVE GIVEN COMMENTS THAT

03:51:34.330 --> 03:51:36.330
YOU ACTUALLY DIDN'T ELICIT AREA AND WE HAVE RECEIVED

03:51:39.330 --> 03:51:41.330
YOUR REPORT , AND WE THANK YOU FOR THIS YEAR

03:51:43.330 --> 03:51:45.330
AND REPORT .
AND HOPEFULLY, YOU HAVE HEARD ENOUGH THAT I THINK

03:51:47.330 --> 03:51:49.330
MOORE SHOULD COME FROM THIS ON HOW WE CAN

03:51:52.330 --> 03:51:54.330
CONTINUOUSLY IMPROVE OUR PROGRAM OBJECTIVES. THANK YOU.

03:51:55.330 --> 03:51:57.330
>> THANK YOU.

03:51:58.330 --> 03:52:00.330
>> THANK YOU.

03:52:04.967 --> 03:52:06.967
>> OKAY. THAT ACTUALLY CONCLUDES OUR BUSINESS OF THE DAY.

03:52:10.200 --> 03:52:12.200
FOR OUR SECOND TO LAST MEETING

03:52:14.100 --> 03:52:16.100
, OF THE CALENDAR YEAR, SO WE WILL NOW ADJOURN TO THE NEXT REGULAR MEETING

03:52:20.633 --> 03:52:22.633
OF THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS, THE LAST MEETING OF THE

03:52:23.467 --> 03:52:25.467
YEAR, TUESDAY, DECEMBER 19 AT 9:00 A.M.

03:52:27.100 --> 03:52:29.100
WE ARE ADJOURNED.